Vacation Rentals By Owner In Bay Shore, NY

Memories are waiting to be made at this lovely 3-bedroom, 1-bathroom Bay Shore vacation rental. The delightful apartment offers a well-stocked kitchen, inviting furnishings, 4 Smart TVs, a shared, fenced backyard, and even an additional vacation rental on-site for larger groups. Explore the hiking trails in Edgewood Oak Brush Plains Preserve, share laughs at Schmitt’s Family Farm, or learn about the history of the gilded age at the Museum of American Armor.brbr-- THE PROPERTY --brbrModern, Inviting Furnishings | Smart TV in Each Bedroom | Free Shared WiFi (880-940 Mbps) brbrBedroom 1: King Bed | Bedroom 2: Queen Bed | Bedroom 3: Queen BedbrbrSHARED AMENITIES: Fenced backyard, washer & dryer (accessed via yard)brINDOOR LIVING: 4 Smart TVs w/ cable & Netflix, 3 laptop-friendly workspaces, 1,250 sq ftbrKITCHEN: Dishwasher, fridge, oven, 4-burner stovetop, microwave, blender, drip coffee maker, toaster, cooking basics, dishware & flatware, ice maker, water filterbrGENERAL: Central heating & A/C, linens/towels, complimentary toiletries, iron/board, hair dryer, hangers, trash bags & paper towelsbrFAQ: Stairs required for access, 4 exterior security cameras (facing out)brPARKING: Driveway (2 vehicles, tandem parked)brADDT’L ACCOMMODATIONS: An additional 1-bedroom property for 4 guests is available on-site with a separate nightly rate. If you would like to reserve both rentals, please inquire for more information prior to bookingbrbr-- THE LOCATION --brbrHOT SPOTS: The Himes Museum of Motor Racing Nostalgia (4 miles), Seatuck Environmental Association (5 miles), American Airpower Museum (11 miles), Museum of American Armor (14 miles), Fire Island Lighthouse (14 miles)brESCAPE TO NATURE: Edgewood Oak Brush Plains Preserve (4 miles), Shipwreck Cove Spray Park (5 miles), Islip Beach (6 miles), Hoyt Farm Nature Preserve (7 miles), Sweet Briar Nature Center (11 miles), Waltess Estates Park (13 miles), Raynor Beach County Park (13 miles)brFUN FOR THE WHOLE FAMILY: Tanger Outlets Deer Park (3 miles), Xplore Commack (4 miles), Monster Mini Golf (4 miles), The Adventure Park at Long Island (8 miles), Schmitt's Family Farm (11 miles), Adventureland (13 miles)brAIRPORTS: John F. Kennedy International Airport (33 miles), LaGuardia Airport (38 miles)brbr-- REST EASY WITH US --brbrEvolve makes it easy to find and book properties you'll never want to leave. You can relax knowing that our properties will always be ready for you and that we'll answer the phone 24/7. Even better, if anything is off about your stay, we'll make it right. You can count on our homes and our people to make you feel welcome — because we know what vacation means to you.brbr-- POLICIES --brbr- No smokingbr- No pets allowedbr- No events, parties, or large gatheringsbr- Additional fees and taxes may applybr- Photo ID may be required upon check-inbr- NOTE: The property requires stairs for accessbr- NOTE: There is another bookable vacation rental on-site; the laundry room, WiFi connection, and outdoor amenities are shared with this unit and other travelers may be present during your staybr- NOTE: The garage and shed are not available for guest usebr- NOTE: Your safety matters. This property features 4 exterior security cameras: 2 cameras are located on the front door and garage facing the front outdoor entry, 1 is on the side door facing the basement outdoor entry, and 1 is on the right side of the yard facing the yard gate entrance and the street. The cameras are outward facing and do not look into interior spaces. The cameras record video and sound when activated by motion and will be on during the duration of your stay

Bay Shore Vacation Rental w/ Shared Yard!

Bay Shore, New York, United States

Bed

Bath

Sleeps

Exceptional(1)

$1097.52

Get ready to relax in this 5-bedroom house in Bay Shore. The space offers three bathrooms, making it easy for guests to refresh and recharge. Whether you’re cooling off with the AC or staying cozy with heating, comfort is always within reach. The house also features a fitness room, perfect for guests who like to keep active while away. With a serene atmosphere and excellent layout, this home invites you to unwind and enjoy your stay. It’s easy to see why you’ll feel right at home here.

Spacious 5-bedroom house with AC in amazing Bay Shore

Bay Shore, New York, United States

Bed

Bath

Sleeps

Exceptional(2)

$194.73

Great South Bay area within a short distance of the water taxi to Fire Island and a buzzing restaurant district on Main St. Also close to Southside University Hospital, Good Samaritan Hospital and Turo Medical College. Come and have a good night's sleep at my place that's cozy with modern glam touches. Ideal for medical traveling professionals. This is a private townhouse with a huge backyard that includes a firepit, grill and seating area. Three spacious bedrooms with lounging areas. Unit does not have a living room space (3bdrm's that sleeps 6), two and a half bathrooms, full kitchen with spices, pots/pans, coffee brewing station, tea kittle, microwave and airfryer to make your own meals if desired. Also experience a day of shopping at The Tanger Outlets in Deer Park which is ten minutes away with seasonal ice skating, farmers market or taking in a movie is enjoyable. Close to all ocean beaches and state parks, cedar beach, Captree, Robert mosses, Sunken Meadow, Jones Beach to name a few. Absolutely no parties or large gathering are allowed in respect of my neighbors peaceful, quiet enjoyment. PLEASE DO NOT move furniture around the house!br

South Shore Long Term Stays

Bay Shore, New York, United States

Bed

Bath

Sleeps

Select Dates for Price

This gorgeous 2 bedroom exceptional lounge rental is surrounded by many conveniences. The recently updated rental is a 2min drive to Main st where there are many wonderful restaurants to explore. In addition to main st the bayshore marine is a 7min drive where you can catch the ferry to fire island, and a 5min drive to the shopping mall. With this rental you will be able to experience all of what Long Island has to offer. Located in the center of L.I. 20min drive to Top Golf/ 10.2 mi. Jake's 58.

Beach theme bnb

Bay Shore, New York, United States

Bed

Bath

Sleeps

Exceptional(7)

$274.55

This Bay Shore apartment boasts 1 inviting bedroom with a cozy king bed. The peaceful ambiance of the living room, complete with a cool sofa bed, is perfect for unwinding after a day of exploring. Guests can relax in the jetted bathtub or adjust the heating and AC to their liking. Near Fire Island Ferry, marina, fishing charters, beaches, and Main Street dining. Fully equipped kitchenette and two TVs. Quiet neighborhood with private entrance and driveway parking. Enjoy your time in Bay Shore at our marvelous apartment. Please note: This is a completely private apartment that is attached to the main house, but it has its own separate entrance, private bathroom, living room, kitchenette, and dedicated parking in the driveway.brNothing is shared with the main house — the only point of connection is that one wall (by the kitchenette) is shared with the main home.brThis is not a full-house rental — it is a private, self-contained apartment.

Comfort Suite in charming Bay Shore

Bay Shore, New York, United States

Bed

Bath

Sleeps

Exceptional(13)

$1023.4

Welcome to The Crazy Coconut!brbrOur fully air conditioned home features bayfront views and is 2nd from the bay and a 3 minute walk to the ocean. This house have 4 bedrooms and 3 newly renovated full baths as well as two outdoor showers. Two bedrooms have a bathroom ensuite, one with a private entrance. Each bedroom is equipped with air conditioning. This home features a wrap around deck with plenty of waterview seating. Within steps from both ocean and bay, there is plenty to do for all ages. Escape to paradise, you will not regret this trip. Fire Island is a car-less island. Ferrys and water taxis are available to get you where you need to go. brBoth bay and ocean beaches are lifeguarded in season. brbr3 minute walk to beach!brbr7 night minimums for July and August (Friday to Friday) br3 night stays in May/June/Sept/Oct

Fire Island Beach House - Atlantique

Bay Shore, New York, United States

Bed

Bath

Sleeps

Exceptional(2)

Select Dates for Price

Cottage

Fair Harbor Fire island

Bay Shore, New York, United States

Our cozy cottage is waiting for you! June onlybrNewly Renovated new kitchen 3 bedrooms 2 baths outdoor shower. Large deck 700 feet to the ocean. Beach chairs, 5 bikes, bbq, brDog friendly after approval 3 night min

Bed

Bath

Sleeps

$304.67

Situated right on the corner of Main Street and only steps away from the Bayshore train station and Fire Island ferries! This apartment is the perfect place to come relax and enjoy the heart of Bayshore. The high ceilings make this studio apartment feel spacious and modern. There are restaurants and an amazing night life right on Main street once you walk out of the building! There is parking in the back parking lot in un-numbered spots and enjoy the luxury of having everything all around the apartment!

Chic on Main Street apartment near it all!

Bay Shore, New York, United States

Bath

Sleeps

$831.68

Nestled in Bay Shore, this lovely house offers plenty of space with five comfortable bedrooms and three bathrooms. Guests can relax in a bright, inviting environment where heating and air conditioning keep the temperature just right. Whether you’re freshening up with the hair dryer or ironing your favorite outfit, the house has you covered. The layout encourages both restful nights and lively gatherings. We hope you'll enjoy your stay at our house and make wonderful memories here.

Spacious 5-bedroom house in fantastic Bay Shore with AC

Bay Shore, New York, United States

Bed

Bath

Sleeps

Exceptional(7)

$936.26

It’s allll about the view!! Enjoy sunsets from your deck overlooking the great South Bay!!! brBright and Airy Upside-down Home. 4 Bedrooms, 2 bathrooms plus an outdoor shower, Sleeps 8.brbr4 TV's with satellite, internet, full kitchen, washer/dryer. Beautiful views of the bay, large deck with 2 tables with seating for 10 plus 2 chaise lounge chairs with cushions and 3 umbrellas, widows peak with views of bay and ocean. Air conditioning/heat in great room, gas bbq grill.brbr1 Queen Bed and 6 Twin Beds. Air Conditioning (and heat) in 3 bedrooms.

Fire Island Beach House

Bay Shore, New York, United States

Bed

Bath

Sleeps

$164.9

Welcome to this cozy studio just a few minutes from the beach, dining, shopping, Fire Island ferries and local hospitals. Perfect for solo travelers or couples, the space includes a private entrance, comfy queen bed, kitchenette(No stove or cooktop), microwave, small fridge, coffeemaker, clean private bathroom, WiFi, and free parking. Enjoy a peaceful stay in a convenient location close to everything you need. Whether you're here to explore, work, or relax, this studio is the perfect home base. Book your stay today

Charming Studio Close to Everything!

Bay Shore, New York, United States

Bed

Bath

Sleeps

Exceptional(19)

$156.15

Garden apartment with large master bedroom and walk-in closet, bathroom, kitchen, and living room. The apartment is 3.5 miles to South Shore University Hospital, 6 miles to Good Samaritan Hospital, 9 miles to Suffolk Community College Grant Campus, 5.3 miles to Touro College of Health Science, 3.8 miles to Fire Island Ferries, 14 miles to Sayville Fire Island Ferries, 3.6 miles Tanger outlet mall, and 3.4 miles to Main Street shopping, entertainment, restaurants.

Bay Shore Condo Close to Outdoor Sports & Institutes!

Bay Shore, New York, United States

Bed

Bath

Sleeps

Exceptional(1)

$293.27

Discover this wonderful 2-bedroom gem in Bay Shore NY. Sitting on a small micro farm, this property is very unique to the area. Wake up to the crow of roosters in the morning. Beautiful green landscapes, beautiful red barns and lots of natural beauty. 10 minutes to the Fire Island ferries, and just over an hour to New York City. A short car ride to Robert Moses, State Park, beaches and approximately two hours from Montauk Point. Lots of shared spaces, fire pit area, barbecue area, and a small walking trail. Please keep in mind there is one queen bed and a bunk bed. The top bunk is designed for somebody 125 pounds or less. This park model RV is best suited for two adults and up to three children. This year in 2026 we are encouraging and offering self guided nature learning options. We are providing books on trees and plant identification. Bird watching books and necessary supplies. Books and supplies to enjoy astronomy. A nature trail “off property” but with direct entry from our homestead. Books and hands on learning about chickens and basic homesteading.

Mobile Home

Enjoy a little bit of country living in this park model two bedroom trailer home

Bay Shore, New York, United States

Bed

Bath

Sleeps

Exceptional(4)

$1217.91

Perfect home away from home for your family vacation. Enjoy a relaxing stay free of cars and the hustle and bustle of everyday life. Just a ferry ride away. House in mint condition and just a short walk to the Ocean and steps away from town. Perfect for families, girls getaways or your new home office. brbrOur house includes 4 bedrooms 2.5 baths and outdoor shower. The house can accommodate 10 people comfortably. This house has a large outdoor patio space great for entertaining. Also has 2nd story deck for dining with Bay views. Large living/dining room combo, full modern kitchen equipped with appliances. All bedrooms air conditioned. brbrHouse is completely equipped with all linens, towels, washer, dryer, dishwasher, outdoor shower, TV, TWO gas BBQ grills, beach chairs and bikes! House is cleaned thoroughly. brbrThis vacation rental property is close to: Beach, boating, fishing, National Park, playground, tennis courts, restaurants, wildlife viewing and basketball courts.brbrTo rent you must be 30 years old, sign a rental agreement, provide a copy of your license. This person must be on premises at all times. brbr brNo pets, no smoking!

Beach Lover's Paradise - Kismet, Fire Island

Bay Shore, New York, United States

Bed

Bath

Sleeps

Exceptional(4)

$869.11

Relax in a charming Fire Island 3-br gem in Fair Harbor. Nestled on tranquil Walnut Walk, this house offers a soothing retreat for guests close to the ocean, the bay and ferry. The bedrooms are thoughtfully furnished with a queen bed, a twin bed, and a twin over full bunk bed, ensuring a comfortable stay for everyone. With 1.5 bathrooms, equipped with indoor and outdoor showers, A/C throughout, strong WiFi, washer/dryer, dishwasher, full indoor kitchen and outdoor grill, it's the perfect indoor/outdoor living environment. The living room space features a cozy pullout couch and relaxing armchairs perfect for kicking back. We look forward to welcoming you to our place, where enchantment and tranquility await.

Charming Fair Harbor 3br steps to ocean, sunset view, WiFi, A/C, outdoor shower.

Bay Shore, New York, United States

Bed

Bath

Sleeps

$404.35

Unwind at this stunning Private entrance 3 Bedroom; 1 King Bedroom, 2 Queen Bedrooms include with the Modern Decor is Table & Chair, Water Bottle, Mirror, Bathrobe, Clock, Towels, Soap, Hangers, Garbage can, Shampoo/Conditioner, Small Closet, Storage, Iron, Coffee/Tea, TV, & WiFi.brbrBathroom 2nd Fl., Medicine Cabinet, Shower and Sink, and Toilet.brbrKitchenette Area 2nd Fl. includes Toaster Oven, Stove and Microwave. Great for warming up meals or preparing small meals.

Private 3Br Apt: King-2Queen -PetPally -LTR-STR

Bay Shore, New York, United States

Bed

Bath

Sleeps

Exceptional(7)

$1570.94

This is a lovely well maintained family home. We have owned the home for 30 years and we take tremendous pride in the home. Two year old Heated Pool, day and night swimming. Fence for young children, if needed. The home has four comfortable bedrooms, two newly renovated bathrooms, first floor tub and shower, upstairs brand new large shower , new kitchen with all LG appliances, granite counter tops, very comfortable living room and of course a beautiful pool right outside your door. The home has split air conditioning in each room for the utmost comfort. There is a great outdoor shower and of course beach chairs and bikes. Please families only. No groups. br

Fully renovated 4 bedroom and 2 full bathrooms Sleeps 9 Heated Pool

Bay Shore, New York, United States

Bed

Bath

Sleeps

$933.37

Fire Island cottage featuring 3 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms in the main house plus 1 guest house bedroom and outdoor shower on the back deck. Steps from the bay and ocean. Just .3 mile from the Dunewood ferry dock and .6 mile from Fair Harbor. The house includes:brRamp entry with 1 low step to the front door. brLiving room with 2 couches, coffee table, flat screen tv.brKitchen with island and stools, dining table, dishwasher, toaster oven, microwave, Keurig, electric stove/oven. Kitchen also includes basic pots, pans, cutlery, cutting boards, serving ware, and drink ware.brBedroom with 1 queen bed. brBedroom with 1 queen bed + 1 twin bed.brBedroom with 1 king bed + en suite half bathroom + laundry dryer.brFull bathroom with bathtub and laundry washing machine.brOffices/spare room on the back deck (not in the main house) with 1 double bed.brOutdoor shower.brThe deck has tall fencing for privacy, but the outdoor area is not completely fenced in. Back deck with a table and chairs and other outdoor seating.

Cottage

Island Retreat in Lonelyville

Bay Shore, New York, United States

Bed

Bath

Sleeps

$165.68

Enjoy a stylish experience at this centrally-located place. Near the shopping center (tanger outlets) and 10 mins away from beaches. brenjoy night life near babylon and bayshore bars. brPrefect for a small getaway *There is a pet fee associated if bringing along your furry friend

1 bedroom 1 bath private entrance

Bay Shore, New York, United States

Bed

Bath

Sleeps

Sleeps

$214.96

Cozy 2br Private Apt, Pet Pal, Events, LTR-STR

Bay Shore, New York, United States

Bed

Bath

Sleeps

$1217.91

Private vacation home

Beach Lover's Paradise - Kismet, Fire Island

Bay Shore, New York, United States

Bed

Bath

Sleeps

$340.35