Home Vacation Rentals By Owner In Bay Shore, NY

Showing 25 Of 25 Vacation Rentals
Slider Thumb
Exceptional(1)

$290.99

/ Nightly
Mobile Home

Enjoy a little bit of country living in this park model two bedroom trailer home

Bay Shore, New York, United States

Discover this wonderful 2-bedroom gem in Bay Shore NY. Sitting on a small micro farm, this property is very unique to the area. Wake up to the crow of roosters in the morning. Beautiful green landscapes, beautiful red barns and lots of natural beauty. 10 minutes to the Fire Island ferries, and just over an hour to New York City. A short car ride to Robert Moses, State Park, beaches and approximately two hours from Montauk Point. Lots of shared spaces, fire pit area, barbecue area, and a small walking trail. Please keep in mind there is one queen bed and a bunk bed. The top bunk is designed for somebody 125 pounds or less. This park model RV is best suited for two adults and up to three children. This year in 2026 we are encouraging and offering self guided nature learning options. We are providing books on trees and plant identification. Bird watching books and necessary supplies. Books and supplies to enjoy astronomy. A nature trail “off property” but with direct entry from our homestead. Books and hands on learning about chickens and basic homesteading.
Bed 2

Bed

Bath 1

Bath

Sleep 5

Sleeps
Slider Thumb
Exceptional(7)

$1273.89

/ Nightly
Private Vacation Home

Fully renovated 4 bedroom and 2 full bathrooms Sleeps 9 Heated Pool

Bay Shore, New York, United States

This is a lovely well maintained family home. We have owned the home for 30 years and we take tremendous pride in the home. Two year old Heated Pool, day and night swimming. Fence for young children, if needed. The home has four comfortable bedrooms, two newly renovated bathrooms, first floor tub and shower, upstairs brand new large shower , new kitchen with all LG appliances, granite counter tops, very comfortable living room and of course a beautiful pool right outside your door. The home has split air conditioning in each room for the utmost comfort. There is a great outdoor shower and of course beach chairs and bikes. Please families only. No groups. br
Bed 4

Bed

Bath 2

Bath

Sleep 9

Sleeps
Slider Thumb
Exceptional(2)

Select Dates for Price
Cottage

Fair Harbor Fire island

Bay Shore, New York, United States

Our cozy cottage is waiting for you! June onlybrNewly Renovated new kitchen 3 bedrooms 2 baths outdoor shower. Large deck 700 feet to the ocean. Beach chairs, 5 bikes, bbq, brDog friendly after approval 3 night min
Bed 3

Bed

Bath 2

Bath

Sleep 6

Sleeps
Slider Thumb

$831.68

/ Nightly
Private Vacation Home

Spacious 5-bedroom house in fantastic Bay Shore with AC

Bay Shore, New York, United States

Nestled in Bay Shore, this lovely house offers plenty of space with five comfortable bedrooms and three bathrooms. Guests can relax in a bright, inviting environment where heating and air conditioning keep the temperature just right. Whether you’re freshening up with the hair dryer or ironing your favorite outfit, the house has you covered. The layout encourages both restful nights and lively gatherings. We hope you'll enjoy your stay at our house and make wonderful memories here.
Bed 5

Bed

Bath 3

Bath

Sleep 11

Sleeps
Slider Thumb
Exceptional(19)

$156.15

/ Nightly
Apartment

Bay Shore Condo Close to Outdoor Sports & Institutes!

Bay Shore, New York, United States

Garden apartment with large master bedroom and walk-in closet, bathroom, kitchen, and living room. The apartment is 3.5 miles to South Shore University Hospital, 6 miles to Good Samaritan Hospital, 9 miles to Suffolk Community College Grant Campus, 5.3 miles to Touro College of Health Science, 3.8 miles to Fire Island Ferries, 14 miles to Sayville Fire Island Ferries, 3.6 miles Tanger outlet mall, and 3.4 miles to Main Street shopping, entertainment, restaurants.
Bed 1

Bed

Bath 1

Bath

Sleep 2

Sleeps

Home Most popular vacation rentals in Bay Shore

Slider Thumb
Exceptional(19)

$1590.83

/ Nightly
Private vacation home

Spacious 5-bedroom house with AC in amazing Bay Shore

Bay Shore, New York, United States

Bed 5

Bed

Bath 3

Bath

Sleep 12

Sleeps
Slider Thumb
Exceptional(19)

$1101.70

/ Nightly
Private vacation home

Fire Island Beach House

Bay Shore, New York, United States

Bed 4

Bed

Bath 2

Bath

Sleep 8

Sleeps
Slider Thumb
Exceptional(19)

$950.72

/ Nightly
Private vacation home

Fire Island Beach House - Atlantique

Bay Shore, New York, United States

Bed 4

Bed

Bath 3

Bath

Sleep 8

Sleeps
Slider Thumb
Exceptional(19)

$918.07

/ Nightly
Private vacation home

Charming Fair Harbor 3br steps to ocean, sunset view, WiFi, A/C, outdoor shower.

Bay Shore, New York, United States

Bed 3

Bed

Bath 1

Bath

Sleep 8

Sleeps
Slider Thumb
Exceptional(19)

$290.99

/ Nightly
Mobile home

Enjoy a little bit of country living in this park model two bedroom trailer home

Bay Shore, New York, United States

Bed 2

Bed

Bath 1

Bath

Sleep 5

Sleeps
Slider Thumb
Exceptional(19)

$1273.89

/ Nightly
Private vacation home

Fully renovated 4 bedroom and 2 full bathrooms Sleeps 9 Heated Pool

Bay Shore, New York, United States

Bed 4

Bed

Bath 2

Bath

Sleep 9

Sleeps
Slider Thumb
Exceptional(19)

$148.91

/ Nightly
Apartment

Cozy 2br Private Apt, Pet Pal, Events, LTR-STR

Bay Shore, New York, United States

Bed 2

Bed

Bath 1

Bath

Sleep 8

Sleeps
Slider Thumb
Exceptional(19)

$401.45

/ Nightly
Apartment

Bay Shore Vacation Rental w/ Shared Yard!

Bay Shore, New York, United States

Bed 3

Bed

Bath 1

Bath

Sleep 6

Sleeps
Slider Thumb
Exceptional(19)

$339.38

/ Nightly
Private vacation home

Stirling Croft Mansfield | Family Retreat for 10 Near Mt Buller | Pet-Friendly

Mansfield, Victoria, Australia

Bed 4

Bed

Bath 2

Bath

Sleep 10

Sleeps
Slider Thumb
Exceptional(19)

$1232.76

/ Nightly
Private vacation home

Beach Lover's Paradise - Kismet, Fire Island

Bay Shore, New York, United States

Bed 4

Bed

Bath 2

Bath

Sleep 10

Sleeps

Most Popular Cities in New York