Home Vacation Rentals By Owner In New Buffalo, MI

Showing 80 Of 270 Vacation Rentals
Slider Thumb
Exceptional(29)

$979.17

/ Nightly
Private Vacation Home

HEATED POOL OPEN. Blue Heron Private Retreat in heart of New Buffalo

New Buffalo, Michigan, United States

Now booking summer 2026-4 night minimum. Winter rates during offseason (2 night minimum). Before 6/18, 8/2-8/5 and after 9/18 available. brbrPool is open and heated May 1st- mid October. We are registered with the city under permit CR25-0011brbrFeel like you're tucked away with an outdoor space that mirrors a resort while being close to all the New Buffalo action. Property includes an oversized/commercial new (2020) heated pool with steps across, larger outdoor space with large deck and gazebo area, sunbathing areas surrounded by lush landscaping. Large firepit area, chipping green/regulation cornhole/game area and huge elevated sunporch with vaulted ceilings nestled among the trees overlooking a large park with playground, walking trails, track, pickleball and tennis courts, skate park, etc. Plenty of space to dine outside under the umbrella, sun or trees.brbrSimilar to Property 1580568 and 1184533, this property has been completely rehabbed and stocked with every amenity in mind. brbrInside you'll find a large living room with sectional and Queen pullout sofa bed, dining room with table for 8, plus a separate table with additional seating and island, new kitchen (2021) and full bath on the main floor. brbrHeading upstairs is another full bathroom, Bedroom 1: Queen bedroom and Bedroom 2: King bed, vaulted ceilings and a twin daybed with pullout twin. brbrFrom the main floor, head downstairs to the 3rd level with Bedroom 3: King leading out to the deck overlooking the pool and a 3rd full size bath. brbrIn the basement you’ll find an office with a large tv and daybed as well as a 5th game room with foosball table and laundry room. There is an extra fridge in the garage. brbrAll but the Queen bedroom have smart Tv's equipped with access to all major channels (YouTube TV, Netflix, Amazon Prime, Hulu, etc). Because of the layout with the separate floors each room feels like it's own private wing. Please note that this is an older house so the ceiling height in the basement is lower and that steps are required to access all levels. Each of the bedrooms has its own AC controls. brbrMain floor: Kitchen, Living, Dining, Full Bath, and SunporchbrbrUpstairs: 2 Bedroom and Full Bathroom 1) King Bed and Twin Daybed with Twin Pullout and 2) Queen Bed brbrDownstairs; (approximately 6 steps): King Bedroom opening to pool deck/patiobrbrBasement: (3 steps from downstairs): Full Bathroom, Laundry Room, Game Room and Office room with Full Daybed brbrYou're located within a few blocks of Redamaks and downtown, across from the park with all of it's amenities and with a double lot/fenced in yard to enjoy the heated pool in complete privacy. brbrThe home is well stocked so you can leave everything at home, from beach towels and toys, bikes, kitchen gadgets, linens, toiletries, etc. As discerning travelers, everything is setup to make your stay as comfortable as possible. brbrWe are conveniently located 1.1 miles from the beach, 0.3 miles from Redamaks, 0.5 miles from downtown New Buffalo shops and restaurants as well as a few miles from Four Winds Casino, a quick drive to the Warren Dunes and/or Michigan City Prime Outlets or zoo. Notre Dame is only a 40 min drive and Chicago is a little over an hour drive or train ride.brbrWhether antiquing, doing a winery or brewery tour, hitting the casino, riding the bike trails, exploring the shops or beach, enjoying smores by the firepit looking at the stars, and/or simply relaxing by the pool we have something for everyone!brbrWell behaved dogs are accepted with prior approval.brbrSigned rental agreement and New Buffalo visitor form required
Bed 5

Bed

Bath 3

Bath

Sleep 10

Sleeps

Slider Thumb

$283.02

/ Nightly
Condo

'Summer Breeze' Lakeside Condo - Walk to Town & Marina + POOL

New Buffalo, Michigan, United States

Chic Condo Lakeside in Downtown New Buffalo Adorable TWO bedroom, ONE bathroom condo with a community outdoor-heated pool. Short walk to Downtown restaurants and shops. Quiet location - deck tucked away overlooking the forest preserve. brbrLakeside Condo sleeps 6 comfortably;br• Bedroom #1 features a KING bed with 32 TV with basic cablebr• Bedroom #2 features a QUEEN bed and a twin trundle br• Main room has a FULL sleeper sofa br• Updated BathroombrbrOpen Floor Layout with Dining & Family Roombr*Community Heated Outdoor Pool: Memorial Day- Mid September*brbr• Updated Kitchen is stocked with all the basic necessities to dine inbr• Dining area has bar height wood dining table provides seating for allbr• Updated bathroom provides shower with bath towelsbr• Outdoors: Deck has gas grill and small seating area br• Complex heated pool is a quick walk br• Flat screen 65” TV with basic cable and secure WIFIbr• Coffee bar with Keurig br• Washer / DryerbrbrLIMIT is 6 people on property! br*City Ordinance REQUIRES Guest Information - names and ages of all guest or reservation will be cancelled without refund brbrCleaning Fee is $110brbrChicago Visitors: Amtrak station is 7 blocks away - short 75 minute commute from Chicago.brbrCheck OUT time is 10:30AM ESTbrCheck IN time is 3:30 ESTbrbrIf you enjoy the beach town living - this is a perfect place to create memories!brbr**If you are looking for a larger place or if this one is booked - check out my other listing: VRBO #1029758 & #590003brbr————————————————————————————brbr- Contactless Check IN & OUTbr- $50 Biohazard Cleaning Fee May Be Charged if Not Cleaned Upbr——————————————————————————
Bed 2

Bed

Bath 1

Bath

Sleep 6

Sleeps

Slider Thumb
Exceptional(4)

$2194.37

/ Nightly
Private Vacation Home

Pool | Sauna | Walk to Town | New Buffalo

New Buffalo, Michigan, United States

Welcome to La Loma! This beautiful modern 5 bdrm 4 ba home offers an unforgettable vacation experience.brbrEndless amenities abound at La Loma...br-heated in ground poolbr-rooftop with two separate living spaces, including a tv area and outdoor fire placebr-elevatorbr-work out space, includes elliptical machine, Peloton bike (bring your own shoes) and a variety of other equipment and free weights.brbrJust a short 15 min walk to the main street in New Buffalo and another 5 min walk to the beach.brbrMain level-brbr-Living area open concept off of kitchen and dining area, smart TV, gas fireplacebr-Kitchen has large Wolf Range, Kitchen Aid refrigerator, dishwasher and microwave.br-Dining area has seating for 8pp with another 4 seats at the kitchen island.br-Large laundry roombr-Guest room with queen bedbr-Full bathbrbrbrSecond level-brbr-Two guest roomsbr-Full bathroom with tub/shower combobr-Primary bedroom with ensuite bathroombrbrThird level-brbr-Sitting area with sink and beverage fridgebr-Half bathbr-Two outdoor living spaces with TV, fireplace and fire tablebrbrLower level-brbr-Bunk room with 2 twin bunksbr-Projector and screenbr-Full bathbr-Workout space in garagebrbrOutdoor area-brbr-Heated pool in seasonbr-Fire pitbr-Outdoor ping pong tablebrbrAccess code will be given 24 hrs in advancebrbrWe take the lead from our guests. We will have as much or as little interaction as you prefer.brNo parties-no bachelor, no bachelorette, no prom partiesbrMust be at least 28yrs or older to bookbrMax number of guests strictly enforcedbrNo smoking, no petsbrQuiet hours strictly enforcedbrMax number of cars 4brbr*Our rules are strictly enforced and not adhering to them may result in us asking you to vacate the property immediately and a forfeiture of all monies paid.
Bed 1

Bed

Bath 3

Bath

Sleep 12

Sleeps

Slider Thumb
Exceptional(33)

$484.7

/ Nightly
Country House

Private Setting - Close to Beach, Shops, Restaurants and the Casino

New Buffalo, Michigan, United States

2026 NOW OPEN (4 NIGHT MIN. DURING PEAK SEASON)brbrHOT TUB!!brbrGo 'Just Off the Beaten Path' and escape with this charming 3BR/2.5BA farmhouse-style home, perfectly situated just minutes from downtown New Buffalo. Tucked away on a serene wooded lot, this inviting retreat features an open floor plan, a cozy screened-in porch, and a private hot tub—ideal for relaxing after a day of adventure.brbrConveniently located near Four Winds Casino Resort, Lake Michigan beaches, and the vibrant downtown scene, you’ll have easy access to the marina, shopping, dining, and more. Whether you’re unwinding by the firepit, soaking in the hot tub, or exploring Harbor Country, this home offers the perfect blend of comfort and convenience.brbrWe kindly request that guests refrain from hosting large parties or family gatherings out of respect for the neighboring homeowners, many of whom reside here year-round. By fostering a sense of harmony and consideration, we can ensure that everyone enjoys a peaceful and rejuvenating stay.brbrBring food, drinks, personal items, and the good times.brbrThis property is well-maintained and equipped for the comfort and convenience of our guests. Our vacation rentals include well-equipped kitchens, living, and dining areas. Linens and towels are provided. Homes have washers and dryers, a dishwasher, central heat and air conditioning, and high-speed Internet service. This home is equipped with Smart TVs, NO basic cable service is available at this home.brbr⚠PLEASE be advised the fireplace is a decorative feature and not for use.brbrWe ask that renters bring condiments, dishwasher soap, laundry soap, extra toilet paper, and convenience items like plastic wrap, aluminum foil, and zip-lock bags. We do not resupply anything during the stay. We provide two rolls of toilet paper in each bathroom, 2 rolls of paper towels, 4 garbage bags, and hand soap in each bathroom so plan according to your needs.brbrMinimum Age Limit for Renters: The guest signing the rental agreement/contract must be 30 years of age or older (ID at check-in required) and must be responsible for the group during the entire time of the stay.brbrMaximum occupancy restrictions: The number of guests at any WAYA-managed property can not exceed the maximum occupancy number (or sleeps number). This includes invited guests, friends, or additional family members. Events, parties, or family gatherings are not permitted without express written permission prior to booking.
Bed 3

Bed

Bath 2

Bath

Sleep 8

Sleeps

Slider Thumb
Exceptional(3)

$782.91

/ Nightly
Private Vacation Home

New Buffalo With Hot Tub and Association Beach!

New Buffalo, Michigan, United States

4 Bedrooms, 3 Bathrooms, Sleeps 10brbrThree Night Summer Minimum!brbrLocated in the charming town of New Buffalo, we welcome you to Pinewood Retreat! This gorgeous four-bedroom, three-bathroom home has been completely revamped from top to bottom! The main floor of Pinewood Retreat has loads of natural light and room to spread. Enjoy the cozy family room while watching your favorite show or warm yourself by the electric fireplace for those cooler autumn evenings. The fully stocked kitchen, with brand-new stainless-steel appliances and quartz countertops, has everything you will need. Dining area can seat up to six as well as island seating for three. Open the new double French doors to the front deck for additional outdoor dining space that can accommodate up to six. brbrThree bedrooms on the main floor. Primary bedroom with king bed and en suite full bathroom. Second bedroom with queen bed and third bedroom with two full beds. Full bathroom in hallway for these two bedrooms.brbrKids and adults alike will LOVE the finished downstairs basement. Large flat screen television and sectional couch great for movie night. Have a friendly game of tabletop shuffleboard perfect for all ages. The fourth bedroom bunk room has two twin bunk beds over full beds along with twin trundles. Basement now has new full bathroom!brbrThe large backyard features a new deck and lounge area perfect for soaking up the sun. Kick back and relax in the brand-new hot tub or roast some marshmallows around the fire pit (firewood supplied)! Prepare a delicious meal using the new gas grill to enjoy al fresco at the large outdoor dining table that seats up to ten. Just a short walk to sandy Sunset Beach, a private association Lake Michigan beach.brbrAll the amenities you would expect in a quality rental including private beach access, hot tub, gas grill, washer/dryer, internet, heat/air conditioning, electric fireplace, fire pit, outdoor lounge area, two outdoor dining areas, and much more!brbr**All Guests required to sign our Guest Occupancy Agreement as well. brbr**Minimum age of 30 years old to rent. brbr**Maximum three car parking.
Bed 4

Bed

Bath 3

Bath

Sleep 10

Sleeps

Slider Thumb
Exceptional(14)

$3788.16

/ Nightly
Private Vacation Home

Breathtaking Home on Lake MI w Priv Beach & VIEWS

New Buffalo, Michigan, United States

Summary:brbrStay at a breathtaking luxury home on Lake Michigan with upgrades and amenities! Enjoy a private beach, two decks, lake view windows, a fireplace, and million-dollar views from a bluff. The chef’s kitchen features high-end appliances, and the custom dining table seats 12. There’s a cozy living room, sitting room, and screened porch. The sumptuous primary bedroom has a designer bath and deck access. Upstairs has 3 bedrooms and 2 baths; the lower level has 2 bedrooms and a bath. Pure luxury!brbrbrbrThe Space:brbrThe amazingly beautiful, family-friendly Shore House is nestled on a bluff overlooking Lake Michigan, and every square inch has been designed for vacation bliss! The three-story home sits at the top of the hill, boasting never-ending million-dollar views. Backyard entertainment features are truly epic here, with a private white sand beach, a lower chaise lounge sundeck, and an upper-level dining and entertainment area that runs the full length of the home.brbrbrbrInside, the Shore House’s main floor boasts a gorgeous chef’s kitchen with stainless-steel appliances, dining with a view and a table that expands to seat up to 12, an inviting living room with a fireplace, and an intimate sitting room that leads to a screened porch. A sumptuous ensuite defines the ultimate escape with never-ending views, access to the deck, and a designer bathroom that rivals a spa. Head upstairs to find three bedrooms and two full baths. The residence’s lower level has two more bedrooms and an additional full bath, and every space on each floor is lushly styled for luxury and comfort.brbrbrbrSLEEPING CONFIGURATIONbrbrbrbrMAIN LEVELbrbrBedroom 1: King bedbrbrbrbrUPPER LEVELbrbrBedroom 2: Queen bedbrbrBedroom 3: Queen bedbrbrBedroom 4: Queen bedbrbrbrbrLOWER LEVELbrbrBedroom 5: King bedbrbrBedroom 6: Two twin-sized bedsbrbrbrbrThe Shore House features five well-appointed bathrooms. The primary ensuite includes a luxurious bathtub, walk-in shower, and double vanity. Near the entrance, there's a bathroom with a walk-in shower, perfect for guests. The upper level has two bathrooms, each with a bathtub and shower-tub combo, conveniently located parallel to each other. The lower level offers a bathroom with a walk-in shower.brbrbrbrRecently listed by Travel + Leisure magazine as one of America’s 50 Best Places to Travel, New Buffalo — just 70 miles from Chicago — is not just known for its pristine beaches but also its wide range of outdoor activities, fine restaurants and art galleries, vintage and antique stores, stylish boutiques, distinguished wineries, and local craft beer pubs. And the fact is, Harbor Haven is super-close to all of these! Plus, you’re less than a stone’s throw from the region’s largest recreational harbor, which includes boat, jet-ski, kayak, and other watercraft rentals, as well as fishing expeditions and day or evening cruises.brbrbrbrThere are all sorts of nearby woodland, lake, and riverside parks with hiking and biking trails galore, the most popular of which is Warren Dunes State Park, with its 2,000 acres of amazing sand dunes, gorgeous beachfront, and wetland trails, as well as its extraordinary birdwatching! You and your guests might relish visiting New Buffalo’s Oselka Park, which has baseball fields, playground equipment, and tennis courts. And for even more variety, nearby Union Pier also has a number of other great restaurants, coffee shops, and breakfast spots. Plus, being so centrally located, there are guided tours of local vineyards and award-winning breweries.brbrbrbrThe Neighborhood:brbrJust 70 miles from downtown Chicago, New Buffalo is the gateway to Michigan and a historic Lake Michigan beach town. There are plenty of shops, places to eat, and recreational offerings. Beyond the legacy of summer fun, find a community of hosts and creatives sharing their love of art, culture, and craft throughout the year. New Buffalo is also the location for Southwestern Michigan’s first gambling casino, the Four Winds Casino Resort, and Silver Creek Event Center – the place for concerts featuring headliner entertainment plus conferences and special events.brbrbrbrOther Things to Note:brbrTo ensure a safe and compliant stay, all guests are required to complete identity verification prior to check-in. A valid government-issued photo ID will be collected and verified, and the name on the ID must match the credit card used for payment. When applicable, a background screening may also be required as part of the booking process.brbrbrbrAll guests are required to review and sign Juniper Holiday + Home's Guest Occupancy Agreement prior to check-in. While we understand that events can affect your trip, it is our policy to stick to the agreed-upon cancellation policy in the listing. We recommend purchasing vacation travel insurance if you suspect you may need to cancel your reservation.brbrbrbrThe minimum age to rent this home is 25.brbrbrbrPets are not allowed at this home.brbrThe outdoor fire table is currently under maintenance.brbrbrbrA non-refundable Accidental Damage Waiver is included with your reservation. This waiver covers accidental damage or loss to the rental property caused by you or members of your party up to a maximum of $2,000. This plan does not cover intentional acts, gross negligence, or willful misconduct.brbrbrbrOut of respect for our staff and their families, we do not permit check-ins or check-outs on Thanksgiving Day and Christmas Day. Thank you for your understanding.brbrbrbrPermit No: PRyy0073
Bed 6

Bed

Bath 5

Bath

Sleep 12

Sleeps

Slider Thumb
Exceptional(6)

$444.41

/ Nightly
Private Vacation Home

Cozy Bungalow in the Heart of New Buffalo, Fire Pit

New Buffalo, Michigan, United States

Welcome to Susie’s Getaway, a charming lakeshore cottage offered by Third Coast Vacations, a full-service vacation rental company run by locals who love Harbor Country.  When you book with us, you aren’t just getting another vacation rental company, you’re getting access to the area’s experts. We know where to go because we live here and we love it. brbrThird Coast Vacations is more than a place to find a great home base for your getaway. Staying with us gets you:brDiscounts for beach rentals and other vacation gearbrCharcuterie boards and breakfast with free deliverybrA concierge who can book winery trips and distillery tours for youbrTons more resources to make your time in Harbor Country amazingbrLearn more at the end of the listing!brLooking for a quiet place to get away from it all You found it at Susie’s Getaway! brbrThis lovely New Buffalo bungalow will charm you from the moment you walk through the doors. Park in the circle drive and feel the stress melt away.brbrThis little bungalow is perfect for a small family or group of friends looking to come to New Buffalo and enjoy a slower pace of life. Walk through the front door into an open-concept space. The living area features cozy seating and a smart TV with streaming services. brbrOff the living area is a well-stocked kitchen with bar seating overlooking the dining area. Through the french doors of the dining room is access to a well-furnished deck and views of the garden and charming firepit. brbrThe main floor also features a King bedroom suite with access to the bathroom via a spacious closet where you can unpack and make yourself at home. brbrOff the back of the main floor you’ll find another bathroom and stairs leading down to the basement where there is a washer and dryer for guest use. brbrHead upstairs to a well-furnished sleeping loft with a King bed and two twins, perfect for kids or close friends! brbrThere is a new Tesla EV charger at the house with a J1772 adapter. The back of the home features a secluded fire pit area perfect for your morning coffee or s’mores in the evenings! brbrThis home sits in the front of a two-homes property. There is a gate separating the two properties and the other home houses the caretakers for the compound.  brbrPlease mind your space and they will do the same. They are quiet, respectful and you won’t even know they are around other than the occasional greeting.  Please make sure to not block the gate for the other house.brbrCick here For a walkthrough video of this home as well as more videos of local beaches, vacation homes, and other local attractions, check out the Third Coast Vacations Youtube Channel. If this link doesn't work, just search Youtube for Third Coast Vacations.brbrOnce you’ve booked a home we will provide you with discount codes for the following:brbrWeekends Harbor Country, offering beach gear, maui mats / lilly pads,stand up paddle boards, corn hole sets, board game boxes, coolers, baby items… and more believe it or not.brbrWant a charcuterie board awaiting your arrival How about a s’mores board for the campfire Don't want to make or go out for breakfast Bougie Boards is a partner company that can help you with all these and more with free delivery to your vacation rental.brbrDiscounts offers will be sent after your reservation is confirmed.
Bed 2

Bed

Bath 2

Bath

Sleep 6

Sleeps

Home Most popular vacation rentals in New Buffalo