SELL IT. BUY IT. RENT IT. FIND IT Continental Real Estate Group, Inc.

Home
Login
List My Property

For Sale
For Rent
Vacation Rentals

Today's Mortgage Rates
Get Pre Approved
Payment Calculator
Home Affordability Table
Home Equity Rates

List My Property

Welcome to ByOwner

Search Name

Email address

Password

Remember me

Forgot password?

Search Name

First Name

Last Name

Email address

Phone Number

Password

Confirm Password

By clicking Get Started You agree to be contacted by real estate and mortgage services providers at the phone number and email address you provided, including via automated technology such as autodialing systems, prerecorded voice messages, and text messages. You understand that your consent is not a condition of purchase, and you may opt out at any time. Standard message and data rates may apply. you agree to our Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy including the provisions on cookies

Verify Your Phone Number

Please enter the 6-digit verification code
sent to your phone number.

Didn’t receive the code? Resend Try Again

Change Phone Number

Enter a different phone number to receive verification code.

Add a Verified Phone Number

Buyers are more likely to contact listings with verified numbers.

Continue to your profile to verify your phone in a few quick steps.

Go to Profile

Enter valid City or Address or Sub Division or Zip

Price Selector

-

Apartment
Bed & Breakfast
Condo
Cottage
Guest House
Hotel
Villa
Private Vacation Home

Vacation Rentals By Owner In Shelter Island Heights, NY

Showing 21 Of 21 Vacation Rentals

Slider Thumb

Exceptional(43)

$372

Private Vacation Home

Relaxing Shelter Island Getaway - great for families and couples!

Shelter Island Heights, New York, United States

Bed

Bath

Sleeps

Previous
First
1
2
Last
Next

Home
Vacation Rental
New York
Shelter Island Heights

Most popular vacation rentals in Shelter Island Heights

Exceptional(43)

$2476.29

Private vacation home

Spacious house next to the beach, Ferry and Eateries.

Shelter Island Heights, New York, United States

Bed

Bath

Sleeps

Exceptional(43)

$1936.84

Private vacation home

Silver Beach Water view house, accross from beach and water.

Shelter Island Heights, New York, United States

Bed

Bath

Sleeps

Exceptional(43)

$1286.13

Private vacation home

Relax and Enjoy!

Shelter Island, New York, United States

Bed

Bath

Sleeps

Exceptional(43)

$1215.05

Private vacation home

Impeccably Restored & Charming Victorian Summer Cottage-5 Bed, 4 Bath, Sleeps 10

Shelter Island Heights, New York, United States

Bed

Bath

Sleeps

Exceptional(43)

$1034.62

Private vacation home

Away From it All! Bright, generous and well located 5-bedroom/3.5 Heights house

Shelter Island Heights, New York, United States

Bed

Bath

Sleeps

Exceptional(43)

$936.69

Private vacation home

Relax By The Pool, Or Walk To The Beach And Restaurants

Shelter Island Heights, New York, United States

Bed

Bath

Sleeps

Exceptional(43)

$743.78

Private vacation home

Kick back and unwind

Shelter Island Heights, New York, United States

Bed

Bath

Sleeps

Exceptional(43)

$583.25

Private vacation home

NEWLY RENOVATED WITH POOL, HOT TUB, AND FIREPLACE!

Shelter Island, New York, United States

Bed

Bath

Sleeps

Exceptional(43)

$871.40

Private vacation home

Elegant Treetop Modern Steps from Hay Beach, Heated Gunite Pool

Shelter Island, New York, United States

Bed

Bath

Sleeps

Exceptional(43)

$372.00

Private vacation home

Relaxing Shelter Island Getaway - great for families and couples!

Shelter Island Heights, New York, United States

Bed

Bath

Sleeps

Most Popular Cities in New York

Are You Enjoying ByOwner?

Like

Meh

Dislike

Thank you! Your Voice Matters

Please leave us a Google review.
It helps to strengthen our reach and FSBO community nationwide.

Share on Google

Thank you for your feedback

How can we make ByOwner better ?
Please tell us how we can do a better job.

Please enter feedback

Filter By

Property Common Features

Property Type

Price

Price Selector

-

Property Features

Guests

Bedroom

Bathroom

More Filter

Sports And Adventure Activities

Biking

Fishing

Golf

Hiking

Jet Skiing

Kayaking

Paragliding

Parasailing

Racquetball

Rafting

Roller Blading

Sailing

Scuba Diving - Snorkling

Skiing

Surfing

Swimming

Tennis

Water Skiing

Water Tubing

Leisure Activities

Beach

Bird Watching

Eco Tourism

Gambling Casinos

Horseback Riding

Horseshoes

Paddle Boating

Photography

Scenic Drives

Shopping

Shuffleboard

Sight Seeing

Walking

Wildlife Viewing

Local Services And Businesses

Babysitter

Fitness Center

Groceries

Hospital

Laundromat

Massage Therapist

Attractions

Bay/sound

Botanical Garden

Caves

Churches

Cinemas

Coin Laundry

Duty Free Shops

Festivals

Health/beauty Spa

Library

Live Theater

Marina

Museums

Nude Beach

Playground

Recreation Center

Restaurants

Synagogues

Theme Parks

Water Parks

Zoo

Location Type

Beach - Ocean

Downtown

Resort

Rural

Waterfront -Water View

Catering Options

Guests Provide Their Own Meals

General

Air Conditioning

Alarm Clock

Broadband Access

Ceiling Fans

Clothes Dryer

Elevator

Free Long Distance

Hair Dryer

Heating

Internet

Iron & Board

Linens Provided

Living Area

Living Room

Local Maps

Local Restaurant Guide

Parking

Parking Off Street

Safe

Toilet Paper

Towels Provided

Washing Machine

Wireless Internet

Kitchen

Blender

Coffee Maker

Cooking Utensils

Dishes & Utensils

Dishwasher

Freezer

Grill

Ice Maker

Kitchen

Microwave

Oven

Refrigerator

Stove

Toaster

Entertainment

Books

CD Player

DVD Player

Game Room

Games

Music Library

Ping Pong Table

Pool Table

Satellite / Cable

Stereo

Television

Toys

Video Games

Video Library

Theme

Adventure

Away From It All

Budget

Family

Historic

Romantic

Spa

Sports & Activities

Tourist Attractions

Suitability

Children Welcome

Limited Accessibility

No Children

Non Smoking Only

Pets Allowed

Pets Not Allowed

Wheelchair Accessible

Wheelchair Inaccessible

Pool / Spa

Pool - Spa

Suitability Chkbox

Events Allowed

Long-term Renters Welcome

Minimum Age Limit For Renters

Onsite Services

Car Available

Concierge

Massage

Private Chef

Staff

House Cleaning

Housekeeper Optional

Follow us on Social Media

Site Home Sell My Home Partner

Legal Stuff Terms and Conditions Privacy Policy DMCA Notice Licensing

Information Blog About FAQs Commission Calculator How it works Cancellation and Refund Policy

Quick links Login Ebook Pricing Video Contact Us Home Value Estimator

Texas TREC: Info About Brokerage Services, Consumer Protection Notice

New York: New York Fair Housing Regulations Notice

New York: New York Standard Operating Procedure

© 2026 ByOwner.com All Rights Reserved All Commissions Are Negotiable.

Location*

YouTube Video