Vacation Rentals By Owner In Sayville, NY

Showing 51 Of 51 Vacation Rentals

Exceptional(6)

Select Dates for Price

Private Vacation Home

3BR/2.5bath Ocean View Home in Fire Island Pines with heated pool

Fire Island Pines, New York, United States

Bed

Bath

Sleeps

Exceptional(1)

$839.33

/ Nightly

Private Vacation Home

Ocean Front, Cherry Grove, Fire Island 2 Bedroom, First Floor - Great Location

Fire Island, New York, United States

Bed

Bath

Sleeps

$1240.87

/ Nightly

Private Vacation Home

Private Fire Island Pines Retreat, Pool & Spa, 5 mins from beach and harbor.

Fire Island Pines, New York, United States

Bed

Bath

Sleeps

$2768.28

/ Nightly

Private Vacation Home

Modern, Remodeled 5BR Home; 5 mins walk to Harbor!

Fire Island, New York, United States

Bed

Bath

Sleeps

$1164.53

/ Nightly

Private Vacation Home

Mint Oceanfront Fire Island Pines 2 BR/2 bath Co-op

Sayville, New York, United States

Bed

Bath

Sleeps

Exceptional(4)

$1079.95

/ Nightly

Private Vacation Home

Ocean Front, Cherry Grove Fire Island, Upper Level

Fire Island, New York, United States

Bed

Bath

Sleeps

$2226.44

/ Nightly

Private Vacation Home

Fabulous FIP Whole House Bayfront Retreat

Fire Island, New York, United States

Bed

Bath

Sleeps

$3292.17

/ Nightly

Private Vacation Home

Bayfront Home With All The Bells And Whistles

Fire Island Pines, New York, United States

Bed

Bath

Sleeps

$1570.29

/ Nightly

Private Vacation Home

Sun, Sand & Serenity: Your 4‑Bedroom Fire Island Pines Escape

Sayville, New York, United States

Bed

Bath

Sleeps

Exceptional(1)

$2167.98

/ Nightly

Private Vacation Home

Modern gem nestled in the Pines Community.

Fire Island Pines, New York, United States

Bed

Bath

Sleeps

Exceptional(5)

$2126.88

/ Nightly

Private Vacation Home

Gorgeous Bay Front Home with Water Views and Stunning Sunsets

Fire Island Pines, New York, United States

Bed

Bath

Sleeps

Rent a place that suits your needs

Private vacation home

View 47 Private vacation home

Most popular vacation rentals in Sayville

Exceptional(5)

$3735.39

/ Nightly

Private vacation home

Fire Island Pines | Exclusive Oceanfront Getaway

Fire Island Pines, New York, United States

Bed

Bath

Sleeps

Exceptional(5)

$652.37

/ Nightly

Villa

Pristine Queen Ensuite walk out to deck & pool - shared Kitchen LR DR Pool

Sayville, New York, United States

Bed

Bath

Sleeps

Exceptional(5)

$849.57

/ Nightly

Private vacation home

Bayfront Retreat • 3 Ensuite BR + Hot Tub

Cherry Grove, Fire Island, New York, United States

Bed

Bath

Sleeps

Exceptional(5)

$1079.95

/ Nightly

Private vacation home

Ocean Front, Cherry Grove Fire Island, Upper Level

Fire Island, New York, United States

Bed

Bath

Sleeps

Exceptional(5)

$1100.23

/ Nightly

Private vacation home

2-bedroom designer bungalow with Hot Tub, 1GB FiOS, AC, steps from the beach

Sayville, New York, United States

Bed

Bath

Sleeps

Exceptional(5)

$1142.73

/ Nightly

Private vacation home

Luxury 4-bedroom house in Fire Island Pines - AC, bay views, heated pool and spa

Fire Island Pines, New York, United States

Bed

Bath

Sleeps

Exceptional(5)

$1272.18

/ Nightly

Private vacation home

Charming Beach Cottage Steps from beach with delightful ocean views

Fire Island, New York, United States

Bed

Bath

Sleeps

Exceptional(5)

$1344.04

/ Nightly

Private vacation home

Immaculate Luxury Fire Island Pines Home, Gourmet Kitchen, Pool, Hot Tub Private

Fire Island Pines, New York, United States

Bed

Bath

Sleeps

Exceptional(5)

$1425.68

/ Nightly

Private vacation home

Sweeping ocean views on Sky Walk. Renovated 2023, open floor plan. pets ok

Sayville, New York, United States

Bed

Bath

Sleeps

Exceptional(5)

$3361.42

/ Nightly

Private vacation home

FIP Modern Beach House

Fire Island, New York, United States

Bed

Bath

Sleeps

Vacation Rentals By Owner In Sayville, NY

$839.33

$1240.87

$2768.28

$1164.53

$1079.95

$2226.44

$3292.17

$1570.29

$2167.98

$2126.88

Rent a place that suits your needs

Most popular vacation rentals in Sayville

$3735.39

$652.37

$849.57

$1079.95

$1100.23

$1142.73

$1272.18

$1344.04

$1425.68

$3361.42

Most Popular Cities in New York