Vacation Rentals By Owner In Monticello, IN

Family friendly spacious 4-bedroom, 3-bathroom home ON Lake Shafer facing west for amazing sunsets! Several levels of decking offers grilling (Blackstone), large outdoor eating area, water sports, fishing, and lounging areas with fire table and fire pit nook right next to the lake. Large lake raft, kayaks, and paddle board waiting by the pier for you with two bays close by. Large living room with electric fire place and panoramic view of the lake. Cozy second floor loft with books/games. Stocked coffee and tea bar. Washer and dryer with supplies on sight. Child friendly home with pack' n plays', highchair, child gate, bed guard rail, and dinnerware. Four parking spaces right in front of the house. This house is a short 10-minute car or boat ride to Indiana Beach, golfing, and several restaurants on the lake. This is a great house to enjoy time on the water with family and friends!

Lake Shafer Home: Boat, Swim, Kayak, BBQ, Sunsets, ten minutes to Indiana Beach

Monticello, Indiana, United States

Bed

Bath

Sleeps

Exceptional(75)

$789.27

Custom-designed lakefront home built for multi-family & multi-generational getaways.br• Main house + attached in-law suite for flexible spacebr• 102 ft of main Lake Shafer waterfront with private dockbr• Hot tub with panoramic lake viewsbr• 5-minute walk to Indiana Beach Amusement & Water Parkbr• Perfect for boaters, families & groups seeking lake lifebrbrHOUSE LAYOUTbrbrGREAT ROOM: The gathering hub for your group.br• Large leather RH sectional sofa & chairsbr• 60 flat screen TV with DVD playerbr• Indoor/outdoor AV speakersbr• Huge windows with stunning lake viewsbr• Fireplacebr• Open to dining room, kitchen, and screened porchbrbrDINING SPACES: Ample seating indoors and out for dining, games, and gathering.br[ Seating for 16 indoors ]bro 8 chairs at large communal tablebro 4 stools at kitchen islandbro 4 chairs at table in apartmentbr[ Seating for 10 outdoors ]bro 6 chairs on main house screened porchbro 4 chairs on apartment screened porchbrbrKITCHENS + COOKING: Kitchens designed for effortless large-group meal prep.br• Two complete kitchens stocked with quality cookware and full appliancesbr• Everything doubled: fridges, freezers, microwaves, ovens, dishwashers, disposalsbr• Gas grill and Hasty Bake charcoal smoker for outdoor cookingbrbrSLEEPING: Sleeps 15 comfortably in 5 bedrooms across three separate zones. Each zone has its own hallway, bedrooms, and bathrooms—thoughtfully located away from the main great room for quiet & privacy.brbrAll bedrooms include:br• Highest quality mattresses, pillows, and bed linensbr• Blackout drapery/blindsbr• White noise machinesbr• TVsbr• Clothing storagebrbrZONE 1: [Bedroom 1 + Bedroom 2 + Bathroom 1] — Sleeps 4brBEDROOM 1:br• California King bedbr• En suite Bathroom 1br• Lake viewbrBEDROOM 2:br• 2 twin beds (trundle configuration; pull one out for use)br• Laundry room accessbrBATHROOM 1:br• Shower with double vanitybrbrZONE 2: [Bedroom 3 + Bedroom 4 + Bathroom 2] — Sleeps 6brBEDROOM 3:br• King bedbrBEDROOM 4:br• Queen bed + 2 twin bunk bedsbrBATHROOM 2:br• Bathtub/shower combobr• Double vanitybrbrZONE 3 — APARTMENT: [Bedroom 5 + Sleeping Nook + Bathroom 3] — Sleeps 5brBEDROOM 5:br• King bed + 1 twin bedbrSLEEPING NOOK:br• King bed (built-in wall-to-wall, open to apartment living room)brBATHROOM 3:br• Bathtub/shower combobrbrOUTDOOR LIVING SPACES: Screened-in porch connected to the living room.br• Dining table for 6br• Upholstered sofa + ottomanbr• Lake viewsbrbrAMENITIESbrbrINDOOR AMENITIES:br• Central heat/AC systems (independent climate control)br• Endless hot waterbr• High speed WIFIbr• Comcast Basic Cablebr• Fireplacebr• Board gamesbr• Washer & dryerbrbrBABY & CHILD AMENITIES:br• 2 high chairs (restaurant style)br• 1 Pack N Play crib + sheetsbr• Playground with infant + regular swingsbrbrOUTDOOR AMENITIES: The house sits on a south facing sloped wooded lake front lot. It provides both sun and shade, sunrise and sunsets. You’ll never forget campfires on Lake Shafer with the historic wood roller coaster and ferris wheel in the distance.br• Hot tub with panoramic lake viewsbr• Playgroundbr• Kayakbr• Private boat dockbr• Hammocksbr• 2 fire pits (one at top of hill, one by the dock)br• Gated drivewaybr• Ample parking, including space for boat trailersbrbrLAKE SHAFER ACTIVITIES:br• Indiana Beach Amusement & Water Park (5-minute walk)br• Boating (bring your own or rent locally)br• Swimming off our dock in a no-wake zonebr• Kayakingbr• Fishing off the dockbr• Run/walk trailbrbrLOCAL AREA ATTRACTIONS:br• Indiana Beach Amusement Park & Water Park (5-minute walk)br• Drive-in movie theater (4 minute drive)br• Canoe trips (23 minute drive)br• Horseback riding (27 minute drive)br• Golf courses (5 minute drive)br• Restaurants (5 minute drive)br• Grocery stores (8 minute drive)br• Winery (12 minute drive)br• PURDUE UNIVERSITY - ROSS ADE Stadium (40 minute drive)brbr• VIBE — Located on the street leading to Indiana Beach, surrounded by older vacation lodges and private lake homes. The property is gated and bordered by tall landscaping and fencing, creating an incredibly private feel despite being steps from the action.br• PROXIMITY — On Lake Shafer | 5-minute walk to Indiana Beach Amusement Park | 7-10 minutes to restaurants and stores in Monticello, Indiana.br• GETTING AROUND — Easy parking in private driveway for 8+ cars and boat trailers.br• EXPECTATIONS — Noise isn't an issue, whether you're making it or worried about hearing it. The property is well-shielded from neighbors by landscaping and fencing, and the house is exceptionally well-insulated with spray foam.

Waterfront Lake Shafer - Hot Tub + Fireplace

Monticello, Indiana, United States

Bed

Bath

Sleeps

Exceptional(26)

$430.4

Beautiful lakefront rental house. 5 bedrooms an office, sleeps up to 10 or more comfortably. Perfect space for entertaining a large family or group. 2 tier deck access from 3 bedrooms as well as entertainment area with a bar, board games and ping pong table. Pier access with public dock across the street. Just a few minutes walk to Indiana Beach and 10 min drive to Tippecanoe Golf Country Club or downtown Monticello.

Amazing Lakefront House with all the Amenities!

Monticello, Indiana, United States

Bed

Bath

Sleeps

$166.14

Monticello is waiting for you at this cozy 1-bedroom cottage. Inside, guests find a queen bed perfect for restful nights and a cozy living room with a futon for extra comfort. The bathroom features a refreshing shower and a handy hair dryer. Whether you’re relaxing indoors with heating or cooling, this space offers a tremendous spot to unwind. The cottage creates an enjoyable atmosphere where every detail is designed with guests in mind. Book now and enjoy everything this awesome cottage has to offer.

Cottage

Cozy 1-bedroom cottage in charming Monticello

Monticello, Indiana, United States

Bed

Bath

Sleeps

Exceptional(1)

$135.39

Discounted rates for 30+ nights!brbrbrbrWelcome to Dave’s Last Resort—your cozy home base just **300 feet from thebrbrentrance to Indiana Beach Amusement Park**! Nestled along 70 feet of scenicbrbrLake Shafer shoreline, our charming lakeside property features **6 individualbrbrunits** , each thoughtfully equipped for a comfortable and convenient stay.brbrbrbrThis unit sleeps **up to 4 guests** and includes: • Shared porch with outdoorbrbrseating • Mini fridge, microwave, toaster, coffee maker • Smart TV forbrbrstreaming your favorite shows • Air conditioning and comfortable beddingbrbrbrbrAs our guest, you'll also enjoy access to the resort’s shared amenities:brbr**Outdoor pool** for refreshing summer swimbrbrbrbr**Hot tub** relax while viewing the lake.brbrbrbr**Lakefront dock** —coming soon!! brbrbrbr**Picnic areas** with tables for lakeside meals and gatheringsbrbrbrbrWhether you're here for family fun, a weekend of waterside relaxation, or abrbrnostalgic trip to the amusement park, Dave’s Last Resort offers everything youbrbrneed for a memorable Monticello getaway.brbrbrbr Note: Outdoor pool and hot tub are a shared space.brbrbrbrOne vehicle can park East of the building (in the rocks section at the verybrbrfront of the property). Additional vehicles will need to park across thebrbrstreet in the Indiana Beach overflow parking. brbr brbrPlease note there's additional penalty fee that will be charged if you werebrbrfound littering in the property. Container is provided at the entrance of thebrbrunit for trashes, so please keep the property clean during your stay. brbrbrbr

NEW! Dave's Last Resort Poolside - Long Stay Discount - Comforting Cabin 2

Monticello, Indiana, United States

Bed

Bath

Sleeps

Very Good(1)

$141.57

Discounted rates for 30+ nights!brbrbrbrWelcome to Dave’s Last Resort—your cozy home base just **300 feet from thebrbrentrance to Indiana Beach Amusement Park**! Nestled along 70 feet of scenicbrbrLake Shafer shoreline, our charming lakeside property features **6 individualbrbrunits** , each thoughtfully equipped for a comfortable and convenient stay.brbrbrbrThis unit sleeps **up to 4 guests** and includes: brbr• Shared porch with outdoor seating brbr• Mini fridge, microwave, toaster, coffee maker brbr• Smart TV for streaming your favorite shows brbr• Air conditioning and comfortable beddingbrbrbrbrAs our guest, you'll also enjoy access to the resort’s shared amenities: brbr**Outdoor pool** for refreshing summer swimbrbrbrbr**Hot tub** relax while viewing the lake.brbrbrbr**Lakefront dock** —coming soon!! brbrbrbr**Picnic areas** with tables for lakeside meals and gatheringsbrbrbrbrWhether you're here for family fun, a weekend of waterside relaxation, or abrbrnostalgic trip to the amusement park, Dave’s Last Resort offers everything youbrbrneed for a memorable Monticello getaway.brbrbrbr Note: Outdoor pool and hot tub are a shared space.brbrbrbrOne vehicle can park East of the building (in the rocks section at the verybrbrfront of the property). Additional vehicles will need to park across thebrbrstreet in the Indiana Beach overflow parking. brbr brbrPlease note there's additional penalty fee that will be charged if you werebrbrfound littering in the property. Container is provided at the entrance of thebrbrunit for trashes, so please keep the property clean during your stay.brbrbrbr

Cabin

NEW! Dave's Last Resort Poolside - Long Stay Discount - Charming Cabin 1

Monticello, Indiana, United States

Bed

Bath

Sleeps

$138.18

Discounted rates for 30+ nights!brbrbrbrWelcome to Dave’s Last Resort—your cozy home base just **300 feet from thebrbrentrance to Indiana Beach Amusement Park**! Nestled along 70 feet of scenicbrbrLake Shafer shoreline, our charming lakeside property features **6 individualbrbrunits** , each thoughtfully equipped for a comfortable and convenient stay.brbrbrbrThis unit sleeps **up to 4 guests** and includes: • Shared porch with outdoorbrbrseating • Mini fridge, microwave, toaster, coffee maker • Smart TV forbrbrstreaming your favorite shows • Air conditioning and comfortable beddingbrbrbrbrAs our guest, you'll also enjoy access to the resort’s shared amenities:brbr**Outdoor pool** for refreshing summer swimbrbrbrbr**Hot tub** relax while viewing the lake.brbrbrbr**Lakefront dock** —coming soon!! brbrbrbr**Picnic areas** with tables for lakeside meals and gatheringsbrbrbrbrWhether you're here for family fun, a weekend of waterside relaxation, or abrbrnostalgic trip to the amusement park, Dave’s Last Resort offers everything youbrbrneed for a memorable Monticello getaway.brbrbrbr Note: Outdoor pool and hot tub are a shared space.brbrbrbrPlease note there's additional penalty fee that will be charged if you werebrbrfound littering in the property. Container is provided at the unit forbrbrtrashes, so please keep the property clean during your stay. brbrbrbr

NEW! Dave's Last Resort Poolside - Long Stay Discount - Relaxing Cabin 3

Monticello, Indiana, United States

Bed

Bath

Sleeps

$237.03

Discounted rates for 30+ nights!brbrbrbrEnjoy your own private lakeside escape just **two blocks from Indiana BeachbrbrAmusement & Water Park**! This spacious 2-bedroom home is perfect for familiesbrbror small groups looking to relax, play, and soak up the best of Monticello’sbrbrlake life.brbrbrbrThe house features: brbr• **2 bedrooms** , each with a comfy **queen-sized bed** brbr• **1.5 bathrooms** for added convenience brbr• A **large living room** and a **fully equipped kitchen** brbr• **Smart TVs** , central A/C, and Wi-Fi for modern comfortbrbrbrbrStep outside to enjoy your own backyard oasis, including: brbr• A **heated in-ground pool** just behind the house brbr• A shared**deck with hot tub** overlooking **Lake Shafer** brbr• Plenty of **outdoor seating and lounge areas**brbrbrbr**Outdoor pool** for refreshing summer swimbrbrbrbr**Lakefront dock** —coming soon!! brbrbrbrWhether you’re splashing in the pool, relaxing in the hot tub, or strollingbrbrover to Indiana Beach, this home offers the perfect blend of privacy, comfort,brbrand location for your next lakeside getaway.brbrbrbr Note: Outdoor pool and hot tub are a shared space.brbrbrbrGuests are allowed to park one vehicle on the property. Additional vehiclesbrbrmay park across the street in the Indiana Beach overflow lot. brbr brbrPlease note there's additional penalty fee that will be charged if you werebrbrfound littering in the property. Container is provided at the entrance of thebrbrunit for trashes, so please keep the property clean during your stay.brbrbrbr

NEW! Dave's Last Resort - Long Stay Discount - House on the Lake

Monticello, Indiana, United States

Bed

Bath

Sleeps

$126.99

Discounted rates for 30+ nights!brbrbrbrWelcome to Dave’s Last Resort—your cozy home base just **300 feet from thebrbrentrance to Indiana Beach Amusement Park**! Nestled along 70 feet of scenicbrbrLake Shafer shoreline, our charming lakeside property features **6 individualbrbrunits** , each thoughtfully equipped for a comfortable and convenient stay.brbrbrbrThis unit sleeps ** 2 guests** and includes: • Private porch with outdoorbrbrseating that overlooks the lake • Mini fridge, microwave, toaster, coffeebrbrmaker • Smart TV for streaming your favorite shows • Air conditioning andbrbrcomfortable beddingbrbrbrbrAs our guest, you'll also enjoy access to the resort’s shared amenities:brbrbrbr**Outdoor pool** for refreshing summer swimbrbrbrbr**Hot tub** relax while viewing the lake.brbrbrbr**Lakefront dock** —coming soon!! brbrbrbr**Picnic areas** with tables for lakeside meals and gatheringsbrbrbrbrWhether you're here for family fun, a weekend of waterside relaxation, or abrbrnostalgic trip to the amusement park, Dave’s Last Resort offers everything youbrbrneed for a memorable Monticello getaway.brbrbrbrNote: Outdoor pool and hot tub are a shared space.brbrbrbrPlease note there's additional penalty fee that will be charged if you werebrbrfound littering in the property. Container for trashes is provided at thebrbrunit, so please keep the property clean during your stay. brbrbrbr

Cabin

NEW! Dave's Last Resort Lakeside - Long Stay Discount - Comfy Cabin 5

Monticello, Indiana, United States

Bed

Bath

Sleeps

Exceptional(2)

$124.27

Discounted rates for 30+ nights!brbrbrbrWelcome to Dave’s Last Resort—your cozy home base just **300 feet from thebrbrentrance to Indiana Beach Amusement Park**! Nestled along 70 feet of scenicbrbrLake Shafer shoreline, our charming lakeside property features **6 individualbrbrunits** , each thoughtfully equipped for a comfortable and convenient stay.brbrbrbrThis unit sleeps ** 2 guests** and includes: • Private porch with outdoorbrbrseating that overlooks the lake • Mini fridge, microwave, toaster, coffeebrbrmaker • Smart TV for streaming your favorite shows • Air conditioning andbrbrcomfortable beddingbrbrbrbrAs our guest, you'll also enjoy access to the resort’s shared amenities:brbrbrbr**Outdoor pool** for refreshing summer swimbrbrbrbr**Hot tub** relax while viewing the lake.brbrbrbr**Lakefront dock** —coming soon!! brbrbrbr**Picnic areas** with tables for lakeside meals and gatheringsbrbrbrbrWhether you're here for family fun, a weekend of waterside relaxation, or abrbrnostalgic trip to the amusement park, Dave’s Last Resort offers everything youbrbrneed for a memorable Monticello getaway.brbrbrbr Note: Outdoor pool and hot tub are a shared space.brbrbrbrPlease note there's additional penalty fee that will be charged if you werebrbrfound littering in the property. Container for trashes is provided at thebrbrunit, so please keep the property clean during your stay. brbrbrbr

NEW! Dave's Last Resort Lakeside - Long Stay Discount - Cozy Cabin 6

Monticello, Indiana, United States

Bed

Bath

Sleeps

$123.38