Waterfront Estate on Shelter Island - 200 Feet of Waterfront - 100 Foot Dock

We had a wonderful time at Shelter Island. The ferry ride is easy from New London to Orient Point and then a short 5 minute ferry from Greenport to Shelter Island. If you’re looking for quiet beaches and beautiful views, this is the place. The property is serene with a lovely view of the harbor. It has beautiful bathrooms, cozy furniture to read a book and a great deck to watch boats go by. We were able to go crabbing right off the dock and had enough for a delicious crab corn chowder. We would definitely go back! Thank you for a wonderful vacation!

Staying on Shelter Island was pure bliss. Our family enjoyed a beautiful summer vacation together on shelter surrounded by beautiful nature, in a lovely house situated on Coecles Harbor. It was our first time on Shelter and we absolutely loved it. The beaches were beautiful, the saturday morning farmers market was great and the low key, relaxed vibe of the island were perfect. Edward the property owner was gracious and accommodating to our every need. We will definitely plan to return.

Relaxing home in a quiet neighborhood providing just the kind of retreat we were looking for. We enjoyed the view of the Coecles Harbor and the chance to read books and catch up with family in a beautiful setting.

Classic shelter island house on the water. Close to everything and super quiet location.

As we drove down the block we realized there would be no photo to give you the feeling you would have going into the long driveway. The house sits on a beautiful large piece of property. The location is very peaceful. The view from the backyard was fantastic. The ? sunrises were beautiful. The house has a deck in the back perfect to have a nice dinner. One of my favorite area was the porch with windows and screens. A great place to work or sit and relax. The master bed and bath were perfect size and very accommodating. The other bedrooms were equally as nice. Everyone in my family felt it was one of the nicest homes we have rented. It was also the first time staying on Shelter Island and we love it. Our host was very timely helping us with any questions we had. The photos listed, but no photo could capture the beautiful, peaceful home and property

Incredibly beautiful location on harbor with breathtaking sunrise - close to everything , well equipped, 2 comfortable masters and 2 smaller bedrooms - very homey

This rental is outstanding; highly recommended! We loved every minute of our stay, and would certainly rent it again if available.

Lovely property and view. Hard to access water from dock as steps are not well maintained but the views are beautiful. The kitchen is very well equipped except guests should bring a knife sharpener ! All rooms are very well decorated and comfortable. Takes a genius to figure out audiovisual system and even the very accommodating host had difficulty trying to explain it. But we seldom wanted to watch VCR or TV and we loved our stay!

We enjoyed paddleboarding off the dock, particularly. We had to cut our visit a little short because of the storm. Plenty of nooks for people to work remotely. Edward was very responsive to any little request! Send beach towels overnight, et cetera.

On the day we were set to depart, my grandson grabbed his fishing rod, walked down to the water, and caught himself a striped bass from the dock (no bait needed). It was a fitting end to a wonderful month-long stay on Shelter Island. Life couldn’t have been easier on North Cartwright. Each day, several times, we walked out the door and onto the dock to wash some lures or take a dip, relaxed in the living room overlooking Coecles Harbor, had a chat while completing a Puzzle of the North Ferry in 1815 on the lovely screened in porch, or took a lounge on the spacious deck. If baking is your thing, as it is mine, the kitchen is well stocked; cooking on the new grill (bought while we were there, as a matter of fact) was a breeze too. And through it all, Edward couldn’t have been more helpful. If we needed anything, he was happy to oblige. As for Shelter Island itself, this was our first time staying, and it exceeded our expectations, both for its spacious beauty and its calm pace of life. All in all, my family heartily recommends.