Summer 2026 Great house near town in a private setting

The house was a bit dated but lovely overall and pictures are current/accurate. Sheets were provided but needed to make beds upon arrival. Second full bath is a very small bath if the house is very full so sharing the master bath is a must. The one thing that wasn’t mentioned in the property details that was a bit surprising, was the property manager lives in an apartment/room under the house in the basement. She has her own entrance & we never saw her but I feel as though the description should make you aware of that prior to booking. We found out at check in.

Clean place in a great location with lots of room for hosting on the deck and in the great room. The kitchen is great for preparing meals, expecially with two sinks! We had an excellent time and the great house helped with that big time.The only surprise was that a caretaker lived in a separate section of the house. She was nice, quiet and we didn't have any issues with it whatsoever, but it wasn't obvious that was the situation going into it.

The house and location was idelic!!!! Loved all the amenities the house had to offer especially the outdoor shower!!!!

We couldn’t have asked for a more perfect place to stay on Block Island. Everything about this house was wonderful - it was clean, spacious, so comfortable, and in a location that we all loved!

This home was the perfect place for bringing our family and friends together. Beautiful, welcoming, and full of charm, it gave us the space to relax, laugh, and make lasting memories. The location was ideal – central, scenic, and very walkable. Truly an unforgettable getaway.

We absolutely adored our time staying at the Mcaloon house and will definitely be coming back. Block island was a great getaway and the hospitality of our host made us feel immediately at home.

This house is larger that appearances would have you believe and wonderfully laid out. It is an old dwelling and has some perks that should be expected. We rented the house while we were on Block Island for a work project. The opening foyer is quaint and matches the living room with its cleanliness and historic furnishings. The kitchen is modern, looks recently renovated and is a culinary paradise. The best room however is the addition on the left side of the house. Large and comfortable with plenty of windows and access to the party size porch. The caretaker who lives in the basement apartment is charming and eager to supply information about the local eateries and events.

very nice property. House manager was incredibly nice!

Was a great stay that had everything we could want at an incredibly convenient location. We loved seeing all of the Deer in the yard every morning and evening!

I really enjoyed our stay. The caretaker met us at the house and showed us the layout. The house was clean and the kitchen had all the utensils, etc. needed. One member of our party wanted to be more in town but the ferry was an easy walk without alot of luggage. I will stay her again!!!! I recommend the property.