New Blue Lake House in the Heart of the Finger Lakes

Best equipped Vrbo house we have ever stayed in. Most responsive host we’ve ever had.

This is the way to spend a summer week on Lake Cayuga! Beautiful home just like photos, well stocked kitchen for family meals and cookouts. Clean, comfortable, plenty of space for our family of 6 including 2 teenagers. We rented a boat from a local owner and enjoyed the kayaks at the house. The Lake and sunsets and fireside were enjoyed by all. Easy to travel by boat to several wineries and eateries. Wine trail and state parks nearby, and Ithaca Farmers Market worth the visit. Only downside is the buggy evenings but I think that comes with Lake life in August. Don’t miss this beautiful spot, we hope to be back! Owners very responsive, thank you for a great stay!

We had an absolutely wonderful stay at the New Blue Lake House! This property was perfect for our multi-generational family vacation - we had our adult son with us, plus our daughter and son-in-law with their 7-week-old baby, and there was plenty of room for everyone.The house itself is spacious and light-filled, with gorgeous lake views from just about everywhere. We loved the generously sized rooms, and having two decks was fantastic - one of them is completely screened in from floor to ceiling.The kitchen was large with a great island and the dining room has an over-sized table that made it easy to accommodate our group. There's also a four-burner outdoor grill that we made extensive use of. Everything was spotless when we arrived and the house had all the amenities we needed.Tod was an exceptional host who really went above and beyond. Even before we arrived, he was reaching out with great local recommendations for restaurants, wine tastings, and things to do. He also suggested Finger Lake Boat Rentals, which turned out to be an excellent recommendation. The folks at the boat rental place actually mentioned how lucky we were to have an owner who lets guests use the boat lift overnight - apparently a lot of rental owners don't allow that, and it made our whole boating experience much better.Having easy access to the water, just a few steps out the lower level back door, was ideal..This home has everything you could want in a vacation rental - a beautiful and well

I can’t say enough about the amazing week we just spent in this beautiful house Having rented many homes in this country and in Europe , I can honestly say that Tod’s house sets a new standard of excellence for vacation rentals My family felt more like welcome friends than just renters in this beautiful , spotless, fully equipped home Every little detail was perfectly thought out and made our vacation perfect from start to finish We will definitely be back next summer !!

Blue Lake House is perfect for a family vacation on the western shore of Cayuga Lake. The house is immaculately clean and the best stocked house we have ever rented. The house is new, and all of the finishes are extremely high end. We had room for everyone and it felt like a high end resort! We enjoyed the screened in porch every day and every night. The beds and linens are extremely comfortable. Truly a luxury property in every sense. The kitchen and baths and entire house are stocked beyond your expectations with everything you could need on vacation. The dock and the boat lift are fantastic, and Tod provided wood for the fire pit. The location is really lovely...close to Seneca Falls, wineries, state parks, golf, great restaurants, groceries, shops, and other fun towns in the Finger Lakes. We enjoyed the kayaks, and the grill, and rented a boat for the week on Tod's suggestion which worked out perfectly. Tod was the greatest host...very welcoming and super helpful with suggestions and a speedy answer to all of my questions. He is easily reachable and the process was so smooth and flawless. Tod and his family made us feel so welcomed in their gorgeous home. This is a beautiful home and they have thought of everything!

My family and I had an absolutely wonderful stay at this property. It is a gorgeous home, spacious and equipped with everything you will need to enjoy yourselves. The house was absolutely immaculate and we appreciated all that we had access to - stocked kitchen, kayaks, life jackets, plenty of towels, fire wood, outdoor grilling tools, and the list goes on. Tod was super communicative and made the process smooth and easy - though we never had an issue we needed to reach out for! The location is great - easy to get to Seneca Falls, enjoy the wine trails, state park, etc. Would highly recommend this to anyone!

Blue Lake House was everything we expected and more. The private location was perfectly situated on the western shore of Cayuaga Lake with walk-out lake access. The spacious house was laid out perfectly for our family. The resort-like amenities and attention to detail were spectacular and made our vacation one we will always remember. The owners were very helpful and responsive to all our questions. We highly recommend renting this goregeous home.

My family and I had a fantastic week at the blue lake house. Todd the owner was great to deal with from the booking process, to checking out. He always responded very quickly to any communication. On arrival the owners had provided a welcome pack, which was so thoughtful, we really did feel at home. There was everything we needed at the house and the layout was perfect for our family of 5. The house was exactly as the pictures portrayed, and the serenity and many outside seating areas worked perfectly for us. We had our own jet ski, but rented a boat for the week from finger lakes boat rentals, which was very easy, and they delivered right to the boat dock We couldn't have asked for a better week away, thank you Todd, for being such a fantastic host

What a lovely lake home — very well appointed and comfortable, with amazing views. Nothing about this house feels like a cold, sparse rental. Tod was a great host, responded immediately with questions, and his restaurant recommendations did not disappoint! We fell in love with the area and can’t wait to come back.

It’s over priced for what you offer.