Gorgeous historic inn in downtown Ithaca

A beautiful and comfortable home. Wouldn’t change a thing!

I truly loved my stay at this historic inn. There was so much attention paid to making my stay more enjoyable - like leaving an incredible almond torte and real cream for coffee.The hosts were responsive and check in was a breeze. I don’t think I had a reason to contact them besides passing pleasantries and check out time. There was something really wonderful about not being presented with a ton of house rules but instead seeing signs like don’t worry about the (beautiful) countertops . . .The rooms are lovely, the beds were very comfortable and the tv room nice and cozy. The location in town couldn’t have been more convenient, and, despite being so close to everything there was plenty of onsite parking.

Charming house located in a beautiful neighborhood.Very clean large rooms, with each bedroom having a private bath. We loved the large dining room table where we could meet for breakfast or evening game nights. Very close to shopping and churches. The host was very gracious and provided amenities like coffee and coffee cake for us to use during our stay.

Beautiful house and perfect location

This property was absolutely amazing! We had a group of ten girls for a 2 night trip and the place had everything we needed, was very clean and had some beautiful details. There was plenty of street parking available but it was nice to have the option of a private parking area behind the house. The amount of bathrooms and space was essential for having so many girls in one place! The location was also fantastic, we were able to walk to dinner, some bars at night and even breakfast for the morning. I would recommend this place to anyone, especially for a group of people.

Very nice and comfortable historic home in downtown Ithaca. Walkable neighborhood with wide selection of restaurants. Home is very clean and well-maintained.Mike B

Comfortable and clean. There were 7 of us. Tv room with sleeper sofa was pretty warm, but fan helped. Huge house, very nice, well equipped.

Beautiful property. Super clean and comfortable. Fully stocked kitchen. Within walking distance of shops, restaurants and hiking trails. Our group of 3 couples really enjoyed staying here. Onsite manager was friendly and helpful.

Every room is delightful. I cannot tell you how wonderful it was to “discover” each room when we first arrived. The house has all the charm of an old Victorian home with lovely antique finds, but it definitely was not a grandmother’s old house or a stuff museum. The house is clean, bright, and comfortably furnished. I wish Crystal (or whoever decorated the house) could come help me decorate my house! My daughter, the restaurant chef, and I were quite happy in the kitchen! While it is not huge, it is well laid out and easily accommodates 4 people cooking a thanksgiving dinner for 7. Plenty of shelves and pantry space, lots of pretty plates, mugs, and glassware, pots, pans, baking dishes, and kitchen tools. The dining room is gorgeous! The turn-table and LPs and the candles made dinner very fancy. It was nice to have the TV upstairs with a door- large enough to accommodate everyone, but very cozy and could be closed off if others needed quiet. Everything was just right. It was really a pleasure hosting a holiday with family and friends. There are were a lot of thoughtful touches, but I do not want to spoil all the great treats there to greet you. Crystal is a gracious host, contacting me a few days before the start of our rental to see if there was anything we needed, and contacting me soon after we arrived. The location is great with a small grocery store with nice produce, an ice cream parlor, a bookstore, and the DeWitt Mall (a small mall) all only a block away; Ithaca

The DeWitt Park House was exactly as pictured and described on VRBO's website - if anything, it felt bigger once inside. My husband, three adult daughters, and I rented the house for a long weekend of wedding festivities and everything was perfect. The location couldn't have been better as the Commons was only minutes aways. With regard to cleanliness, I can't figure out how a house built in the early 1800's could be so pristine and clean -- please give your cleaning crew a special thanks from us! Given our jam-packed weekend of wedding activities, the number of rooms and their spaciousness assured the comfort of the bride and our family, as well as the various guests who came and went. Finally, thanks so much to Cristal for being so responsive to all my messages. Just the BEST experience overall!