Lemon Hill Amish Guest House. . . an Amish themed, whole house experience.

Fantastic place ! We loved it !!! Absolutely loved every thoughtful part of the stay!

Overall a very nice place, could of used a bit more dusting. Wellstocked and the cookies were a nice bonus. There were farm fresh eggs in the fridge but we did not cook while there. The animals were fun to watch and we did use the bonfire. We loved the porch swing and watching the buggies go by. The property was in a great area, close to all and Mooey's ice cream down the street was very good.

Brenda is a very gracious host and takes extra care to make the stay special. This is a very peaceful setting and if you're biking it is very close to the Pumpkinvine trail. We hope to return

It is a beautiful space, with many special touches in creating a welcoming space filled with lemon design, warmth and comfort. Delightful to be on the same property with farm animals, donkeys and goats. My grandchildren loved playing outside and resisted being online during our time of game playing, puzzling and singing around the fire circle. Great family stay and amazing communication with hosts!

My sisters and I were extremely happy with our stay. House was clean, kitchen was well stocked and beds were comfy. There was even a dozen eggs in the frig! We enjoyed feeding the donkeys and goats (Letty and Snow White). Host always quickly responded to our questions. She arranged a buggy ride with her Amish neighbor, Sharon who was very open to answering our questions. We had a blast!

Lemon Hill Amish guest house was a wonderful, comfortable and charming experience! Don’t hesitate to book your stay in this quaint home. Everything you need, plus homemade cookies and farm fresh eggs await you. Appreciated the two comfy recliner chairs too!

Everything was amazing!! Very clean! Very welcoming! Great communication! The donkeys were the best! We will be back.

The home was a very peaceful place to stay, yet close to Shipshe. Loved the donkeys that were next to the house, too. The home was very clean and everything that we needed was there. I would not hesitate to stay again

Everything was clean. Beds were comfortable plenty of space for all of us and plenty of activities

The house was very clean, Brenda was super communicative and the beds, bathroom and everything was perfect.

A wonderful little getaway in a tucked away corner of Amish County. Friendly host, incredibly clean and everything was clear, easy to find, and labeled. Came stocked with the essentials and a lot more than what we were expecting, which was a nice surprise (a welcome plate of yummy cookies, some things in the fridge that we were welcome to use, a propane grill and fire pit, etc.). Friendly animals that chilled in their own fenced-in area that loved head pats and neck scritches. We had a blast during our stay!

This property was all we were expecting -- and more! The home was clean and neat and provided unique decor to look at. Beds were comfortable! The kitchen and bathroom were stocked with way more than I ever expected. The cookies were a sweet touch. I am a big animal lover, so my favorite part was the donkeys and goats! We would love to stay at Lemon Hill again and highly recommend it!

Fantastic house! Easy access, clean, comfortable beds, kitchen was very user friendly - even used the BBQ grill! Neighboring farm animals were a fun bonus! Host was kind, very responsive. Would highly recommend this host and this house!

We enjoyed our stay and the delicious cookies.

As a first-time-guest to northern Indiana, we were overwhelming pleased with our stay. Our visit was driven by Anne Wilson concert tickets (that were purchased 6 mons prior) at the Elkhart County Fair, and just exploded with adventure from there. The house was perfect… coming from the country in north Texas, we felt right at home with the beautiful crop land behind us, including a heard of deer one cool evening. My daughter fell in love with the two friendly goats. And we thoroughly enjoyed the fire pit out back. Brenda was the perfect host and very attentive to any concerns/questions we had. The cookies that were left for us were delicious and lunch/ice cream at Mooey’s, just right down the road, was a wonderful treat. I would highly recommend walking/biking the Pumpkinvine Trail, which is an awesome, paved trail, less than half-mile down the road. Other suggested activities we experienced:-Lake Michigan at Indiana Dunes State Park, lunch at The Goblin Dunside, ice cream at Bubbles in Michigan City-Norte Dame, we just parked/walked around-Shipshewana, although we missed the Tues/Wed flea market, we had wonderful lunch & desserts at Shawna Rae’s and 15 min buggy ride around town w/Buggy Lane Tours-Amish Family Dinner w/Buggy Lane *highly recommend!-Harvest Community Church made us feel very welcome Psalm 27:13 tells us to “see the goodness of the Lord in the land of the living” and we definitely saw so much of His goodness in Middlebury, IN!! we will be back

What a peaceful place to enjoy our family girls' trip. We sat on the front porch and watched the horses and listened to the quiet sounds of the Amish country. The inside of the house was very unique and we loved reading the Amish directory!

Such a lovely guest house. Beautifully decorated and so well furnished. Brenda and Dave were quick to help us settle in. We were welcomed with some delicious fresh baked cookies . We look forward to visiting again and highly recommend a stay at Lemon Hill.

Home was everything we expected, tucked off the main road but still able to enjoy seeing the Amish carriages go by. Hostess left us a plate of yummy cookies and, of course, we had to go check out Mooey's Ice Cream right up the road!

Easy to work with and very accommodating. Defiantly would stay again!!

Love this cute little Amish style home. The decor was amazing, the house was clean and included anything you might need. Nothing was left out including the special treat left on the table. Thank you for your hospitality. It really was a nice visit and close to everywhere that we were going

Brenda is an excellent host. The house was very clean and tidy. It felt like home with books and games, and a porch swing. We even got to pet the donkeys! They loved the attention. Brenda has thought of everything you might need. If you have an opportunity to visit this area, I highly recommend Lemon Hill Amish Guest house.

If you’re looking for a quiet place to get away you’ve found it. A well equipped kitchen and bath, comfy beds and sitting areas inside and out. A perfect getaway!

Our stay at Lemon Hill was exactly what we needed—a peaceful retreat from the busyness of life. Surrounded by blooming lilac bushes and the gentle sounds of farm animals, we felt instantly at ease. Mornings were a dream—sipping coffee on the porch wrapped in handmade quilts, watching the countryside come to life. The Pumpkinvine Trail was a highlight—perfect for walking and simply soaking in the serene views. Every detail of the stay felt thoughtfully simple and refreshingly calm. It was the perfect place to catch our breath and reset.

A group of 5 of us plus children stayed here. The place was perfection. Everyone loved it!! My mother in law kept saying how “CUTE!!” it was. It had everything and more. The town also is a really great spot to have family adventures.Brenda was extremely available and so great to interact with. She has hospitality mastered!I highly recommend this place!

We enjoyed the quiet atmosphere, surrounded by farm animals!!The house was clean and neat and the homemade cookies were very welcoming!Our hosts certainly thought of everything!!

This was the perfect place to relax after our daughter’s wedding week! The home was clean and inviting and had so many extras to make our stay comfortable. We especially enjoyed sitting on the front porch and interacting with the sweet donkey on property.

Cant say enough great things avout this house. Wonderful country setting. Very quite. Very clean. Great beds. Wonderful owner and great communication too. Will be staying here again when we come back to Elkhart!