Stately Strip Home | Pets OK | Walk to Winery

Perfectly located in walking distance of everything! This was an excellent choice for our girl's trip. We enjoyed going out each night, having great food options nearby, and overall would recommend this home to anyone with a larger group!

Large bedrooms, attic bedrooms cabin feel, beautiful original woodwork, updated bathrooms, loved the fire pit, immediate response to questions, plenty parking, lake views from some bedrooms! Fell in love with this house!!!

Matt was very responsive. We had an issue due to the extreme winds and it was handled immediately. My guests and I enjoyed our visit.

Enjoyed the house

Great location and plenty of space!

⸻**“My stay was extremely disappointing and the property was very poorly maintained. There were bugs throughout the home, including in the bedroom and common areas, which made the stay uncomfortable and unsanitary. Several areas of the house felt neglected or not properly cleaned before our arrival.Although my family and I tried to make the best of the situation, we were very disappointed by the condition of the property. For the price charged, I expected a safe, clean, and functional space — but this did not meet even basic standards. This experience disrupted our trip, and I do not feel we received the quality we paid for. I am requesting a refund due to the poor conditions, lack of cleanliness, and overall maintenance issues.”** I’m confused about the 10/10 stars

Excellent location and we had great weather. The house was extremely satisfying with all the space and layout to accommodate all of us. Looking forward to coming back next year.

Great house to rent. Huge, close to center of town. This was our first time for GOTL. When we go back will be renting this house again!

I left a note on a chair in the kitchen that the right front leg was broken. We did not break it. We noticed it when someone tried to sit on it. Thank you. Always a fabulous stay.

Great stay with all utensils dishes and linens you’d ever need. House is huge with so many beds! We had firewood and a grill outside as well! Will definitely choose them in the future!

Love the location, cleanliness and size of the property. Have stayed here a few times and will again

Great stay! The house was as advertised, but the 3rd floor was a little challenging for 76 year olds!

Had a great time.

My family and I just had another wonderful reunion at The Colonial and as usual, everything was absolutely perfect!!! The house is so clean, spacious and comfortable and we love that there is plenty of seating, both inside and out. You can gather at the large dining room table, the huge front porch or around the fire pit. The location is amazing, literally right on the strip but set back a bit so that there is also some level of privacy. There is so much to see and do in the area that we always wish that we could all stay longer. Thank you for the excellent accomodations!!!

House is exactly as described and exactly as pictured. Very clean. Plenty of room for big groups. Couldn’t hand pick a better location if you’re coming to GOTL. Easy check in process. Great fire pit. And at check out you’re only asked to handle your trash (perfectly reasonable), whereas most places expect you to be the cleaning service before leaving. I have nothing negative to say. Highly recommend.

We had a great stay. My family made some wonderful memories.

The property was perfect for our needs! Enough rooms for all of us to enjoy a fantastic Fourth of July weekend together! Being right on the strip was so convenient as we could walk to any of the activities and/or shops. We had a wonderful time and especially enjoyed the firepit on the property!

We stay here every year. This year, my 91-year old mother joined us along with her 5-year old great grandson, her grandson and me. Four generations! The Colonial helped her turn back the hands of time. So relaxing sitting on the huge comfortably furnished porch, watching the activity on The Strip. If you don't enjoy staying at the beautiful Colonial, check your pulse. Already looking forward to staying at The Colonial in 2026. So is Mom.

We take our family every year for a staycation close to Erie. This was a great place to stay. Everyone enjoyed the location!!

Great time

Always a great to place to stay. Close to everything!

Little pricey but worth it for the location. Definitely plan on booking each year

House was great. Lots of room. Was perfect for adults, not too many bunk beds or single beds, that adults do not want to sleep in. Close to strip and easy drive to most of the wineries. Perfect for large group we had 11 adults and still had extra rooms. Has everything you could need!

Our second stay - accommodations exactly what we need, location is perfect! Thanks Matt!

The house is great for large groups, sleeps 20 easily. The house is also perfectly located on the strip of shops, restaurants and bars all within walking distance. Perfect for parties and there is a large fire place. The time of the year we went it was cold at night, the house doesn’t have central heat and the heated are gas controlled with an open flame and risk CO exposure if not done right, we did not feel comfortable lighting these. Also the midges were all over the outside of the house and hundreds got inside. One of the guests left because of this. It rained the last night we were there and the attic ceiling started leaking in one of the other guests rooms. The house is old and needs some updating. Additionally there were decorations left in places in the house from a previous party that the cleaning people missed and weren’t exactly appropriate for kids so hopefully those are removed before a big family party. Otherwise we had a great time!

Perfect fall get away. Enjoyed the strip, shopping, good food, and sitting around the fire pit with friends and dressing up in Halloween costumes and going to see the bands at the clubs. House was in a perfect location at the center of town. We did some cooking and there were plenty of pots, pans, utensils available. Would rent again.

The house was very charming. The host responded immediately to the questions I had. We had a great time and the location is perfect!!

Great place! Right in the middle of everything GoTL has to offer. Big house with a lot of room! Fire pit and unlimited firewood was a hit. Stayed here twice and had a blast!

We have been staying at this property yearly for 10 years. It’s the perfect place for our large group and close to everything