Luxurious Lakefront Living With Amenities close to Cooperstown

Clean, comfortable and good location with access to the lake.

A wonderfully comfortable and fun home overlooking Canadarago Lake. Comprehensively administered by its owners, this waterfront getaway was the perfect place for the five of us. The concrete patio and Adirondack chair nook with fire pit was a joyful spot to take in a glorious sunset two nights in a row. And the PacMan Jr. video game in the game room was a nostalgic throwback that my son and friend appreciated sharing in. Well-appointed and thoughtful, I'm sure this home will remain in high demand for its value, location, and established base of fans.

Beautiful location and house. Very comfortable. Was perfect for our golf trip to play Leatherstocking.

Beautiful place, very spacious, thank you for sharing your place with us

Excellent choice

Great place! Beautiful view! Great host and view!

Great location, great amenities, great experience overall. The house was lovely, and the PacMan arcade game? I mean c’mon. We’ll surely be back!

Everywhere in the house was fully equipped. We did not use the kitchen, but everything was supplied for us. The whole house was very clean and was family friendly. Would recommend to stay here anytime of the year!

This house and the host exceeded our expectations. The host was highly communicative and accommodating. Everything was as stated and the home was very clean. The view of the lake was beautiful even when partially frozen over. The game rooms were a hit with our kiddos. Close enough to Cooperstown to still make it convenient. Wonderful stay!

Great place to stay. Host is very responsive to questions.

Really amazing house with activities, lots of space for families to enjoy; be sure to bring your own basics like shampoo, soap, matches for fire, all cooking basics too, coffee, etc.

The place was great! Host provided clear instructions and available if we needed him!

We enjoyed our stay here. The house is as described. It was neat, clean, and the beds were comfy. It was peaceful and the view of the lake was awesome.

This was our second visit to the All Star Lakehouse and we’re anxious to return. The house is beautiful, clean and so comfortable. We love cooking in the well stocked kitchen and on the Blackstone griddle. Nothing beats waking up to the view of the lake other than the most amazing sunsets! Thank you Rodney for sharing this piece of heaven.

Awesome house. We thoroughly enjoyed it! Rodney was great to work with and responded quickly.

beautiful home in an excellent location. Everything went well, except for the weather. LOL

Game room was fun. Wife and friend enjoyed being on the water. Water pressue was an issue. Water stopped completely once. Toilet paper was very poor. Left a message about a thermostat problem that was never returned. Kitchen was well equipped. Good location. Providing a list of grocery stores, good dinning options, local attractions would be helpful.

Beautiful house with magnificent views of the lake. Enjoyed kayaking and the fire pit. House has super comfy beds. Will book again soon.

Beautiful place to stay. Well taken care of by the owner. Everyone enjoyed the accommodations, atmosphere and closeness to Cooperstown and Price Chopper. Very convenient. Golf options are great and the outdoor amenities are exceptional. Very relaxing location and great views of the lake. Communications with the owner were excellent with immediate response time. Will stay here again.

Couldn’t have been more perfect. Spent a lot of time on the lake, which is only steps from the back patio. Rodney provides all the toys. And ending each night with a fire and Pac-Man tournaments was pretty incredible. We will be back!

What a gem. From the moment we pulled up to the house and looked down to the water, we felt so much happiness and calmness. It’s an absolutely perfect house for a family - this stay being only myself, my father, and my 9 year old son. We cooked nearly every meal on the Blackstone, enjoyed watching the boats go by, did a bit of fishing, slept with the windows open listening to the water lap on the shore, but mostly just sat outside and spent time as a family. We saw the neighbors briefly and would waved at the passing boats, but besides that it’s very private. Check-in and out instructions were crystal clear, the house was fully appointed, and the view is really unbelievable. We had just the perfect end-of-summer getaway. (Don’t get me started on the sunsets. Literally breathtaking.) Many thanks to Rodney and Amy!

Everything was perfect for our family!

Great property. Clean and great view of the lake . About 25 min from dreams park. Easy drive Well maintened house. Rodney was awesome and answered many questions!

Great house and location

This vacation home is exactly as described. The location on the lake is phenomenal and offered a serene environment for our family. I looked forward to my cup of coffee on the outdoor patio every morning. Rodney (the host) was excellent to work with - extremely responsive!

Great house right on the lake, perfect place to watch the sunset. We caught tons of different fish on the lake and also right off the dock at the house. Kids loved the kayaks and paddle boat.

The house was more than what we could've ever imagined. The Lake view was gorgeous. The house was very well kept. It was very easy to work with Rodney. I highly recommend staying here.

Beautiful home and location. Very convenient to Cooperstown and good restaurants. Also enjoyed The Estate at Maplewood restaurant in Richfield Springs. Owner very responsive to questions.

The property was just like it was described! I would highly recommend this property to anyone!

We had a fabulous stay at the Allstar Lakehouse. Beautiful property, great amenities, everything you need for a lovely trip. My kids loved the game room and the lakefront was beautiful. Easy trip into Cooperstown to visit and explore. Can’t wait to come back again!

Had the pleasure of staying at the “All-Star Lakehouse” this past week and it was amazing. The pictures do not do it justice. Beautiful home, beautiful location, quiet, and more than enough room for our family to be able to relax. As an added bonus my wife and I are huge baseball fans and the nostalgic memorabilia around the house was just an awesome touch. If you have the chance to stay here, do not pass it up.

We just had a few days to visit and this place was perfect for our family. While the weather wasn’t warm for us, it’s easy to see how this would be a really fun summer stay. Everything was as described and communication was great!

Beautiful property and house. The kids had a great time playing with all of the toys and games. Easy to get to Cooperstown and back. Would definitely stay here again.

Quick trip to Cooperstown to see the Baseball Hall of Fame. The house was gorgeous and had every amenity you could possibly need or want! Plenty of room for our family of 6!! Views were exquisite. Hope to come back in the summer!! Thank you Rodney and Amy for sharing your beautiful and pristine home with us!!

The house is lovely. We found it to be well appointed and comfortable for everyone. We absolutely loved the game room. For a brief time, I felt like a kid again.

This was a gift from me to my husband and our three adult sons- Baseball Hall of Fame and weekend stay. This was on his bucket list to do with our adult sons. The house was a perfect place to hang our for some quality time

A group of buddies took some time to relax, grill, play fuse ball, and try our luck at ice fishing at this lovely home on Canadarago Lake. The amenities were great, the house was lovely, the instructions were clear, and we had a wonderful time over the weekend. We’re already looking forward to coming back!

Everything, everyone has said in these reviews are 100% accurate about the house. 5 stars all the way. If you are as big a baseball nerd as we are, Cooperstown a short 10 minute drive. Went in the off season to the Hall. We actually had time to look around and take everything in. Summer time is ALWAYS busy and rushed.