Historic Sea Captains Home in Downtown Mystic, Walk everywhere, Pet Friendly!

To put it simply - absolutely fantastic. The house and property is absolutely amazing and Sue and Tyler's attention to detail truly is second to none. The location is (obviously) perfect for a stay in wonderful Mystic. At first I was concerned with only street parking but you are able to work it out easily and the street never really fills up. The back yard area is better than it even looks in pictures and the bedrooms and kitchen areas were immaculate. We were there for Conn College Fall Weekend and couldn't have chosen a better place. If you are looking for a place to stay in Mystic - look no further - you will not regret this place. Thanks again to our wonderful hosts.

Gorgeous historic property with a short walk into Mystic.

The Sea Captains Home offered our familiy a special retreat just a few blocks from the center of Mystic. We stayed here with our extended family--my sister's family and ours--adults and teens. There was plenty of space including access to the beautiful deck, yard, and firepit. Our kids enjoyed walking in and out of town on their own. Sue was incredibly gracious and responsive. She has decorated the home with love and sweet touches of color and tasteful design.

Great location we enjoyed walking to town!

PERFECT location! Property owner was great and responsive. We had a fantastic time!

Beautiful historic home in walking distance to all of the shops and restaurants. We had plenty of space to enjoy each other‘s company. The back porch was delightful in the mornings with a cup of coffee and good conversation.

Susan was a great host! House is adorable and fully loaded with everything you need! Quick walk into downtown Mystic for shops and great restaurants!I will definitely be coming back!

House is perfect.

We had a girls trip to meet up with family who lives in the area. This is a Great Location to explore Mystic. The house had everything we needed and enough room for everyone without feeling like we were all on top of each other. 10 out of 10 stay!

We were in town for a Celebration of Life. The house was a perfect place for all 8 of us to stay. We were even able to host a few relatives with all of the leftovers afterwards in the backyard. We especially enjoyed our visits from Herman.

Eight lifetime friends went for two nights to celebrate all turning 70 this year! The house was lovely! So close to town! We had a wonderful time, our host was lovely! I wish we could’ve stayed longer

Sue’s Captain Morgan historic home has an excellent yard — large, fully fenced for kids or a small well behaved dog like ours. Note that the house is separate but the property is shared w/ Sue’s dog and her family. They live in an adjacent home on the large parcel, though the yard is mostly private use when guests are there. The historic home has some unusual renovation elements that provide a lot of beds in this basically three bedroom, 2 bath multi level house. Kitchen is stocked but items are hard to find. Very cozy inside. Gorgeous porch and deck. Would be nice for family gatherings outside. Easy walk to downtown Mystic. Sue is friendly and quick to reach out. Would stay again. Thanks Sue!

My family, who lives in New Jersey, Massachusetts, and New York picked this house and Mystic for a long weekend gathering. Perfect choice. Large living room and dining room and kitchen which was well stocked for cooking, etc. Enough bedrooms for all (we needed 5), although the loft area was not too private but doable. Lovely house, clean, beautifully decorated, down a quiet street right in town. One block to all the stores, bars, restaurants, gallery... Lots of great places to eat. The outdoor space was lovely too. A covered back deck with table and chairs and a front porch; large lawn. The hostess was very welcoming and accommodating. Highly recommend the house.

The Captain Morgan house in downtown Mystic is the perfect place to stay for anyone looking for comfortable accommodations in a prime spot. The house itself was unique, clean, and had a beautiful back deck overlooking the manicured back yard. We were able to walk everywhere downtown from Mystic Pizza to the drawbridge, without needing to move our cars the whole weekend…a huge plus! We would not hesitate to book this house with Susan again!

We rented this for a sisters (4) gathering. We all live in CT but decided to do a VRBO do we could spend quality time together This is a perfect location. Everything is within walking distance. A wrll stock kitchen afforded us the pleasure of cooking breakfast together. Beautiful grounds in a quiet neighborhood. We are planning on returning in the fall.

The house was beautiful full of nice amenities. The kitchen was stocked and both bathrooms had everything we needed. The furnishings were very nice and comfortable. All the bedrooms except the first floor bedroom had air conditioning. The outdoor space was wonderful and enclosed so our dogs and toddler could enjoy it without fear of going in the street. Herman was very friendly and social. The one challenge was street parking. We managed acceptably but at times we had to park further away than expected. The location of the property to downtown Mystic was fantastic. A very easy walk to main street and the draw bridge. We had a wonderful time there.

We were 8 college friends getting together to catch up. It was great sitting on the back porch enjoying the garden and Herman (the friendliest dog). We will definitely return!

This was our family's second stay at the Captain's House. It's just a lovely place and Sue is a great host. The house was clean with thoughtful fresh cut flowers throughout. It has great spaces to gather, a well stocked gourmet kitchen and a huge back porch overlooking the gardens. Very walkable neighborhood with downtown Mystic shops and cafes just a few blocks away. Highly recommend.