3Bedroom 2Bath~~Kayaks~PaddleBoard~~Swim Spa~Cabana Club~10% Off Open 2026 Wks

This home was very family friendly providing many things for kids of all ages!We enjoyed time on the dock fishing with the provided poles and bait. Kayaks and paddleboard were great to explore the area from the water. The indoor games and popcorn machine were a big hit with the kids and the margarita machine was enjoyed by the adults. The kitchen was well stocked with a variety of seasonings and pots and pans for cooking. The outdoor grills were clean and in good working order. Our host Sherry was very friendly and easy to communicate with. The spa pool was great! The cabana club was a bonus for pool time and tiki bar. We very much enjoyed our stay here and appreciated the effort Sherry puts in to make it relaxing for everyone!

We enjoyed our stay at this property. The kitchen had everything we needed throughout our stay. The bedrooms were large and the bathrooms even had soap, body wash, and shampoo provided! The location was amazing and we caught lots of fish off the dock in the backyard. We would definitely stay at this property again!

This property was PERFECT for our family vacation to the Keys! So many extra amenities and we used all of them! The property was very clean and had everything you needed. Sherry was a wonderful host, extremely responsive and made us feel at home. We will definitely be contacting Sherry again the next time we plan to visit the Keys!

Sherrie the host is outstanding and the property had pretty much everything you can think of to make our stay as great as possible.

The home was amazing. Our host did an exceptional job making it welcoming. Honestly they had it set up and ready to go for us like we would if we had family or friends coming to stay. I’ve never been at a VRBO that had so much thought put into, “how can we be helpful, what can we have so our guests have everything they need, etc.” 10 out 5 stars on hospitality. They went above and beyond.

Sherry had the house incredibly stocked. very clean and she was very accessible

Great stay for the week. Enjoyed fishing off the dock and swimming in the spa pool. Enjoyed the games and popcorn machine. Would stay again.

This was, honestly, the easiest review we have ever written. This house is wonderful and earns every one of 10/10 stars. It is immaculately clean. The beds are comfortable. Every amenity you could possibly want is thought of - popcorn maker, swim spa, ice maker, fishing rods, stand up paddleboard, kayaks (with vests), as well as snorkeling equipment. The dock overlooks a canal that is teaming with life. The host thinks of absolutely EVERYTHING for her guests. Towels, sunscreen, bug spray, detergent, spices - all here. This home wants for nothing in a vacation paradise. Sherry is a thoughtful and wonderful host who goes out of her way to make her home feel like yours. We also took advantage of her recommendation for Captain Jay for a fishing excursion with our son - a day which was nothing short of amazing - if you get a chance, book with him!!!!! We will be back, and often. Thank you for sharing your wonderful home with us!!!!

Owner strives for 10/10

This place has it all. Attention to details. The Owner provided anything you would want in a vacation rental. Awesome!

Great location, very responsive host and so much to keep our kids occupied. I've never stayed in vacation home that has so many cooking utensils, spices etc awesome!

We loved this house! There were so many amenities that came with it and made everything so convenient. Our kids really enjoyed the little pool and the Cabana Club. The owners were extremely helpful and nice. We want to book this house again for next year!

Property was delightful. Had everything needed for our stay; much more than we utilized.

Key colony beach house had amazing amenities to share with the teenagers and elementary school child such as paddleboard, kayaks, fishing poles and especially the game room and the full size hot tub spa. Almost forgot the popcorn maker that everyone enjoyed on multiple occasions!The restaurants in the area were fantastic island fish co and Sparky’s labding. And the proximity to other recreational activities like mermaid marathon tours and the adventure aquarium encounters made planning fun activities a breeze with a family. The hour and change drive from key west airport and a day trip there as well allowed us to enjoy the Hemingway house and Duval street.The other key amenity the cabana club we took full advantage of with the swimming pool and quaint beach.Overall this place was relaxing, super key decor with tons of amenities, super location and was spectacular!! Would stay here again in a heartbeat.

We enjoyed our stay at this home for the week! Many amenities available. We enjoyed the hot tub, fishing off the canal with bait from the bait freezer, ice machine, popcorn maker, kayaks and the Beach Club. There were also coffee pods for the keurig which was a nice perk. Would recommend.

. Mystical Seas is a gem and our week was so enjoyable. You won’t want or need for anything! This is now our go-to vacation rental in Key Colony Beach.

We stayed for a week in Jan. The property was just as described. We had 5 adults, our 3 kids and my husband and myself. We have stayed at VRBO's before, but NEVER one that has been this equipped, full of supplies and welcoming.Sherry thought of everything, plenty of beach towels, sunscreen, books for all ages, blankets in every room, working rods/reels, bait in the outside freezer for fishing, laundry soap, TP, paper towels, hand soap, dish soap, everything you need for a meal in the kitchen and the seasonings...OMG! Pantry even had supplies! Like I said, nowhere have we found a VRBO this well stocked, it was more like a home than a rental. Location was terrific. We ate at Key Colony Inn, service was SLOW but meal was fantastic. We did Landshore fishing, deep sea fishing and many excursions. 2 Grocery stores within 3 miles. The short walk to Sunset Beach is easy and the view is just amazing, go early to get a bench. This property is not pet friendly, however the town and restaurants are. So many dogs!!Sherry was great with communication, both before and after our stay. Only things i would note are..you have to walk through second bedroom to get to Primary. There is a door so wasn't an issue for us, but if it is a house full of couples...it might be. Furniture in living room could use a cleaning too. Overall a great stay, would book again in a heartbeat. Sherry is amazing and she shows that through her thoughtfully supplied/decorated home.

This place was awesome! We had an amazing time! Sherry was great! She was so helpful even before we got there with weather concerns. We would definitely stay here again. Plenty of room for everyone. My son enjoyed fishing everyday. She was even so helpful with things to do in the area. Wonderful experience! We felt right at home. Beautiful place so relaxing! Even had all the seasonings for our fish fry. Missing it now that we are home. Thank you Sherry! for everyone