Tappan Lake Area: Sunny, peaceful Cottage with Fishing Pond on 13 Gorgeous Acres

The property was perfect for us. The woods were a beautiful setting for my walk. The path was maintained, private, shady and provided a beautiful setting. The cottage was comfortable and nice. We would stay here again.

Always nice to stay here. So relaxing!

Beautiful, clean pet free cottage. We had a great time here.

What a nice place. Looking forward to visiting again. Just what we needed.

I enjoyed this cottage. The location is right behind the general store. The fishing location is marvelous. Peaceful location, and friendly people. You can't go wrong at this cottage. Looking forward to going here again soon.

We love the comfort of the home and the beautiful grounds. We keep coming back!

Was an excellent property.. had everything you needed!! Would recommend

Enjoyed the property and loved the nostalgic decor. Some of furniture predated me, so It was really interesting to be using these relics from the past. Just loved it! Our main purpose of this trip was bluegill fishing, and the pond below turned out to be far superior to Tappan Lake. Great place for beginners or kids with no patience to fish because there is no waiting for a hit with the traditional worm and bobber setup. There is a hose next to the door which came in handy for the dog that can't stay out of the water. We brought our own utility blanket for her to lay on when wet. At Tappan Lake, the ticks were super thick, but we didn't pick up any on the property, probably because the trail is wide and clear, and the grassy areas were well kept and short. We found a couple morels growing next to the picnic table. A mallard has nest near the other trailer. Walking up the hill for some ice cream at the General Store is a must. My wife recommends the 4 scoop sampler. Had a great time, and hope to return while the aging dogs are still with us. They really loved it.

Very cozy and comfortable. We really enjoyed looking at the artwork beautifully arranged throughout the house. We are looking forward to coming again. The people at the general store are wonderful!!!

Wonderful stay and cottage had everything we needed.

The cabin was great as usual. Host was amazing. Great stay.

Home was very clean , well maintained and the property was lovely. Jim was wonderful as a host......we will stay again....

Clean and fully equipped kitchen. We love the upstairs room! TV is great. I love getting out on the trail around the spring fed pond. So peaceful!

Great little house. Felt comfortable immediately. Loved the fishing pond.

We have been to the cottage many times. It is always peaceful and relaxing. Always stocked with everything you may need. My dog absolutely loves it here.

Wonderful place to stay!

We very much enjoyed our stay. The house was beautiful and well equipped and the property was well kept. It was pet friendly and very spacious. Although we didn't have little ones, the loft area was very cute for a family with kids. My husband very much enjoyed the private fishing pond.

Very nice place to stay. Very clean. Lots of deer to watch.

Had a great time .

Clean and quiet! Right between two good fishing lakes!

This was our 4th stay. As always, never disappoints!Jim is an awesome host.

We loved our stay!! Everything was beautiful and we plan to return with our kids and grandkids!

Beautiful and relaxing especially for my mother who was having surgery the following week.

Cozy cottage on a beautiful property. Well equipped for kids and adults alike (games, movies, books, fire pit). Hosts were amazing…very communicative and helpful. Close to Tappan Lake and within walking distance of a wonderful General Store that has been in business for over 100 years…they make their own ice cream! So much fun and very relaxing.

Everything was just as described! The cottage was comfy for all six of us and the property was beautiful! We enjoyed fishing in the private pond and curling up inside with books and movies when the storms rolled in!

The property was lovely. The path to the pond was not the only hiking path. There was one that was even longer that was great. The cottage was great. My husband and I and our adult daughters had enough room and the kitchen was great. Communication was great. Jim was friendly and responsive to our emails. Great stay.

Great host,very attentive..Super clean rental

Great property, everything you could possibly need is provided. Great communication with property owners. Very clean and spacious!

We stay here every year and are never disappointed.Overall great place to stay.

This cottage home and property always in top condition. Have been there about four times through the years and always have loved it! Our dog has room to enjoy outside, cleanliness is great, and ice cream at the general store!

I was looking for a reset weekend. Got to relax and enjoy nature from deer to pine squirrels and ground hogs. Pond was nice lots of hungry fish, not very relaxing when they bit one after another. All around great weekend.

The cottage was comfortable and clean. Had everything we needed. Fire pit was a plus. Neighborhood was quiet. The pond was lovely. Parking was a little tricky with the boat but we made it work. Honestly we wish we stayed longer. It was close distance to a few lakes so we went to different ones. A plus also having the general store close by. Would definitely consider booking again when we come back to the area. Host was very responsive and friendly. Nothing negative about the stay. Would recommend!.

Well maintained and every effort to make sure that everything possible is ready for your enjoyment. Very thoughtful and interesting decorations.

Always a pleasant stay at Jim and Eleni’s! My son always finds something new to entertain himself with upstairs in the kid area, and the beds are so comfortable. Enough space for a family of three to spread out and also spend time together. We wait to come back!

Been there before, that's why I came back.

We love this cottage. It’s clean and comfortable, with intriguing decorative items to discover. The walking trail and spring fed pond are especially lovely. Our favorite in the area!

This was a nice place to stay, easy to get the Lake!!