3rd of 6 Premier Waterfront Vacation Rentals on Long Island NY in Wine Country of Famed North Fork

We loved everything about our stay at the cottage. Such beautiful property and surroundings. If you’re looking to spend some quality time with family in a quiet setting with beautiful surroundings , look no further. Thanks Sandy. We will be Back.

We were 3 adults and were comfortable, but not a lot of room to spare - there could be a little less furniture. It's a peaceful setting with beautiful surroundings. The quaint town of Riverhead is close by. Sandy was was a responsive host.

These cottages are beautiful and we had a lovely experience. Two small issues to address: 1) property manager was not clear on beach pass access. We missed out on a day at the beach because we didn't realize the house came with a pass. This was never communicated to us. 2) if you have a dog, you are going to be told you need to leash the dog at all times outside even if you have your own yard with the house. Not necessarily something we planned for.

This was just what we were looking for. The cottage is in a small town with little traffic and few tourists. So, it was peaceful and we didn't need to wear masks most of the time. We had lots of fun kayaking from the cottage and relaxing in the sun. As others have noted, John and Sandy were wonderful hosts and it was a great spot for our dog. We took several day trips to wineries, outlet mall, North Fork, and South Fork locations. There are so many beaches in the area and they were not crowded. It could not have been a nicer week!

My girlfriend and I absolutely loved Sandy’s cottage and will certainly be coming back. The cottages are on a quiet river bank in a large and beautifully manicured estate. The history of the land is interesting in itself, but Sandy and her husband have done a great job of making the property very welcoming and enjoyable. It’s well off the main road so very well secluded, The river opens up into the massive bay maybe 100 yards down. The cottage itself was very cozy, we loved the three seasons porch off the back. We will certainly be going again soon

This is a miraculous peaceful place, that is an amazing combination of laid back and modern facilities! The owner have mastered the art of being right there for every need but without being in any way intrusive or too present like in other cottages we have been. The cottages are wonderful and artsy , and the grounds are like from a movie setting. We were 4 adults , one 2 year old and a Great Dane , and the 2 room cottage was suitable. We stayed for 1 month, and I am glad we did, made exellent memories with my daughter and my elderly parents in a beautiful place.

I am 2 weeks into a 3 week stay at the J&S Reeves Cottages and am so happy that we chose to shelter here while waiting to move into a new house. The cottage is bright, clean, and comfortable. The setting is tranquil with a peaceful view of the creek. The paddle boards and kayaks have been a blast. The four area beaches are close by and not crowded at all. I thought we may get bored and be on top of each other after three weeks but there is so much to do and explore in the area. Definitely will come back!