Whaling Captain Pierson's Apartment TOO

Beautiful location! Wonderful water views and an easy walk to town

Lower level of an older house. Enjoyed watching the sunsets over the cove from the small screened in porch. Did have to clean off the porch furniture but it was pollen season after all. A minor issue with the heat but the owners resolved it quickly. Overall a perfectly nice stay.

My boyfriend (now fiancé!) stayed here for 2 nights. The house was warm and cozy and had really nice energy. Our host was a great communicator and he greeted us as we pulled up. The house had everything we needed. It was within walking distance of Sag Harbor’s quaint downtown. The views from the house were picturesque, particularly at sunset. We got engaged on this trip and this was the perfect place to do it! Will definitely visit again. Thank you!

I recently had the pleasure of staying at Paris's incredible home, and I cannot say enough positive things about my experience. From the moment I arrived, it was clear that this would be a fantastic stay. - First and foremost, the home itself is absolutely beautiful. Every detail has been thoughtfully considered. The space was spotless and inviting, making it easy to feel right at home; what set this stay apart was Paris. He ensured that I had everything I needed, was incredibly responsive, and provided excellent recommendations for things to do and places to eat; he made me feel welcome from the start and was always available to answer any questions or provide assistance. I cannot wait to stay here again!

Cozy, comfortable and quiet, this absolutely charming 'cottage / luxury home' has incredible views of the water. The manager was very respectful of our privacy.

Stay was fine. Place is quaint and well located. Only bedrooms were air conditioned ( July 15 &very hot outside) master bed is small ( double?) Pillows could use a refresh.

My elderly mother, my two cats (who have never traveled), and I all had such a relaxing, refreshing, and incredible experience thanks to Paris and Clifton’s attentiveness to detail and welcoming spirit. The house was more than expected when we arrived. The photos on here are fantastic and thorough, but they don’t really show how close to the water you are which was the best surprise! The view, particularly from the screened sunroom, kitchen, and deck, is breathtakingly serene. It, along with the beautiful, historic home filled with so many charming antiques and interesting details, matched with Paris’ warm welcome and telling us of the history of the home all immediately immerse you in the spirit of Sag Harbor. We had only traveled one hour east to come here, but it felt like we had been transported hundreds of miles away. And the best part was that the 2 cats also loved it! They specifically enjoyed the screened sunroom. It was such a relief to be able to bring them with us and Paris and Clifton were so easygoing and inviting towards them and us which enabled us to truly relax. I did make sure to “cat proof” the home when we arrived (I brought my own bedding, put away anything I thought they could break, and covered any upholstered furniture with throw blankets), but that was all my doing as I wanted to be a considerate guest, having brought my pets with me. I really can’t say enough good things about this home. The location is ideal. It’s right on the cove with a large piece of beautiful property and still only a few minutes from all the shops and restaurants down on Main Street in Sag Harbor. We had only two days of sunshine while there and two cloudy days, but the sunsets on the water on the sunny days were unmatched to any I’ve ever seen and we enjoyed them directly from the screened sunroom in our beyond immaculate and spacious apartment. This place is perfect for any person of any age (my mother has a slightly hard time walking and the very few steps she had to navigate were not a problem, which was a big relief)! It was stocked with just about any item you can imagine, especially the gorgeous kitchen, and the attention to the small details - even the antique toilet paper holder and the fantastic smelling sachet bag in the bedroom closet - made this place a warm, gorgeous, and very comfortable place to stay, all thanks to Paris and Clifton. I would stay here again, no question, and you should as well!

GREAT location in Sag Harbor - walking distance to everything in the village, while providing the quiet and waterfront views of a great escape. The host welcomes you personally with a wonderful story of the history of this old captain's house. While restaurants are within a 10 minute walk, there is also shopping if you want to stock up the fridge and hang out close to the property. The beds are comfy and the cable works. Nature close by - saw 3 deer on an early Sunday walk. Great alternative to the hotels in the village, we were so happy we chose this option.

We adored staying here. Large apartment, immaculately clean, simple and charming decor located a few blocks away from downtown. Perfect for an evening walk to and from any of the great restaurants on Main Street. Bedding was immaculately fresh and clean, an important factor for me. View of the water is beautiful with a cup of coffee in the morning and a glass of wine at night. My husband and I and our two pups felt entirely comfortable and can't wait to return. Paris was a lovely host!

Very happy stay, nicer in person.