Sanibel Homes For Sale By Owner (418 Homes)

  • Home For Sale $549,000
    • 2Bed
    • 2Baths
    • 1,260Sq ft
    827 E Gulf DR #H6, Sanibel, Florida

    This charming two bedroom, two bathroom, second floor turn-key unit is the perfect place to relax... Read More

  • Home For Sale $534,000
    • 2Bed
    • 2Baths
    • 1,260Sq ft
    827 E Gulf DR #A1, Sanibel, Florida

    Open kitchen and corner location (no common wall on lanai) in sought after "a" building.... Read More

  • Home For Sale $1,749,000
    • 3Bed
    • 4Baths
    • 7,152Sq ft
    6014 White Heron LN, Sanibel, Florida

    Boaters: this is your dream home! a spacious 3bed, 3.5bath pool home with boat dock and lift just... Read More

  • Home For Sale $540,000
    • 3Bed
    • 2Baths
    • 1,916Sq ft
    1339 Tahiti DR, Sanibel, Florida

    Large duplex in one of the best beach access community in sanibel. the tradewinds community... Read More

  • Vacant Land For Sale $267,555
    6095 Dinkins Lake RD, Sanibel, Florida

    This over sized parcel is the result of combining two separate lots into one property. lot #12 is... Read More

  • Home For Sale $489,000
    • 2Bed
    • 2Baths
    • 3,331Sq ft
    1764 Bunting LN, Sanibel, Florida

    Located on a large lot in the popular gumbo limbo neighborhood this 2 bedroom 2 bath home has... Read More

  • Home For Sale $738,000
    • 3Bed
    • 2Baths
    • 4,126Sq ft
    4455 Gulf Pines DR, Sanibel, Florida

    Privately nestled on a large double lot in one of sanibel‘s most sought after locations, gulf... Read More

  • Home For Sale $675,000
    • 3Bed
    • 2Baths
    • 1,850Sq ft
    6141 Henderson RD, Sanibel, Florida

    This quaint cottage has been beautifully remodeled featuring a sparkling new pool with tanning... Read More

  • Home For Sale $599,000
    • 3Bed
    • 2Baths
    • 3,388Sq ft
    9426 Beverly LN, Sanibel, Florida

    This beautifully remodeled 3 bedroom 2 bath home is located on a quiet street in the quiet gumbo... Read More

  • Home For Sale $460,000
    • 3Bed
    • 2Baths
    • 2,460Sq ft
    560 Piedmont RD, Sanibel, Florida

    Perfectly charming sanibel island cottage in a serene setting is an ideal vacation spot for you... Read More

  • Home For Sale $1,199,000
    • 4Bed
    • 5Baths
    • 7,699Sq ft
    2857 Wulfert RD, Sanibel, Florida

    Sanctuary estate living at it’s finest with this 4 br plus den, 5 bth, 4700 sqft home. beautiful... Read More

  • Vacant Land For Sale $223,000
    486 Ponce De Leon RD, Sanibel, Florida

    Located in a quiet neighborhood, this lot totals approximately .75 acres providing plenty of area... Read More

  • Home For Sale $1,449,000
    • 4Bed
    • 4Baths
    • 5,816Sq ft
    790 Beach RD, Sanibel, Florida

    The ultimate in island living, this canal front home has it all! located on the beautiful east... Read More

  • Home For Sale $6,995,000
    • 5Bed
    • 6Baths
    • 12,515Sq ft
    1314 SEASPRAY LN, Sanibel, Florida

    New construction on the beach! available for immediate occupancy on feb 1, 2020. gorgeous coastal... Read More

  • Home For Sale $1,949,000
    • 4Bed
    • 5Baths
    • 6,940Sq ft
    5633 BALTUSROL CT, Sanibel, Florida

    Brand new construction! awesome lot location w/championship golf course setting w/ southern... Read More

  • Home For Sale $549,000
    • 2Bed
    • 2Baths
    • 1,022Sq ft
    845 E Gulf DR #1512, Sanibel, Florida

    Nicely updated 2 br/2ba 2nd floor corner unit located on the canal side. this condo has been... Read More

  • Home For Sale $949,000
    • 3Bed
    • 2Baths
    • 5,320Sq ft
    201 Violet DR, Sanibel, Florida

    Marvel in the beauty of this grand, old florida home as you walk up the double staircase with... Read More

  • Home For Sale $1,045,000
    • 2Bed
    • 2Baths
    • 1,425Sq ft
    979 E Gulf DR #E514, Sanibel, Florida

    This is a very rare to the market direct gulf front penthouse corner unit in sanibel's popular... Read More

  • Vacant Land For Sale $339,000
    5847 Pine Tree DR, Sanibel, Florida

    One of only a handful of vacant canal lots remaining on sanibel and this one is priced to sell.... Read More

  • Home For Sale $759,000
    • 3Bed
    • 3Baths
    • 3,714Sq ft
    1068 White Ibis DR, Sanibel, Florida

    This beautiful ground level home is in a serene setting on the water and is just steps to a... Read More

Sanibel - Statistics and Home Trends

Actives Activity Chart


$ 1,547,634




$ 327

Average Price
3 Bed Condos For Sale in SANIBEL (1) $ 675,000


$ 1,402,195




$ 389

Average Price
Land in SANIBEL (77) $ 717,871


$ 1,304,435




$ N/A

Learn More About Sanibel, Florida

Currently there are 341 homes for sale, 1 condos and apartments for sale and 77 vacant land for sale in Sanibel

Background, General Information and Weather in Sanibel, Florida –
Sanibel is both an island and city found in Lee County, Florida. The population here at the time of the 2010 census was 6,469. The population only increased slightly in 2012 when a local survey was taken. At that time the population here was 6,741. As of the most recent non census related survey taken the population had increased slightly with roughly 7,351 residents. Sanibel is part of the Cape Coral – Fort Myers, Florida Metro Statistical Area. Sanibel is often referred to as “Sanibel Island” and is what is known as a barrier island. A barrier island is essentially a coastal landform and a type of dune system that is known for being exceptionally flat or lumpy with areas of sand that were formed by wave and tidal action just parallel to the mainland coast. These types of islands usually occur in chairs. Most times there are a few of these islands but there are some instances where there are more than a dozen of them. Most of the city is located at the east end of Sanibel Island. This city was incorporated back in 1974. Sanibel is extremely easy to access which makes it a very popular tourist destination. This area is known for its shell beaches as well as wildlife refuges. One of the most interesting things about Sanibel is that more than half of the island is made up of wildlife refuges. According to the United States Census Bureau, Sanibel is a total of 33.25 square miles with 16.12 of that being water. When it comes to the weather here in Sanibel it falls into the category of “Humid Subtropical.” This means that the summer months will be long, hot and wet where as the winter months will be very short, extremely comfortable but windy. Throughout the course of the year you can expect to see temperatures range from the mid 50s through the mid 90s. The hot season here lasts for four and a half months. From the end of May until the beginning of October the daily average high is just about 86 degrees. The low for this time is a very breezy 77 degrees. The warmest time of the year here is in August when the daily average high is about 90 degrees. The cool season on the other hand lasts for less than three months. From mid December until the beginning of March the daily average high is the same as the low for the summer months coming in at 77 degrees. The low for this time is a somewhat chilly 57 degrees. The coolest time of the year here is mid-January. Sanibel receives close to 60 inches of rain per year and absolutely no snow. This is the perfect place to retire if you looking for a city with gorgeous weather year round.

Sanibel Public Library –
The Sanibel Public Library was built back in 1994 and was a whopping 19,000 square feet at that time. In 2004 this public library was expanded adding an additional 10,386 square feet which brought the grand square feet total to just under 30,000. Here you will find more than 60,000 books. This library is also a charter member of the Southwest Florida Library Network. If you were looking to escape the beaches for some peace and quiet, this is the place to do it. Most people typically spend several hours here exploring all this massive library has to offer.

Fun Things to do in Sanibel –
Blind Pass Beach is somewhat off the beaten path but is worth the trek. This small beach is the perfect place to find tons of shells that have washed ashore. But make sure you are careful near the water since the current is pretty strong and swimming is not encouraged at this beach. Most people usually come here to tan and collect shells. If you were looking to take a break from all the tanning and shell collecting you can take a trip over to the 5,200 acre J.N Darling National Wildlife Refuge. This place is a must see regardless if you live here or are vacationing here. This wildlife refuge was founded by an editorial cartoonist from Iowa and is now home to hundreds of animals. Here you will find crocodiles, several different kinds of birds as well as the endangered giant manatees.

Summary –
Sanibel is a gorgeous island community located in Florida. This is the perfect place to live if you were looking for a laid back lifestyle and plenty of outdoor recreation. Make sure to check out Sanibel is you are thinking of making the move out to Florida! offers For Sale By Owner listing services throughout the country. By posting home with ByOwner your property will get the same exposure you’d receive from a traditional real estate company. Our Sanibel, Florida Flat Fee MLS listing Service saves you from paying the traditional 6% commission charged by most real estate offices, but gives you the same worldwide exposure.

Your home will be found on the local MLS, plus all the major search engines and popular real estate portal sites, including: Trulia, Zillow,, MSN, AOL, Bing, Yahoo, and of course Google. Additionally when your home gets added to the MLS, your FSBO listing will listed alongside of the homes listed by ReMax, C-21, Coldwell Banker, ERA, Redfin, Movoto, Keller Williams and all the other nationwide brokerage sites. These sites often display “all” of the MLS postings, not just their own, which means your home will be on these sites also.

The average seller who uses our Flat Rate MLS Listing, will save over $15,000. We give you the tools and exposure you need as a ForSaleByOwner to compete with every other listing in the MLS. But you are in control of the savings and the fees you pay.

Currently Sanibel has 419 properties on the market for sale. The inventory was last updated 01/26/2020. Of these properties, 341 single family homes are for sale by their owners in Sanibel, and 1 condos are for sale by their owners in Sanibel. The average price of the single family homes for sale in Sanibel, is $1,547,634, the average condo price in Sanibel, is $1,402,195. The average price per square foot of the active inventory is $239. This is based the living area square footage.

Over the last year, there have been 1,067 of properties sold in Sanibel. Of these properties, 1,001 single family homes have sold by their owners in Sanibel, and 4 condos have sold by their owners in Sanibel. The average sales price of the single family homes sold in Sanibel, is $1,373,696. Single family homes have been selling for 71 per square foot of living area. The average sales price of the condos for sale in Sanibel, is $1,270,909. Condos have been selling for 552 per square foot of living area.

The most active subdivisions with listings for sale in Sanibel, are: Metes And Bounds (24 For Sale), Sanctuary At Wulfert (23 For Sale), Gumbo Limbo (14 For Sale), Pointe Santo De Sanibel Condo (13 For Sale), Beachview Country Club Estates (13 For Sale), Not Applicable (12 For Sale), Loggerhead Cay Condo (11 For Sale), Dunes At Sanibel Island (11 For Sale), Shell Harbor (10 For Sale), Sundial Of Sanibel (8 For Sale)

If you are thinking of selling your Sanibel home, try our flat fee listing service, Our list fees start at $449, and may save you $15,000 in real estate commissions. Click here to start saving.

Disclaimer: Listing broker has attempted to offer accurate data, but buyers/lessees are advised to confirm all information IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use that it may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing, and that data is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed accurate by the MLS. The MLS may, at its discretion, require use of other disclaimers as necessary to protect Participants and/or the MLS from liability.
This data up-to-date as of 01/26/2020