16 Elizabeth Street, Port Jervis, New York image 1
Active

16 Elizabeth Street

Port Jervis, NY 12771
Mark as Favorite
$535,000 $2,255/Mo
Get Pre-Approved Check your credit
Bed 5

Bed

Bath 4

Bath

Acres0.18

Acre(Lot)

Built in 1880, this brick Victorian residence seamlessly blends historic elegance, architectural detail, and modern functionality. The beautifully preserved brick main structure exudes durability and classic charm. The front porch features an ornamental pavilion crowned with a faceted pointed roof - a striking detail reflecting the artistry of Victorian design. Together, the sculptured porch and brick exterior create a warm and inviting facade. A standout feature is the 2025 Brava synthetic slate roof, accented by copper rakes, valleys, drip edges, and custom copper detailing over the bay window. Delivering the timeless appearance of natural slate with exceptional durability and minimal maintenance, it beautifully complements the original bluestone window headers. In 2024, all flat roofs w ere replaced, and in 2023, Leaf Gutter systems were installed for added convenience. The custom gingerbread trim, inspired by a historic home in Orleans, Cape Cod, incorporates sixteen Gothic cusps as a subtle nod to the house number. These intricate architectural details create exceptional curb appeal while honoring the home's Victorian heritage. Inside, the owner's residence is thoughtfully designed for both comfortable everyday living and entertaining. The main level features an inviting entry hall adorned with Thibaut wall coverings, a sun-filled living room showcasing original architectural details, and a formal dining room enhanced by an arched bay window, Egg & Dart crown moldings, and beautifully appointed old English Greeff (F. Schumacker & Co.) wallpaper. Off the dining room, a charming coffee conservatory with classic black-and-white checkered floors creates a delightful alcove for morning coffee, a favorite book, or evening cocktails. Bathed in natural light and perfectly suited for botanical displays, this unique space offers a rare touch of conservatory-inspired living seldom found in today's homes. The eat-in kitchen, accented with wainscoting, is rich in character and features butcher block countertops, solid wood cabinetry, stainless steel appliances, and a skylight that fills the space with natural light. A convenient mudroom and full bath add practicality to the home's historic charm. Upstairs, you'll find three bedrooms, all featuring original hardwood flooring, a dedicated home office, and a second full bath. Two bedrooms showcase beautiful stained-glass windows, while three cedar closets provide additional character and functionality. Additionally, two legal units (not pictured) offer exceptional flexibility for rental income, guest accommodations, a variety of living conditions, or a private workspace, however, can potentially be converted to a one or two family home. Outside, a private fenced garden provides a peaceful retreat with mature plantings that offer season-long color. Fig and hydrangea trees, David Austin roses, lavender, and other established perennials create a picturesque setting that enhances the home's architecture. Beyond the garden lies a portion of historic Drew Field, included as part of the property. Once owned by the Drew Methodist Church and the setting for cherished community sunrise services, this expansive green space of lawn of (an additional 0.35 acres) and mature trees provides a rare sense of openness, privacy, and connection to the area's history. Combining architectural significance, modern updates, income-producing potential, and enchanting gardens, this extraordinary Victorian offers a rare opportunity to own a truly one-of-a-kind property. Rich in history yet perfectly suited for modern living, it is a home to be cherished for generations.

Read More Expand

Detail Ic Property Details

Property Type : Residential Income

Price : $535,000

AD Id : 88910650

MLS Id : 1031408

Beds : 5

Lot Size : 0.18 Acre

Year Built : 1880

Garage : 2

County : Orange

  • Map Map

Map

Map What's Nearby

Map Nearby Areas

Feature Features

  • Bedroom Information

    Total beds: 5

    Bathroom Information

    Total Baths: 4 Full Baths: 4

    Room Information

    Basement: Partial, Unfinished, Walk-Out Access

  • Flooring Information

    Carpet, Hardwood, Tile

  • Interior Features

    Crown Molding

  • Heating & Cooling

    Has Heating: Yes Heating: Natural Gas Cooling: None

  • Building Information

    Year Built: 1880 Building Area Total: 3430 Construction Materials: Brick, Vinyl Siding Patio And Porch Features: Covered, Porch Private Pool: No

  • Exterior Features

    Exterior Features: Garden

  • Lot Information

    Lot Size Acres: 0.1808 Lot Size Square Feet: 7875 Lot Description: Back Yard, Garden, Near Public Transit, See Remarks

  • Listing Price Information

    Listing Price: $535000

  • Tax Information

    Parcel Number: 331300-008-000-0013-016.000-0000 Annual Tax: $8303

  • School Information

    Elementary School: East Main Street Elementary School
    Junior High School: Port Jervis Middle School
    Senior High School: Port Jervis Senior High School

  • Utility Information

    Natural Gas Available, Electricity Connected, Natural Gas Connected, Sewer Connected, Water Connected

  • Location Information

    Direction: GPS Navigable WaterSource: Public
Sell a home like this and save $31,601 Find out How

How much is this property worth?

Curious about this home's true market value? Use our free Home Evaluation Tool to instantly get a personalized Comparative Market Analysis (CMA) report. Make smarter, data-driven decisions before you buy.

Images
Loading, please wait...

Nearby Home Value

Address Estimate Bed Bath Sq. Ft Lot Size
27 Elizabeth Street, Port Jervis, NY, 12771 $369,000 4 -- --
31 Lumber Street, Port Jervis, NY, 12771 $320,000 -- -- --

Similar Multifamily To 16 Elizabeth Street

Nearby For Sale

Slider Thumb
Active
Mark as Favorite
$320,000
Multifamily For Sale

31 Lumber Street,
Port Jervis, NY, 12771

Acres0.11

Acre(Lot)
Slider Thumb
Active
Mark as Favorite
$535,000
Multifamily For Sale

16 Elizabeth Street,
Port Jervis, NY, 12771

Bed 5

Bed

Bath 4

Bath

Acres0.18

Acre(Lot)
Slider Thumb
Active
Mark as Favorite
$369,000
Multifamily For Sale

27 Elizabeth Street,
Port Jervis, NY, 12771

Bed 4

Bed

Acres0.24

Acre(Lot)

The data relating to real estate for sale on this website comes in part from the Internet Data exchange of OneKey MLS. IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Copyright © 2026 OneKey MLS. All Rights Reserved

ByOwner last updated this listing 08/26/2026 @ 19:29

MLS: 1031408 LISTED BY: Dominick Tufano, RE/MAX Benchmark Realty Group 845-341-0004 SOURCE: OneKey MLS

More Cities with for Sale by Owner Homes

Homes around $535,000

Slider Thumb
Active
Mark as Favorite
$339,900
Home For Sale

104 N Orange Street,
Port Jervis, NY, 12771

Bed 4

Bed

Bath 2

Bath

SqFt1,685

Sqft

Acres0.10

Acre(Lot)
Slider Thumb
Active
Mark as Favorite
$349,000
Home For Sale

17 Kellogg Avenue,
Port Jervis, NY, 12771

Bed 3

Bed

Bath 1

Bath

SqFt1,450

Sqft

Acres0.17

Acre(Lot)
Slider Thumb
Active
Mark as Favorite
$349,900
Home For Sale

8 Sullivan Avenue,
Port Jervis, NY, 12771

Bed 4

Bed

Bath 2

Bath

SqFt2,326

Sqft

Acres0.10

Acre(Lot)
Slider Thumb
Active
Mark as Favorite
$350,000
Home For Sale

54 Hudson Street,
Port Jervis, NY, 12771

Bed 4

Bed

Bath 2

Bath

SqFt2,000

Sqft

Acres0.14

Acre(Lot)
Slider Thumb
Active
Mark as Favorite
$369,000
Multifamily For Sale

27 Elizabeth Street,
Port Jervis, NY, 12771

Bed 4

Bed

Acres0.24

Acre(Lot)
Slider Thumb
Active
Mark as Favorite
$375,000
Home For Sale

6 Kellogg Avenue,
Port Jervis, NY, 12771

Bed 4

Bed

Bath 1

Bath

SqFt1,536

Sqft

Acres0.07

Acre(Lot)
Slider Thumb
Active
Mark as Favorite
$375,000
Home For Sale

62 Shin Hollow Road,
Port Jervis, NY, 12771

Bed 3

Bed

Bath 2

Bath

SqFt1,568

Sqft

Acres7.30

Acres(Lot)
Slider Thumb
Active
Mark as Favorite
$439,900
Home For Sale

9 Carpenter Road,
Port Jervis, NY, 12771

Bed 3

Bed

Bath 3

Bath

SqFt1,976

Sqft

Acres0.52

Acre(Lot)
Slider Thumb
Active
Mark as Favorite
$489,000
Home For Sale

6 Mark Drive,
Port Jervis, NY, 12771

Bed 3

Bed

Bath 2

Bath

SqFt1,716

Sqft

Acres0.47

Acre(Lot)
Slider Thumb
Active
Mark as Favorite
$500,000
Home For Sale

117 E Main Street,
Port Jervis, NY, 12771

Bed 5

Bed

Bath 4

Bath

SqFt3,531

Sqft

Acres0.32

Acre(Lot)
Slider Thumb
Active
Mark as Favorite
$519,000
Home For Sale

236 Springbrook Road,
Port Jervis, NY, 12771

Bed 3

Bed

Bath 3

Bath

SqFt1,738

Sqft

Acres3.20

Acres(Lot)
Slider Thumb
Active
Mark as Favorite
$539,900
Home For Sale

2 James Place,
Port Jervis, NY, 12771

Bed 4

Bed

Bath 3

Bath

SqFt1,994

Sqft

Acres1.34

Acres(Lot)
Slider Thumb
Active
Mark as Favorite
$540,000
Mobile Homes For Sale

56 Sleepy Hollow Road,
Port Jervis, NY, 12771

Bed 3

Bed

Bath 2

Bath

SqFt1,560

Sqft

Acres5

Acres(Lot)
Slider Thumb
Active
Mark as Favorite
$569,900
Home For Sale

257 Fort Van Tyle Road,
Port Jervis, NY, 12771

Bed 3

Bed

Bath 2

Bath

SqFt2,208

Sqft

Acres1.60

Acres(Lot)
Slider Thumb
Active
Mark as Favorite
$588,000
Home For Sale

1 Van Avenue,
Port Jervis, NY, 12771

Bed 2

Bed

Bath 2

Bath

SqFt1,918

Sqft

Acres12.70

Acres(Lot)
Slider Thumb
Active
Mark as Favorite
$598,000
Home For Sale

36 Sleepy Hollow Road,
Port Jervis, NY, 12771

Bed 3

Bed

Bath 2

Bath

SqFt1,764

Sqft

Acres2

Acres(Lot)
Slider Thumb
Active
Mark as Favorite
$609,900
Home For Sale

5 James Place,
Port Jervis, NY, 12771

Bed 4

Bed

Bath 3

Bath

SqFt2,078

Sqft

Acres1

Acre(Lot)
Slider Thumb
Active
Mark as Favorite
$650,000
Home For Sale

25 Delaware Street,
Port Jervis, NY, 12771

Bed 7

Bed

Bath 2

Bath

SqFt3,024

Sqft

Acres0.19

Acre(Lot)

Selling? Save $31,601 when you sell a home like this

Tour with a ByOwner Agent