Active

2386 Route 5 Rd

Sheridan, NY 14136

$799,900 $3,372/Mo

Get Pre-Approved Check your credit

Overview

Bed

Bath

4,192

Sqft

2.40

Acres(Lot)

Description

Experience waterfront living at its finest in this custom-built 5-bedroom, 3.5-bath home on Eagle Bay, boasting more than 200 feet of unobstructed Lake Erie frontage & breathtaking views. Reinstall the outdoor stairs for full access to the private beach & water below. This home features an extraordinary open-concept living space designed to maximize the waterfront setting, w/ soaring cathedral ceilings, a stunning wall of windows, & endless lake views.The chef's kitchen is appointed with custom Amish-crafted cabinetry, quartz countertops, & overlooks the great room, dining area, & breakfast bar, ensuring the water remains the focal point. The great room's wood-burning fireplace provides the perfect gathering space. Privately situated on the main level, the primary suite offers a peaceful r etreat with a sitting area, walk-in closet, built-in wardrobe and full bath. A second first-floor bedroom w/ patio access & full bath provides flexibility for guests or multi-generational living. Upstairs, 3 additional bedrooms & a full bath accompany a covered balcony overlooking the grounds. Recent updates include a new roof (2025) & several windows (2026). With over 200' of unobstructed Lake Erie views, this is a private waterfront sanctuary!

Property Details

Property Type : Residential

Price : $799,900

AD Id : 78026921

MLS Id : B1679089

Beds : 5

Lot Size : 2.40 Acres

Living Area Size : 4,192

Year Built : 1991

Garage : 2.5

County : Chautauqua

Map

What's Nearby

Nearby Areas

Features

Bedroom Information

Total beds: 5

Bathroom Information

Total Baths: 4 Full Baths: 3 Half Baths: 1

Room Information

Rooms Total: 15 Has Basement: Yes Basement: Partial
Flooring Information

Carpet, Ceramic Tile, Hardwood, Tile, Varies
Roofing Information

Metal
Interior Features

Breakfast Bar, Ceiling Fan(s), Cathedral Ceiling(s), Entrance Foyer, Kitchen Island, Pantry, High Speed Internet, Master Downstairs Roof: Metal Appliances: Built-In Range, Double Oven, Dryer, Dishwasher, Electric Cooktop, Exhaust Fan, Gas Water Heater, Microwave, Refrigerator, Range Hood, Washer, Oven, Water Heater Laundry Features: Main Level Window Features: Drapes, Window Treatments
Heating & Cooling

Has Heating: Yes Heating: Natural Gas, Exhaust Fan, Zoned, Baseboard Has Cooling: Yes Cooling: Ceiling Fan(s), Zoned Water front: 1

Building Information

Year Built: 1991 Building Area Total: 4192 Construction Materials: Brick, Stucco Stories: 2 Frontage Length: 229 Patio And Porch Features: Patio, Covered, Porch Pool Features: In Ground, Outdoor Pool, Private Private Pool: Yes Water front Features: Lake View: Water
Exterior Features

Exterior Features: Balcony, Private Yard

Lot Information

Lot Dimensions: 185X512 Main Square Feet: 2.4 Acres Lot Size Acres: 2.4 Lot Description: Irregular Lot, Secluded, Waterfront

Listing Price Information

Listing Price: $799900 Original Price: $849900 Cash, Conventional, VA Loan

Tax Information

Parcel Number: 066400-048-005-0001-001-000 Tax Lot: 1 Annual Tax: $10792

Parking Information

Attached, Garage, Other, Asphalt, Concrete

Garage Information

Has Garage: Yes Has Attached Garage: Yes Garage Space: 2.5

Homeowners Association Information
Association Amenities: None

Utility Information

Cable Available, Electricity Connected, Water Connected
Location Information

Direction: I-90 to exit 58 towards Silver Creek. US-20 to Village of Silver Creek then proceed to Route 5. Property is on the right hand side. Address AKA 2386 Lake Ave Silver Creek NY 14136 WaterSource: Public

Sell a home like this and save $47,495 Find out How

How much is this property worth?

Curious about this home's true market value? Use our free Home Evaluation Tool to instantly get a personalized Comparative Market Analysis (CMA) report. Make smarter, data-driven decisions before you buy.

Loading, please wait...

Nearby Home Value

Address	Estimate	Bed	Bath	Sq. Ft	Lot Size
1985 Route 5, Sheridan, NY, 14136	$96,900	2	1	753	753 SqFt
2728 Rt-5, Sheridan, NY, 14136	$189,900	1	1	1,204	1,204 SqFt
12374 Pennsylvania Avenue, Sheridan, NY, 14136	$259,000	4	2	2,086	2,086 SqFt
2241 Route 5 Lake Road, Sheridan, NY, 14136	$75,000	2	1	1,576	1,576 SqFt

Similar Homes To 2386 Route 5 Rd

Nearby For Sale

Active

$96,900

Home For Sale

1985 Route 5,
Sheridan, NY, 14136

Bed

Bath

Sqft

Acres(Lot)

2386 Route 5 Rd,
Sheridan, NY, 14136

Bed

Bath

Sqft

Acres(Lot)

10652 W Sheridan Drive,
Sheridan, NY, 14048

Bed

Bath

Sqft

Acre(Lot)

2241 Route 5 Lake Road,
Sheridan, NY, 14136

Bed

Bath

Sqft

Acres(Lot)

12374 Pennsylvania Avenue,
Sheridan, NY, 14136

Bed

Bath

2,086

Sqft

4.10

Acres(Lot)

The data relating to real estate for sale on this website comes in part from the Internet Data exchange (IDX) program of the New York State Alliance MLS. IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Real estate listings held by brokerage firms other than ByOwner, are indicated by detailed information about them such as the name of the listing firms. All information deemed reliable but not guaranteed and should be independently verified. All properties are subject to prior sale, change or withdrawal. Neither the listing broker(s) nor ByOwner shall be responsible for any typographical errors, misinformation, misprints, and shall be held totally harmless. Copyright ©2026 New York State Alliance and participating MLS's - CNYIS, UNYREIS and WNYREIS. All Rights Reserved.

ByOwner last updated this listing 08/17/2026 @ 08:31

MLS: B1679089 LISTED BY: Holli Draves, HUNT Real Estate Corporation 716-633-5350 SOURCE: Western New York Real Estate Information Services (WNYREIS)