Vintage 1920s House W/Beach Path & Glorious Sunset Water Views

What a wonderful cottage! We enjoyed it immensely! From the path to the beach, to the Menemsha fish market, and touring the island! What a wonderful time we had! Nathaniel is the perfect host! Thank you Nathaniel for letting us experience your wonderful cottage in Menemsha! Sandra and I will definitely be back!

Not only was the property a slice of history, it was quiet and secluded enough that we felt like we had the area to ourselves. Perfect for a reunion trip with life-long friends. Nathaniel made us feel like we were truly guests in his home - welcoming us to enjoy the amenities as if we had known him personally. The kitchen was well-appointed, so, based on great recommendations from Nathaniel, we sourced most of our meals from local farm stands and spent time cooking and taking in the sunset from the large deck. We walked the shore to Menemsha Beach, took in the sites of the various other towns, went to the Alpaca Farm, etc. enjoying each for its different experience. There were five of us and we each, except for two twins in one room, had a private space. The garage was available for storing my bikes when it rained. When it turned cold & blustery for one evening, we made use of the fireplace and our comfort was never compromised. I can see why this is often booked so far in advance with repeat customers. We wanted for nothing all week. Thank you!

Our stay could not have been more perfect. The owners pre stay communication was excellent. During our stay he was available (via text) to answer any questions we might have. An excellent cottage information package was provided provided as soon as we booked our stay and was very helpful in explaining the cottage features and history as well as a helpful list of area hikes and activities. We LOVED the cottage! The owner has taken great care to sympathetically renovate the cottage. The living room was choc-a-block full of character. A noteworthy feature was the fireplace in both the living room and the kitchen. The deck was spacious and the view was spectacular. There are two nearby fish markets. We had fabulous fresh fish each evening. We had an accomplished cook in our group and she found everything needed to prepare memorable meals. We also enjoyed the Webber grill. We would return in a heartbeat!

My family and I had a fantastic stay at the house. It was beautiful (with amazing sunsets and a fun winding trail to the beach), clean, and in a quiet location though accessible to many things. The owner was always available to connect to answer any questions we had in advance of our trip and while we stayed at the house. We will recommend this house to our friends and try to come back as well!

While there are enough beds for more, my husband and I found the cottage perfect for the two of us. The owner quickly responded to any questions we had and we found the house really nicely equipped.

Beautiful, off-season stay. Quiet, charming, great sunsets overlooking the water. Loved the quiet during Spring. Perfect affordable getaway.

Nathaniel was the perfect host. It was our first visit to Martha’s Vineyard. Everything as described except exceeded expectations by 10X. Access to all the islands delights. Everything is provided Kitchen is perfect for in house meals. We especially appreciated the opportunity to bring our two well behaved dogs. We understand why you fall in love with this place!

A perfect, relaxing week on the quieter part of Martha's Vineyard. The cottage was exactly as described. Quaint, clean, stocked with everything you could need. We spent most of our time on the deck, as the weather was beautiful and the view/outdoor space was breathtaking.

Quaint classic vineyard property with a spectacular view from a wonderful deck. Can't say enough about the sunsets while eating dinner outside. The cottage was very clean and well stocked. Plenty of space for a family to use as a home base while exploring the island. Have been coming to the Vineyard for years and definitely will come back to this place.

A charming house filled with lots of character and history. Breathtaking views, only add to this quiet and peaceful location. Breakfast on the deck each morning and cozy fires in the stone fireplace each night, make the experience complete. Owners were very responsive with questions, and helpful with entire process. Thank you Nathaniel. We will always have beautiful memories of this special place.