Cottage #1

The cottage itself was gorgeous. Beautiful beach views and the interior was beautifully done. I loved the big soaking tub and comfortable couch. I was disappointed by two things though. The communication with the host was almost non existent. I asked questions and never heard back - I also never received any type of guest guide so had no information about the cottage or things near by. I also was disappointed by the amenities - I read online they had snorkel gear. They only had goggles so we ended up going into town to rent gear. I had also read about a Polaroid camera but ours was missing batteries so couldn’t be used. For the price, I expected better service like welcome water and/or snacks but nothing like that was provided. We stayed in Poipu at a rental right before coming here and the hosting went above our expectations (for a fraction of the price). Given how luxurious these cottages are, we had higher expectations

It was the most prefect stay, the beach was amazing and the house was beautiful!

We had a fantastic time and will definitely come back! Highly recommend! Cottage was updated, clean, easy to get to and beach access was great! So beautiful!

Beautiful cottage and grounds. The interior of the cottage was right out of a designer magazine. So cleanly done. Global knives that were sharp, allclad pans, Smeg coffeemaker and small appliances. Nice gas stove. No AC but the jalousie windows and fans were completely adequate for ventilation. The cottages are close together. Except for young people in number 2 being noisy one evening, the property was very quiet. Super close to the beach. Adequate parking. Highly recommended!

Responsive host, lovely design, great location!

Great place. Very clean, nice quiet location. These cottages are a lot closer together than I was expecting, but no one else was staying in the others so it didn’t bother us. Only reason I’m leaving a 3 star and not a 5 is because there was absolutely 0 communication from the owner. We ran out of toilet paper and paper towels since we were there for a week and sent multiple messages on VRBO and text and never got a response.

It was so easy to check in and unwind. We were a little early, so took a blanket down to the beach just steps away and watched the waves. The cottage was peaceful and had everything we needed.

My partner and I recently enjoyed a wonderful 3-day stay at this cottage for our first trip to Hawaii. Our stay truly exceeded all expectations, and the listing photos simply don't do this place justice. We woke up every day to watch the sunrise on the private beach, a truly unforgettable experience.You'll fall asleep and wake up to the soothing sound of crashing waves, with a gentle breeze flowing through the curtains.We filled our days visiting the local coffee shop, taking long walks along the extensive beach, and even indulging in beach massages at the neighboring resort.The cottage itself is incredibly well-equipped, showcasing the owner's thoughtful and detail-oriented design. It's stocked with high-end products, from Sabré Paris utensils and a Polaroid camera with film (which we loved using!) to a record player complete with a Rufus du Sol record.The location is fantastic – just a quick drive into Hanalei, yet directly next to a state park and botanical gardens.While we spent the second half of our trip on the south shore, we definitely preferred this part of the island. Our only regret is not staying longer!

The cottages are quaint and perfect for 2-4 depending on 1 or 2 bedrooms. The cottages are large enough for a quiet get-a-way. The location is perfect for beach walking and snorkeling. Some of the clearest waters on calm days. The new owners are going to renovate and we are looking forward to some comfort changes. One of our favorite places to stay in our retirement. This is our second time at the Hale Makai Cottages and we love the vibe and beach.

Aloha! Ok— so I don’t want to share this review because I don’t want to share this place and keep it all to myself. However, the right thing to do is to be honest and let you know this is the perfect location for a true getaway on the best side of the island. We loved it and will definitely be coming back. The team managing the property is friendly and responsive. We grilled out while we were there and had fresh fish from the Dolphin which is a fantastic fish market right down the road. LOVED this place!