Anglers Reef Islamorada Vacation Rental 2/2.5 updated 131 Anglers Way

We had such an amazing vacation at Anglers Reef! The property was so clean and well appointed Ted. There was nothing we needed that we didn’t have. We were only 15 minutes or so away from our son who was at Florida Sea Base for a scout trip. Our girls were very comfortable sharing the second bedroom and my husband and I were so pleased with the primary suite as well. It was great having a washer and dryer to clean and wash all the laundry before heading home. The pool was so lovely and we used the paddle boards every day. Tons of great restaurants nearby and only 6 minutes to the Pubkix and CVS for essentials. Thank you for such a relaxing and enjoyable stay.

This place was so amazing! My family and I came here for vacation and right when we got there it feels like home. The place was very clean. Bed is super comfortable that we didn't wake up next day until 11am lol. Note: if you are planning on just staying to swim and being on the boat and ocean like we did. Dont bring lots of clothes because we did and because there was washer and dryer we hardly wore half the clothes we brought with us. Washer and dryer is super convenient! Kitchen was Stocked with spices for cooking and you are surrounded by lots of store. We love that it's gated community. It's such a quiet place even through there was lots of other rentals there. We felt very safe. The house is so cozy and we were very sad to leave. If you want to rent a boat. Go by the island grill and rent from Captain Jeff! He is super honest and amazing! We mostly went to the sand bar and Alligator reef because the is nice and clear that your able to snorkels and swim with lots of fishes and even turtles. We did use the kayaks a couple times and an amazing time just exploring. Jennifer you are awesome! She responds right away when I text her to ask some questions and was very nice. Thank you Jennifer for a nice stay at 131! If we ever come back to islamorada this would definitely be the place!

Everything was great except very limited TV selection with no national news programing.

Stayed at Islamorada with our three daughters. Location was OK but a few things were off here and there with the property pulling down the rating to a 4 stars only. Seemingly wild cat's being fed on the property and roving around leaving fur in outside seating. Irrigation settings leaving outside furniture wet several days of our week long stay. Beds were also not great, starting to show depressions, especially the futon.

We had a wonderful stay at this beautiful house in a safe, gated community. The location was perfect-close to everything we needed while still offering peace and quiet.

Love staying in Anglers Reef! This was our 2nd time visiting Anglers and will continue to make this our annual summer Keyes trip due to the great location on Islamorada, pristine gated community and available boat slip.

House was really nice and property was excellent.

Really nice property in a very safe, gated neighborhood. Loved all the amenities. This is a very family friendly neighborhood. Property manager is excellent and very helpful and responsive if needed.

The house at Angler’s Reef was very comfortable and within a very quiet, peaceful resort. The two beaches and boat docks gave us great opportunities to walk multiple times a day and spectacular views! We enjoyed the relaxing pool and the friendly community. The house is well equipped with all amenities and comfortable beds to compliment the stay. The master bed felt heavenly with the down duvet and pillows. The ONLY recommendation I would give is some solid curtains in the living area OR move the tv to the outer wall, but there’s so much glorious sunlight form every direction, curtains might do best to cut down the glare on the TV on those rainy days or being outside isn’t an option. Overall, this place is wonderful and Jennifer was very helpful!

Perfect