A contemporary island gem that was formerly used as a bottling plant,

The size and layout were the strongest part of this stay — the house was roomy and functional for our needs.However, security was a concern. Several entry points were not in good condition:One door would not lockOne of the property gates either did not have working locks or did not lock at allSliding doors were worn and did not feel secureThe home also felt dated and in need of overall maintenance and attention.There was an issue with a smoke alarm, but to their credit, the property manager was responsive and addressed it quickly once it was reported.Additional notes:Outdoor space was very smallThe overall condition did not fully match the listing photosA neighboring property was under active construction, with noticeable noise throughout the week; this was not disclosed in the listingBottom line: Good interior space, but maintenance and security issues—particularly doors and gates that don't lock —keep this property at a 3‑star level.

House and area were very nice, clean, close to everything, we recommend staying at this house

Awesome place to stay while visiting Key West. Great food and entertainment in all directions of Casa Amor.

6 of us. Very spacious. Cold a/c, hot water, lovely warm pool. Great location.

What an amazing house! The pool was awesome to dip into after a long day. The house was HUGE! Our family stayed together, but we had space to be alone. Kitchen had everything you needed and then some. The cherry on top was the big bathtub in the master!

A group of 6 adults stayed for almost a week and our stay was fantastic. The rental is exactly as advertised. Very clean and spacious. The pool was great and the location was perfect, close enough but not in the party that is Key West. We would definitely stay there again.

Great modern home in quiet area. Beautiful furnishings, immaculate and comfy mattresses. Pool was warm and shaded during hottest part of day. Walking distance to beaches, bars and restaurants. Great property.

Relaxing spacious rental. Nice back patio with small pool.

We were a family group of 6 adults. We cooked seafood dinners in the well-equipped kitchen, ate on the beautiful the outdoor patio, and swam in the incredible private, heated pool. Plenty of room to be together and to have some time away from group also.The house is chic, very clean, up-to-date, well appointed. A really cool place to hang out! It is in a quiet neighborhood but still walkable to all the Duval Street hotspots, the harbor and the beach.We will definitely book again!

Truly enjoyed everything about it. Place was fully stocked with all the amenities that you need

The Casa Amor home is truly stunning, with dramatic high ceilings and unique architecture and decor. Plenty of room for our group of 7 plus our big dog :) Incredible location. We loved the close proximity to all the action on and near Duval and the attractions around the Southernmost point. There's a great, authentic Cuban coffee spot, Cafelito, that is open early and only a block away. We walked everywhere we went except for the one evening we took an uber to the Mallory Square area. The pool was well heated and very comfortable during our stay Thanksgiving week, even with the cold front that came through. The kitchen is well equipped, and beds are comfortable. During our stay we had one issue, and the RentKW team jumped ALL OVER IT and not only did they resolve it, they went above and beyond to make things better than we imagined. Thank you so much to the team, this is excellent customer service. I recommend the Casa Amor to anyone visiting the Keys who wishes to be in the heart of the attractions, restaurants, and wants a unique, once in a lifetime luxury rental that goes against the typical style of home in Key West.

The house is setup as a great entertainment space. Plenty of room, clean and organized, well equipped kitchen. The pool area is visible throughout the space making it feel a part of the experience and it has plenty of seating and dining space as well as a grill. We really enjoyed our stay and would definitely stay there again. The two things we would mention as a potential con is the only stairs going up to the master are the narrow metal circular stairs and if you bring a pet or have to take bulky luggage upstairs it can be a bit precarious. The listing said there were 3 1/2 nathrooms, there are only 2 1/2.

Great place to stay, very close to Duval St

We liked the Casa Amor overall. It’s spacious with high ceilings and plenty of inside space. The one difficulty we encountered involved the pool. When we arrived, it was green and stagnant with debris on the surface and pool bottom. We immediately called the management company since the pool was a major factor in selecting this rental. We received a voicemail back the next day telling us that “green” was the normal color of the pool, which turned out to be true. Some prior notification of this fact would have been helpful. We eventually spoke to the property manager and communicated that something still didn’t seem right since it was not only green, but also stagnant and full of debris. Since this was day two of a three day stay and no one had used the pool, we asked if something would be taken off the high rental cost. We were told that that would not be possible. Later the second day, a maintenance person arrived unannounced and told us that the circulating pump had shut off due to a breaker problem. The pump was restarted and the pool was then swept and tested for bacteria. Everything was fine at that point except that we had never used the pool and the property manager was unwilling to provide any financial relief. As I promised her, I’m taking the time to write this review to communicate our unhappiness. When you pay a lot per night, we feel that the service should be commiserate with the price.