Private Nature Retreat With Game Room

Sister Bay, Wisconsin
$662 avg/night Minimum Stay 1 Nights
Bed 3

Bed

Bath 2

Bath

Home Cottage

Property Type

Sleep 6

Max Sleeps

Night 1 nights

Min Stay

Cottage & Bay is the kind of place where mornings start quietly, surrounded by trees, and days unfold at your own pace. Set on 4.5 private wooded acres just minutes from downtown Sister Bay, this single level, air conditioned home blends seclusion with easy access to Door County’s shops, dining, and shoreline. Whether you are gathering around the fire pit, playing games in the garage, or relaxing by the fireplace, Cottage & Bay is designed for connection, comfort, and memorablestays.

Cottage & Bay Highlights
• 3 bedrooms including 1 King, 2 Queens, and 1 Twin Bunk
• 2 full bathrooms with walk in shower and tub shower
• Single level home with central air conditioning
• 4.5 private acres surrounded by mature cedar trees
• Dog friendly with gated, fenced in dog run. One time pet fee applies
• Fully equipped kitchen with stainless steel appliances and coffee bar
• Gas fireplace with Smart TV and YouTubeTV
• Sunroom with plush seating and dedicated workstation
• Heated garage game room with pool, foosball, ping pong, and pop a shot
• Fire pit with Adirondack chairs and roasting sticks
• High speed Wi Fi, washer and dryer, and private parking

Bedrooms and Bathrooms
The primary bedroom is a peaceful retreat featuring a brand new king bed, luxury linens, bedside lighting, and windows overlooking the cedar grove. A private en suite bathroom includes a double vanity and walk in shower.

The second bedroom features a queen bed with a twin bunk above, making it perfect for kids or groups. The third bedroom offers a queen bed and cozy reading chair. These bedrooms share a full bathroom with tub shower and vanity.

All bedrooms include hospitality grade mattresses, premium linens, and Smart TVs with YouTubeTV provided. Bathrooms are stocked with allergy free, eco friendly toiletries including shampoo, conditioner, body wash, lotion, and hand soap. Hairdryers are provided for guest use.

Kitchen and Living Spaces
The open concept kitchen includes stainless steel appliances, generous counter space, and custom cabinetry. You will find everything needed for home cooked meals or quick snacks, including a toaster, oven, stove, and microwave. The coffee bar includes a drip coffee maker, tea kettle, and a starter supply of coffee and tea.

The living area features a cozy gas fireplace and mounted Smart TV, ideal for relaxing after a day exploring Door County. The sunroom offers additional seating and a dedicated workstation overlooking the woods. A nearby game nook includes board games and puzzles for easy family fun.

Outdoor Living
Enjoy the quiet beauty of the property from the back porch dining area under the umbrella, or fire up the grill for an evening meal. The fire pit area is a favorite gathering spot for cozy nights under the stars.

Garage Game Room
The heated garage game room offers year round entertainment with a pool table, foosball, ping pong, and pop a shot basketball. Perfect for rainy days or late night competitions.

Gatherings at the Property
Please note that parties, gatherings, and events are not permitted at the property. This includes picnics, family reunions, rehearsal dinners, and any event exceeding the home’s maximum occupancy, as it's prohibited by local short-term rental ordinances.

Good to Know
Exterior cameras monitor the driveway and fire pit area for safety. After booking, guests will be asked to sign a rental agreement and upload a photo ID to confirm age requirements. Accidental damage protection is included in place of a traditional security deposit, and guests remain responsible for any damages beyond normal wear and tear.

Read More Expand
  • Feature Features
  • Map Map
  • School District Rates & Availability
  • Review Review

Feature Features

  • PETS

    Pet Friendly
  • DINING

    Dining Table
  • SAFETY

    Carbon Monoxide Detector Installed (host Has Indicated There Is A Carbon Monoxide Detector On The Property) Deadbolt Lock Fire Extinguisher First Aid Kit Smoke Detector Installed (host Has Indicated There Is A Smoke Detector On The Property)
  • BEDROOM

    3 Bedrooms Bed Sheets Provided Sofa Bed
  • GENERAL

    Unit Size: 1882 Sq Ft (175 Sq M)
  • KITCHEN

    Coffee/tea Maker Dishwasher Ice Maker Kitchen Island Microwave Oven Refrigerator Stovetop Toaster
  • LAUNDRY

    Laundry Facilities Washing Machine And Dryer
  • PARKING

    Car Recommended Onsite Parking Onsite Parking Options Include A Garage
  • INTERNET

    WiFi Available, With Speed Of 25+ Mbps
  • OUTDOORS

    Balcony Barbecue Grill Fenced Yard Firepit Garden
  • BATHROOMS

    2 Bathrooms Hair Dryer Shower Towels Provided
  • THINGS TO DO

    Fishing Nearby Hunting Nearby Mountain Biking Nearby Power Boating Nearby Swimming Nearby Water Tubing Nearby Wildlife And Game Walks Nearby Windsurfing Nearby Winery Tours Nearby
  • ENTERTAINMENT

    Arcade/game Room Foosball Table Games Pool Or Billiards Table Table Tennis Smart TV
  • LIVING SPACES

    Dining Room Fireplace Living Room
  • CLIMATE CONTROL

    Air Conditioning Heating
  • FAMILY FRIENDLY

    Playground Travel Crib
  • LOCATION HIGHLIGHTS

    In A Rural Location Near A Hospital Near Outlet Shopping
  • SUITABILITY/ACCESSIBILITY

    Smoke-free Property

CheckIn Check-in : 04:00 PM CheckOut Check-out : 10:00 AM
No Wheelchair No smoking No pets Children allowed
Occupancy Max occupancy : 6

Map Map

School District Rates & Availability

Review Review

  • Hannah S.

    Submitted Feb 10, 2026

    Stayed Feb 5, 2026

    Wonderful experience! Clean, beautiful home, amazing features (game room & dog run), comfortable amenities, and easy communication with the hosts,

  • Kate B.

    Submitted Jan 2, 2026

    Stayed Dec 30, 2025

    This place was perfect for our family NYE getaway...very pet friendly, well equipped for every thing we wanted ...game room was so much fun...will be staying again!!!

  • Carrie K.

    Submitted Aug 20, 2025

    Stayed Jul 31, 2025

    We rented this house for my brother's wedding weekend and it was perfect! Great place to hang out with plenty of room for everyone. Two living areas with comfortable couches, dining room table and small breakfast nook. We especially enjoyed the firepit and game room. The house was perfectly appointed and the hosts were very attentive. Thank you Mitch & Katie!

  • Sheri H.

    Submitted Jan 24, 2025

    Stayed Jan 17, 2025

    This house was AMAZING! We used it for a retreat weekend for our family business, and we got so much work done at the huge kitchen table (with wonderful fireplace for a very, very cold January weekend) and then took breaks to play all the games in the heated garage! We had so much fun and made great family memories and connections. The house was perfectly clean and very well equipped. It was located really close to Sister Bay yet on a large private lot. We will be back!

  • Tracey B.

    Submitted Oct 29, 2024

    Stayed Oct 25, 2024

    Annual girls weekend was elevated by staying at Cottage and Bay. Mitch and Katie are great hosts with a beautiful property that accommodated all of us comfortably. We are looking forward to staying here again next year.

  • Rachael C.

    Submitted Aug 11, 2024

    Stayed Aug 9, 2024

    Beautiful property, hosts were very responsive, LOVED the don’t worry about cleaning up policy (although we did struggle a bit not too) but that was THE BEST bonus for a mom friends getaway! Would highly recommend.

  • Courtney C.

    Submitted Jul 11, 2024

    Stayed Jul 7, 2024

    Fantastic property, close to everything in Sister Bay - just a short bike ride away - yet secluded, private and quiet. The house was very spacious and comfortable. Very clean and had everything we needed. The outdoor space and fire pit were fantastic. The dogs had a safe, fenced in, area to roam. We’d come back in a heartbeat! Thanks Mitch & Katie!

Your dates are Available!

Total

Includes taxes and fees
$662+
View details