Atalaya Tower 605, Well-maintained Three Bedroom, Two Bath Condo

Honestly, I was really disappointed with this unit and our stay. Upon arrival, I noticed that we could not use our master balcony door because a portable AC unit Was hooked up and Styrofoam pieces were taped together with blue painters tape to seal the hole so that the portable AC unit could work. It was a huge eyesore, although I am kind of thankful we had it because we were 2 1/2 days without air conditioner during a heat wave. While unloading all of our belongings, I had to unload a full dishwasher from the previous tenant stay. There were broken lampshades, the TVs did not work and could not figure out which remote we were supposed to use. The towel bar in the guest bath was literally hanging off of the wall, the dryer smelled like urine so much so that I did not want to wash my clothes. And the refrigerator would not stay cold and the icemaker would not work.I did call emergency services when the air wasn’t working and they sent a tech out and all he did was bump it back down to 70, which did nothing, so we woke up the next morning and it was 75 in the condo. So we had to wait another full day for them to fix the air conditioner so that it could be a comfortable temperature. They also did come fix the fridge issues and with the TV, but we were left with the eyesore in the bedroom and couldn’t use our balcony door. Yes, they somewhat fixed the issue, but never offered anything other than “sorry”. We won’t be renting this unit again, unfortunately

The proximity to the beach is fantastic, especially early morning sunrise and sunsets. Maintenance was called and arrived within 15 minutes (fix the air conditioner). Being close to the Garden City Pier was an added benefit. We will be back in 2026.

Rating Details: The property manager was very helpful. The vacation rental was spotless. I was very happy with the location. I was very satisfied with the condition of the vacation rental. Overall, I recommend this vacation rental. Reviewer Comments: The folks at Garden City Reality were wonderful to deal with. We had an incident with Kitchen chair and they were there the next morning.

Cleaning staff was terrible. Sand all over the floors. Bedroom closet, beach umbrella broken, with lots of sand in one of the bedrooms. Location Licatuon

Rating Details: The property manager was very helpful. The vacation rental was spotless. I was very happy with the location. I was very satisfied with the condition of the vacation rental. Overall, I recommend this vacation rental. Reviewer Comments: We had a great time and loved the location. It was quiet and very clean - which is very important to me. The staff was friendly and the premises were kept clean.

We enjoyed our time at atalaya towers

Rating Details: The property manager was very helpful. The vacation rental was spotless. I was very happy with the location. I was satisfied with the condition of the vacation rental. Overall, I recommend this vacation rental. Reviewer Comments: We loved our stay. The location is beautiful. The view of the ocean and the sunrise a special. The building management and garden city Realty were very helpful and attentive. We are looking forward to coming back next year.

Rating Details: The vacation rental was somewhat dirty. I was very happy with the location. I was somewhat dissatisfied with the condition of the vacation rental. Overall, I do not recommend this vacation rental. Reviewer Comments: We booked specifically for the hot tub being listed as an amenity but the hot tub was not available which was very disappointing. Would have loved an email with an option to stop the reservation since the hot tub was not available but we did not find this out until arrival.

Rating Details: The property manager was adequately helpful. The vacation rental was spotless. I was very happy with the location. I was more than satisfied with the condition of the vacation rental. Overall, I recommend this vacation rental. Reviewer Comments: We had a great time. The place was in a perfect spot. Steps from the beach. The only issue we had was that none of the TVs would work and one would not even come on. But we only wanted to watch TV at night so no big issue. Great amenities. Plenty of things to do in a central location. Thank you for the stay.

Rating Details: The property manager was very helpful. The vacation rental was clean. I was very happy with the location. I was satisfied with the condition of the vacation rental. Overall, I recommend this vacation rental. Reviewer Comments: Overall good experience, would rent this unit again. Beds were comfortable. Location is good/convenient. Enjoyed sitting on the balcony. The condo itself could use some minor improvements such as a better shower (pressure was minimal at best). The shower head initially leaked but we were able to secure without calling maintenance. When we arrived our floors were still rather sandy. And 1 set of sheets had stains which we switched with an unused bed. 1 elevator was broken for our entire stay which made check in very slow. Also was not aware that the beach chair/umbrella rentals setup directly in front of the tower. So you either were forced to rent or have a spot behind, not really a fan that the public beach space is 'claimed' by a rental co.