Luxury Water Front Cabin on Island Park Reservoir With Private Bay And Dock

I'll start with the issues (because there are very few). The back area was quite muddy, two of the chairs around the fire pit were broken, the front door handle doesn't latch fully so you have to use the deadbolt, and the foosball table is wobbly and missing a few bolts on the legs. That's the negative.The rest is nothing but positive. The beds are great. Plenty of bathrooms. The bunks for all of the cousins was phenomenal. This house was an ideal set-up for family gatherings. The private dock is a perfect bonus. The property feels secluded and quiet. We caught over 30 fish just standing on the dock (kids loved that). Everything in the kitchen worked well (except the kitchen faucet was a little finicky). The location is great for a day trip to Yellowstone (only a 30-40 minute drive to West Gate). Lorie (the host) was quick to respond and helpful. We rented watercraft from the lodge at the lake and simply drove them over to our dock and parked them (very convenient). Access to Henry's Fork for fly fishing is 5 mintues away (you can even get there by UTV trails... which are everywhere). Overall, if you have a large family gathering and are looking for a large variety of outdoor activities (we even did a river float trip one day that was actually way more fun than we thought it was going to be) this is property is a homerun.

Great location right on the water! Very spacious home with lots of large areas for our whole group to hang out. The host was very easy to communicate with. We loved all the king size beds. We had a fabulous time and awesome memories made.

My family had a wonderful time on Bill’s Island in Island Park Idaho! The house/cabin was clean and inviting. Our surroundings were beautiful and peaceful. Plenty of space for cousins to enjoy. The dock was perfect for our water activities. The O’Tools were great to work with. Carol

This is a great house with plenty of room for 9 adults and 12 kids. We loved having our own dock on the lake although I will say that the lake gets dangerously crowded on saturdays. The kitchen was well equipped with everything we needed, the owners were helpful with any questions. We would love to stay again some time.

O’Toole Haven was a perfect house for our family. It was spacious and comfortable. It’s a beautiful setting on the lake. We loved watching the white pelicans every day. It’s also close to the West entrance to Yellowstone National Park and we went there twice. Also went into Big Sky, MT for the day to shop. Rode horses at Eagle Ridge Ranch, rented UTV’s from Lakeside Lodge and did a float trip. We made lots of great memories.

Great property! Beautiful!!

Great time enjoying the lake, home, and surrounding areas. Perfect place for memories and fun!

Such a great house! Rooms were all bigger than they seem in the pictures. Very private area. Seems like there's no one around. Firepit and dock area were perfect!

Wonderful lake home. Lori was great to work with. Would definitely stay here again!

We have stayed at the O’Toole cabin on famous Bill’s Island in Island Park, Idaho for years. It is always the highlight of our summer. This time we enjoyed the new renovations there. An entire new wing of bedrooms with private bathrooms, an enormous bunkhouse and upstairs playroom. We were blown away with all this space and large comfy beds. It was above and beyond our expectations!!!