Captain's Quarters @The Boat Shop - Overlooking Paradise Bay

After hauling our luggage up 19 steps and catching our breath, we were delighted with our spacious Captain's quarter having a fully equipped modern kitchen. Everything worked well. The location is only about 250 feet from a well stocked market that gladly offered just one stick of butter that was all we needed. We greatly enjoyed meeting many full-time residents who share a pioneering can do spirit. One resident said that nobody suffers alone because we will take care of them. Wow!

Our stay was excellent, the people were very friendly, and the accommodations top-notch. Thank you for making our first trip to Beaver Island an amazing experience! We will definitely be back!

This is a lovely kitchenette apartment. Has a nice view of Paradise Bay and is a 13 minute walk from the town center. It would be perfect for an extended stay.

Great view and location. Walls are a little thin but the neighbors were pretty quiet. The space was nice and comfortable.

Very clean and comfortable.

The apartment had everything we needed, great view of Lake Michigan, would recommend highly

Great place to stay! Can see the water. Basic supplies were all there. We enjoyed exploring Beaver Island!!

Lovely apartment for the price. Carol was a great host and let us check in a little early as our room was ready and we came on the morning ferry. Charming venue in every way!

Really nice place to stay. Clean and super cute decor. Beautiful view from the balcony. You do have to climb a full set of stairs so if you have issues, please be aware of that.

It was like an apartment. We were able to prepare a meal there. Awesome view! Very comfortable.

Located close to dining and shops, the property was very clean and comfortable.

Excellent location within walking distance of downtown, grocery store, and light house. Excellent view of Harbor. Room was clean, overall, with the exception of the toaster which had significant bread crumb accumulation. We did not use the toaster but cleaned it prior to departure. Would suggest adding cleaning of toaster to Housekeeping checklist. We had a question following our departure and called Carol to discuss. Our phone call went to voicemail so we left a message requesting a return call. A return call was not received so we called the next day. Again, our phone call went to voicemail so we left a 2nd message requesting a return call. A return call was not received so we called again the 3rd day and left a 3rd voicemail message requesting a return call. We then received a text message from Carol with a reply Check your email . . . We placed a 4th call and left a voice mail message requesting a return call to discuss the situation but have not received one at the time of this feedback. We were planning to stay at this location for our trip next year to Beaver Island but will now seek accommodations with a Host who is welcoming and willing to speak with customers on the phone regarding questions.

Work trip so not much exploring but the accommodation worked well.

Very cute and cozy place in a terrific location! Very close to the ferry dock and restaurants and steps from a great breakfast spot, market and brewery. Rent an e-bike on site and explore the island!

Nice room with a harbor view. Peaceful place for some great R&R!

Wonderful location, close to everything in town. Spacious and loved the deck!

Nice, comfortable and convenient place to stay. We only had bikes with us and it was only a few blocks from the ferry and very close to Wild Strawberry Cafe for good food and the market. We had warm weather and wondered if it was hot if the one fan would have been enough, as there is no a/c, but it worked out well for us. The view is beautiful!

It was great!

This was our first trip to Beaver Island and absolutely loved it. The apartment was 0.5 mile from town and the grocery store is almost next door. It was great having a kitchen and the patio overlooking the bay was wonderful. We had our car and there was ample parking. Highly recommend this property if you are visiting Beaver Island.

It was a great!

Perfect apartment overlooking bay and marina with restaurant, grocery market, and brewery within a 3 minute walk! Walk to town or lighthouse is 10minutes approximately. A great place to “unplug” and get back to nature!

Great place

Beautiful location, and excellent location for watching the strawberry moon rise!

We only stayed one night at the Boat Shop - Captain Quarters on Beaver Island, but it was absolutely unforgettable. The space was clean, cozy, and full of character — you can feel the thought and care that went into every detail.The view was the true standout. Watching the harbor from the windows and taking in the peaceful water and sky was incredibly relaxing — the kind of view that stays with you long after you leave.Even in a short stay, we felt completely at home. The location was perfect for exploring the island, and the hosts were warm, welcoming, and helpful.We wish we had more time and are already hoping to come back. Highly recommended for anyone looking for a quiet, beautiful getaway — even if just for a night!

We loved our stay on Beaver Island. Carol was a a fantastic host. It was raining when our ferry got in so she so nice and able to picked us up and drove us to our accommodations which because we were staying off season were ready early. She was very helpful the next day when we wanted to rent a car as well so we could explore more of the island. Our accommodations were clean and quiet and on a gorgeous part of the island.

The Captain’s Quarters was perfect for our 2 day stay on the island. It was exactly as shown in the pictures. The location was excellent. Carol was very helpful with island information.

Nice spot right by the water. Very clean place and cozy. Highly recommend!

It was very relaxing to head to the island without having to work on our properties. The accommodations were perfect. Location was great. All within walking distance. The Property Manager was very accommodating and friendly. After all we're Neighbors!!!! Views were amazing and the weather was outstanding. Can't wait to stay again!

This was like an apartment with all the amenities anyone needs. Very clean. The porch view of the water was beautiful!

Right near the water and close to everything. Hosts were vere gracious and helpful. If you need anything, checknwith them first.

Booked two nights. Left reciew there. Thank you.

Gorgeous view, private yet walking distance to island needs!

Great location and hosts were fantastic!

Wonderful place to stay!!! Very clean, comfortable, incredible location and great host!!!I Would stay here again without a second thought!!! Loved this vacation.

Clean place. Not to noisey. The only thing missing was coffee ceamer and sugar. Nice friendly place

The apartment was perfect. Everything we needed was there. The view off the deck was wonderful. The location was perfect since we had no car and this apartment is located in the center of town. Very quiet and very relaxing. With the owner just downstairs it was very handy for asking questions about town and things to do. We'll be back.

Captain’s Quarters were perfect for our stay on Beaver Island. Lovely view overlooking the bay, clean apartment with everything we needed. Not sure about the kitchen just because we were only there one night and since we were taking a much needed break we ate out.