370 Starlight Road, Monticello, New York image 1
Active

370 Starlight Road

Monticello, NY 12701
Mark as Favorite
$399,900 $1,685/Mo
Get Pre-Approved Check your credit
Bed 2

Bed

Bath 2

Bath

SqFt1,080

Sqft

Acres2

Acres(Lot)

History, character, and simplicity come together here. Welcome to 370 Starlight Rd. Set on two well-maintained acres, this former schoolhouse offers charm you can feel the moment you walk in. The setting is quiet and peaceful, yet close to everything the area has to offer. Inside, the home has been thoughtfully updated. A new kitchen with stainless steel appliances and a renovated bathroom bring modern comfort into a space filled with original character. Hardwood floors and detailed woodwork remind you of the home’s history, while an electric fireplace adds warmth to the main living area. Electrical upgrades and a new heating system provide peace of mind, and the roof is only 8 years old. Outside, the lifestyle opens up. Large decks give you space to gather, relax, and entertain. A circ ular blacktop driveway makes access simple, and the open yard gives you room to enjoy the property your way. The size and layout of the property also open the door to future potential. With proper approvals, there may be an opportunity to explore subdivision or the addition of a second home, making this not just a place to live, but a property you can grow into over time. Directly across the street, you have access to Swinging Bridge Reservoir, a motorboat lake with a marina, adding another layer to the lifestyle this home offers. Location matters here. You are within 4 miles of The Arnold House, a well-known local spot for dining. For outdoor time, the Walnut Mountain Park offers walking trails, open space, and scenic views. You are also close to Bethel Woods, Resorts World Catskills, The Kartrite Water Park, and Holiday Mountain. This is a home with a story, updated for today, and set in a location that gives you both access and quiet. Come see it and feel the character for yourself.

Read More Expand

Detail Ic Property Details

Property Type : Residential

Price : $399,900

AD Id : 89980881

MLS Id : 1042561

Beds : 2

Lot Size : 2 Acres

Living Area Size : 1,080

Year Built : 1929

County : Sullivan

  • Map Map

Map

Map What's Nearby

Map Nearby Areas

Feature Features

  • Bedroom Information

    Total beds: 2

    Bathroom Information

    Total Baths: 2 Full Baths: 1 Half Baths: 1

    Room Information

    Rooms Total: 5 Basement: Full

  • Interior Features

    Eat-in Kitchen Appliances: Other

  • Heating & Cooling

    Has Heating: Yes Heating: Forced Air Has Cooling: Yes Cooling: Wall/Window Unit(s)

  • Building Information

    Year Built: 1929 Construction Materials: Frame, Vinyl Siding Private Pool: No Water front Features: Waterfront Access

  • Exterior Features

    Exterior Features: Other

  • Lot Information

    Lot Size Acres: 2 Lot Size Square Feet: 87120

  • Listing Price Information

    Listing Price: $399900

  • Tax Information

    Parcel Number: 484689 41.-1-13 Tax Lot: 13.000 Tax Block: 1 Annual Tax: $2359

  • Parking Information

    Driveway

  • School Information

    Elementary School: Kenneth L Rutherford School
    Junior High School: Robert J Kaiser Middle School
    Senior High School: Monticello High School

  • Utility Information

    Electricity Connected

  • Location Information

    WaterSource: Private, Well
Sell a home like this and save $23,495 Find out How

How much is this property worth?

Curious about this home's true market value? Use our free Home Evaluation Tool to instantly get a personalized Comparative Market Analysis (CMA) report. Make smarter, data-driven decisions before you buy.

Images
Loading, please wait...

Nearby Home Value

Address Estimate Bed Bath Sq. Ft Lot Size
35 Kroeger Road, Monticello, NY, 12701 $1,100,000 3 4 1,484 1,484 SqFt
463 Rose Valley Road, Monticello, NY, 12701 $499,900 5 2 2,122 2,122 SqFt
139 Haddock Road, Monticello, NY, 12701 $399,999 3 2 1,200 1,200 SqFt
14 Willow Lane, Monticello, NY, 12701 $425,000 3 3 1,471 1,471 SqFt
8 Willow Lane, Monticello, NY, 12701 $419,900 3 2 1,200 1,200 SqFt
60 Haddock Road, Monticello, NY, 12701 $399,000 6 2 1,456 1,456 SqFt
226 Rock Ridge Drive #2, Monticello, NY, 12701 $495,000 3 3 2,192 2,192 SqFt
224 Rock Ridge Drive #2, Monticello, NY, 12701 $495,000 3 3 2,192 2,192 SqFt
220 Rock Ridge Drive #3, Monticello, NY, 12701 $525,000 3 3 2,192 2,192 SqFt
174 Rock Ridge Avenue, Monticello, NY, 12701 $368,500 2 1 1,100 1,100 SqFt

Similar Homes To 370 Starlight Road

Nearby For Sale

Slider Thumb
Active
Mark as Favorite
$2,300,000
Home For Sale

114 Levine Road,
Monticello, NY, 12701

Bed 5

Bed

Bath 3

Bath

SqFt4,094

Sqft

Acres70.09

Acres(Lot)
Slider Thumb
Active
Mark as Favorite
$649,900
Home For Sale

275-277 Route 17b,
Monticello, NY, 12701

Bed 5

Bed

Bath 2

Bath

SqFt1,312

Sqft

Acres4.92

Acres(Lot)
Slider Thumb
Active
Mark as Favorite
$799,999
Home For Sale

45 Coopers Corner Road,
Monticello, NY, 12701

Bed 2

Bed

Bath 3

Bath

SqFt2,468

Sqft

Acres6.66

Acres(Lot)
Slider Thumb
Active
Mark as Favorite
$399,999
Home For Sale

139 Haddock Road,
Monticello, NY, 12701

Bed 3

Bed

Bath 2

Bath

SqFt1,200

Sqft

Acres5.02

Acres(Lot)
Slider Thumb
Active
Mark as Favorite
$1,600,000
Home For Sale

174 Dingle Daisy Road,
Monticello, NY, 12701

Acres210

Acres(Lot)

The data relating to real estate for sale on this website comes in part from the Internet Data exchange of OneKey MLS. IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Copyright © 2026 OneKey MLS. All Rights Reserved

ByOwner last updated this listing 08/30/2026 @ 07:32

MLS: 1042561 LISTED BY: Isaiah Lopez, KW Hudson Valley United 845-610-6065 SOURCE: OneKey MLS

More Cities with for Sale by Owner Homes

Homes around $399,900

Slider Thumb
Active
Mark as Favorite
$350,000
Home For Sale

35 Starr Avenue Ave,
Monticello, NY, 12701

Bed 3

Bed

Bath 2

Bath

SqFt1,380

Sqft

Acres0.68

Acre(Lot)
Slider Thumb
Active
Mark as Favorite
$351,999
Home For Sale

10 Hanover Drive,
Monticello, NY, 12701

Bed 3

Bed

Bath 3

Bath

SqFt1,772

Sqft

Acres0.51

Acre(Lot)
Slider Thumb
Active
Mark as Favorite
$359,000
Home For Sale

105 Wood Avenue,
Monticello, NY, 12701

Bed 4

Bed

Bath 2

Bath

SqFt1,768

Sqft

Acres0.34

Acre(Lot)
Slider Thumb
Active
Mark as Favorite
$360,000
Home For Sale

2 Sunset Drive,
Monticello, NY, 12701

Bed 3

Bed

Bath 3

Bath

SqFt1,800

Sqft

Acres0.74

Acre(Lot)
Slider Thumb
Active
Mark as Favorite
$368,500
Home For Sale

174 Rock Ridge Avenue,
Monticello, NY, 12701

Bed 2

Bed

Bath 1

Bath

SqFt1,100

Sqft

Acres0.38

Acre(Lot)
Slider Thumb
Active
Mark as Favorite
$375,000
Home For Sale

28 Lake Street,
Monticello, NY, 12701

Bed 3

Bed

Bath 2

Bath

SqFt1,632

Sqft

Acres0.16

Acre(Lot)
Slider Thumb
Active
Mark as Favorite
$375,000
Home For Sale

36 Waverly Avenue #34,
Monticello, NY, 12701

Bed 3

Bed

Bath 1

Bath

SqFt1,516

Sqft

Acres0.46

Acre(Lot)
Slider Thumb
Active
Mark as Favorite
$375,000
Home For Sale

7 Jenn Lane,
Monticello, NY, 12701

Bed 3

Bed

Bath 2

Bath

SqFt1,056

Sqft

Acres0.40

Acre(Lot)
Slider Thumb
Active
Mark as Favorite
$385,000
Home For Sale

39 Dingle Daisy Road,
Monticello, NY, 12701

Bed 5

Bed

Bath 2

Bath

SqFt2,062

Sqft

Acres1.97

Acres(Lot)
Slider Thumb
Active
Mark as Favorite
$395,000
Home For Sale

530 Sackett Lake Road,
Monticello, NY, 12701

Bed 4

Bed

Bath 3

Bath

SqFt2,452

Sqft

Acres1.20

Acres(Lot)
Slider Thumb
Active
Mark as Favorite
$399,000
Home For Sale

60 Haddock Road,
Monticello, NY, 12701

Bed 6

Bed

Bath 2

Bath

SqFt1,456

Sqft

Acres4

Acres(Lot)
Slider Thumb
Active
Mark as Favorite
$399,999
Home For Sale

139 Haddock Road,
Monticello, NY, 12701

Bed 3

Bed

Bath 2

Bath

SqFt1,200

Sqft

Acres5.02

Acres(Lot)
Slider Thumb
Active
Mark as Favorite
$419,900
Home For Sale

8 Willow Lane,
Monticello, NY, 12701

Bed 3

Bed

Bath 2

Bath

SqFt1,200

Sqft

Acres0.26

Acre(Lot)
Slider Thumb
Active
Mark as Favorite
$425,000
Home For Sale

14 Willow Lane,
Monticello, NY, 12701

Bed 3

Bed

Bath 3

Bath

SqFt1,471

Sqft

Acres0.26

Acre(Lot)
Slider Thumb
Active
Mark as Favorite
$425,000
Multifamily For Sale

31 Cottage Street,
Monticello, NY, 12701

Bed 4

Bed

Bath 2

Bath

Acres0.17

Acre(Lot)
Slider Thumb
Active
Mark as Favorite
$435,000
Home For Sale

3 Water Lilly Lane,
Monticello, NY, 12701

Bed 3

Bed

Bath 3

Bath

SqFt1,112

Sqft

Acres0.04

Acre(Lot)
Slider Thumb
Active
Mark as Favorite
$439,000
Home For Sale

5 Lakeview Terrace,
Monticello, NY, 12701

Bed 3

Bed

Bath 3

Bath

SqFt1,112

Sqft

Acres0.04

Acre(Lot)
Slider Thumb
Active
Mark as Favorite
$445,000
Home For Sale

12 Gandy Lane,
Monticello, NY, 12701

Bed 3

Bed

Bath 1

Bath

SqFt1,000

Sqft

Acres0.79

Acre(Lot)

Selling? Save $23,495 when you sell a home like this

Tour with a ByOwner Agent