11 Fostertown Road, Balmville, New York image 1
Active

11 Fostertown Road

Balmville, NY 12550
Mark as Favorite
$2,700,000 $11,383/Mo
Get Pre-Approved Check your credit
Bed 5

Bed

Bath 5

Bath

SqFt4,388

Sqft

Acres25

Acres(Lot)

Tucked behind a long private drive on 25 park-like acres in the storied Balmville neighborhood of the Town of Newburgh, this distinguished 1938 Georgian Colonial stone manor is one of the Hudson Valley’s most remarkable estate offerings. Original architectural plans dated 1937 identify noted Newburgh architect Gordon S. Marvel as architect for William C. Scott, Esq. An extraordinary collection of original drawings and blueprints remains with the property, documenting the residence in remarkable detail and offering a rare connection between the home as conceived and the estate that stands today. The masterfully laid stone facade, slate roof, columned entry portico, and ornamental wrought-iron balcony establish the home’s timeless character. Step through the arched leaded-glass entry into a n impressive yet classic center hall foyer, where wainscoting, crown moldings, hardwood floors, and a sweeping curved staircase showcase the craftsmanship throughout. The formal living room features a carved-mantel fireplace and French doors opening to a 32-foot screened porch, while the formal dining room overlooks the greenhouse garden through a beautiful bay window. The kitchen connects to a butler’s pantry, preserving the home’s original service flow. Upstairs, five generous bedrooms include a primary suite with private bath, dressing room, and Juliet balcony, along with a dedicated home office and four second-floor bathrooms. The lower level is a singular achievement, paneled in hand-carved Gothic-influenced oak and evoking a private English pub, complete with brick fireplace, built-in cabinetry, bar, wine cellar, stone floors, laundry room, powder room, and extensive storage. The nearly 1,600-square-foot third floor, already plumbed for a bath, offers tremendous potential for additional living quarters, studio, or recreation space. Outside, rolling lawns and mature woodland surround a tennis court, stone-paved garden, picturesque waterfall and stream, attached three-car garage, and spectacular greenhouse-conservatory with attached potting room, a true botanical sanctuary steps from the house. Brand-new energy-efficient electric heat pump systems provide modern mechanical performance within a home of irreplaceable historic character. Perhaps most remarkable is the property’s surviving architectural archive. Gordon S. Marvel drawings dating to September 1937 document floor plans, elevations, fireplaces, windows, millwork, and other custom details, while later drawings chronicle the continued evolution of the Scott estate. Preserved with the property for nearly nine decades, the collection provides an uncommon record of its design and craftsmanship. Conveniently located minutes from the Newburgh waterfront, Stewart International Airport, Metro-North at Beacon, and the Hudson Valley’s cultural and recreational destinations—and approximately 75 minutes from New York City—11 Fostertown Road is a legacy property where architecture, landscape, and nearly 90 years of documented history remain remarkably connected.

Read More Expand
Tour with a ByOwner Agent

Detail Ic Property Details

Property Type : Residential

Price : $2,700,000

AD Id : 80296456

MLS Id : 972449

Beds : 5

Lot Size : 25 Acres

Living Area Size : 4,388 Sq. Ft

Tax Amount : $33,174

Year Built : 1938

Garage : 3

County : Orange

  • Map Map

Map

Map What's Nearby

Map Nearby Areas

Feature Features

  • Bedroom Information

    Total beds: 5

    Bathroom Information

    Total Baths: 5 Full Baths: 5

    Room Information

    Rooms Total: 12 Basement: Partially Finished

  • Flooring Information

    Wood

  • Interior Features

    Built-in Features, Chandelier, Crown Molding, Entrance Foyer, High Ceilings, High Speed Internet, Natural Woodwork, Pantry, Recessed Lighting, Storage, Tray Ceiling(s), Walk-In Closet(s) Appliances: Dishwasher, Dryer, Range, Refrigerator, Washer Laundry Features: Laundry Room

  • Heating & Cooling

    Has Heating: Yes Heating: Electric, Heat Pump Has Cooling: Yes Cooling: Central Air

  • Building Information

    Year Built: 1938 Construction Materials: Stone Private Pool: No

  • Lot Information

    Lot Size Acres: 25 Lot Size Square Feet: 1089000

  • Listing Price Information

    Listing Price: $2700000 Original Price: $2900000

  • Tax Information

    Parcel Number: 334600-043-000-0003-017.000-0000 Annual Tax: $33174

  • Parking Information

    Driveway, Off Street

    Garage Information

    Has Garage: Yes Garage Space: 3

  • School Information

    Elementary School: Fostertown Etc Magnet School
    Junior High School: South Middle School
    Senior High School: Newburgh Free Academy

  • Utility Information

    Electricity Connected

  • Location Information

    WaterSource: Private, Well
Sell a home like this and save $161,501 Find out How

How much is this property worth?

Curious about this home's true market value? Use our free Home Evaluation Tool to instantly get a personalized Comparative Market Analysis (CMA) report. Make smarter, data-driven decisions before you buy.

Images
Loading, please wait...

Nearby Home Value

Address Estimate Bed Bath Sq. Ft Lot Size
70 Johnes Street #325E, Newburgh, NY, 12550 $272,000 2 2 1,199 0.01 Acre
79 Ann Street, Newburgh, NY, 12550 $449,000 3 2 2,058 0.05 Acre
13 Liberty Wh Street, Newburgh, NY, 12550 $159,900 3 1 1,888 0.04 Acre
117 Renwick Street, Newburgh, NY, 12550 $250,000 3 1 1,440 0.06 Acre
72 S Lander Street, Newburgh, NY, 12550 $239,000 3 2 1,150 0.02 Acre
19 Forsythe Place, Newburgh, NY, 12550 $460,000 5 2 1,822 0.08 Acre
249 Grand Street, Newburgh, NY, 12550 $1,199,000 3 4 3,740 0.39 Acre
60 Susan Drive, Newburgh, NY, 12550 $987,000 4 3 2,476 1.20 Acres
105 Carson Avenue, Newburgh, NY, 12550 $239,000 3 2 1,535 0.06 Acre
396 Liberty Street, Newburgh, NY, 12550 $329,900 3 1 1,536 0.07 Acre

Similar Homes To 11 Fostertown Road

Nearby For Sale

Slider Thumb
Active
Mark as Favorite
$629,000
Home For Sale

23 Peach Terrace,
Newburgh, NY, 12550

Bed 4

Bed

Bath 2

Bath

SqFt4,020

Sqft

Acres0.86

Acre(Lot)
Slider Thumb
Active
Mark as Favorite
$250,000
Home For Sale

117 Renwick Street,
Newburgh, NY, 12550

Bed 3

Bed

Bath 1

Bath

SqFt1,440

Sqft

Acres0.06

Acre(Lot)
Slider Thumb
Active
Mark as Favorite
$272,000
Home For Sale

70 Johnes Street #325E,
Newburgh, NY, 12550

Bed 2

Bed

Bath 2

Bath

SqFt1,199

Sqft

Acres0.01

Acre(Lot)
Slider Thumb
Active
Mark as Favorite
$1,195,000
Home For Sale

79 Balmville Road,
Newburgh, NY, 12550

Bed 5

Bed

Bath 4

Bath

SqFt4,696

Sqft

Acres3.10

Acres(Lot)
Slider Thumb
Active
Mark as Favorite
$159,900
Home For Sale

13 Liberty Wh Street,
Newburgh, NY, 12550

Bed 3

Bed

Bath 1

Bath

SqFt1,888

Sqft

Acres0.04

Acre(Lot)

The data relating to real estate for sale on this website comes in part from the Internet Data exchange of OneKey MLS. IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Copyright © 2026 OneKey MLS. All Rights Reserved

ByOwner last updated this listing 09/26/2026 @ 14:10

MLS: 972449 LISTED BY: Katherine Sheehan, Compass Greater NY, LLC 845-236-6170 SOURCE: OneKey MLS

More Cities with for Sale by Owner Homes

Homes around $2,700,000

Slider Thumb
Active
Mark as Favorite
$765,000
Home For Sale

47 Willets Way,
Newburgh, NY, 12550

Bed 4

Bed

Bath 4

Bath

SqFt3,275

Sqft

Acres1.10

Acres(Lot)
Slider Thumb
Active
Mark as Favorite
$789,000
Home For Sale

3 Harvey Way,
Newburgh, NY, 12550

Bed 4

Bed

Bath 4

Bath

SqFt3,830

Sqft

Acres2

Acres(Lot)
Slider Thumb
Active
Mark as Favorite
$795,000
Land For Sale

Route 17k,
Newburgh, NY, 12550

Acres28.90

Acres(Lot)
Slider Thumb
Active
Mark as Favorite
$795,000
Home For Sale

19 Firemens Lane,
Newburgh, NY, 12550

Bed 3

Bed

Bath 3

Bath

SqFt2,039

Sqft

Acres2.20

Acres(Lot)
Slider Thumb
Active
Mark as Favorite
$799,000
Home For Sale

19 Stacy Lee Drive,
Newburgh, NY, 12550

Bed 4

Bed

Bath 3

Bath

SqFt3,300

Sqft

Acres0.93

Acre(Lot)
Slider Thumb
Active
Mark as Favorite
$849,000
Multifamily For Sale

98 Grand Street,
Newburgh, NY, 12550

Bed 4

Bed

Bath 4

Bath

Acres0.06

Acre(Lot)
Slider Thumb
Active
Mark as Favorite
$850,000
Multifamily For Sale

197 Grand Street,
Newburgh, NY, 12550

Bed 4

Bed

Bath 3

Bath

Acres0.18

Acre(Lot)
Slider Thumb
Active
Mark as Favorite
$899,000
Home For Sale

60 Susan Drive,
Newburgh, NY, 12550

Bed 4

Bed

Bath 3

Bath

SqFt2,476

Sqft

Acres1.20

Acres(Lot)
Slider Thumb
Active
Mark as Favorite
$949,000
Home For Sale

97 Leslie Road,
Newburgh, NY, 12550

Bed 4

Bed

Bath 4

Bath

SqFt3,770

Sqft

Acres9.30

Acres(Lot)
Slider Thumb
Active
Mark as Favorite
$949,900
Home For Sale

97 Leslie Road,
Newburgh, NY, 12550

Bed 4

Bed

Bath 4

Bath

SqFt3,770

Sqft

Acres9.30

Acres(Lot)
Slider Thumb
Active
Mark as Favorite
$975,000
Land For Sale

Newburgh Cochecton,
Newburgh, NY, 12550

Acres3.50

Acres(Lot)
Slider Thumb
Active
Mark as Favorite
$1,195,000
Home For Sale

79 Balmville Road,
Newburgh, NY, 12550

Bed 5

Bed

Bath 4

Bath

SqFt4,696

Sqft

Acres3.10

Acres(Lot)
Slider Thumb
Active
Mark as Favorite
$1,199,000
Home For Sale

249 Grand Street,
Newburgh, NY, 12550

Bed 3

Bed

Bath 4

Bath

SqFt3,740

Sqft

Acres0.39

Acre(Lot)
Slider Thumb
Active
Mark as Favorite
$1,300,000
Home For Sale

470 Little Britain Road,
Newburgh, NY, 12550

Bed 3

Bed

Bath 3

Bath

SqFt3,155

Sqft

Acres23

Acres(Lot)
Slider Thumb
Active
Mark as Favorite
$1,500,000
Land For Sale

Rte 17k,
Newburgh, NY, 12550

Acres7.90

Acres(Lot)
Slider Thumb
Active
Mark as Favorite
$1,699,000
Home For Sale

36 Sloane Road,
Newburgh, NY, 12550

Bed 4

Bed

Bath 4

Bath

SqFt5,027

Sqft

Acres3

Acres(Lot)
Slider Thumb
Active
Mark as Favorite
$1,699,000
Home For Sale

36 Sloane Road,
Newburgh, NY, 12550

Bed 4

Bed

Bath 4

Bath

SqFt5,027

Sqft

Acres3

Acres(Lot)
Slider Thumb
Active
Mark as Favorite
$3,475,000
Land For Sale

17k And Orr Ave Ave,
Newburgh, NY, 12550

Acres15

Acres(Lot)

Selling? Save $161,501 when you sell a home like this

Tour with a ByOwner Agent