Diamond Lake Island Cabin

This was our second time staying in this cozy cabin. Comfortable beds! Enjoyable outside seat, BBQ, water toys: Kayak & waterboard. We love enjoying the lake view from inside the cabin. You don’t have to have perfect weather to enjoy this cozy cabin.

House and property had everything we needed for a perfect weekend on the water. Would def stay again.

We really enjoyed our stay! This is an old-school cottage with a few upgrades that make it feel comfortable and clean. We loved being right on the water and the availability of kyaks for an additonal fee. We enjoyed swimming here too but water shoes are helpful. This cottage is on an island, which is part of the charm, but make sure you bring everything you need--it's not easy to run to the store. For that reason, it would be nice if they stocked more basics in the kitchen like salt, pepper, oil, creamer and sugar. Good coffee was supplied.

Really enjoyed our stay. House is older but fit our needs perfectly! Host very communicative and we hope to stay again

Absolutely perfect

We enjoyed our time on Diamond lake. Property was clean and stocked with supplies.

Everything was perfect! The only small…comment-not criticizing. The shoreline is a little rocky so my dog couldn’t get in the water and that might be tough for smaller kids. We swam off the end of the pier and the water is sooooo clean. I rented the paddle board and I was very entertaining for all who saw that struggle but it was super fun. We would come back and my cousins plan on a stay here as well. Great neighbors too!!!! Excellent communication the entire time.

Place was great for a weekend with the family! Great location right on the lake

Absolutely perfect weekend getaway!

Wanted to get out of town for a few days; a little “girl time” for me and my daughter, we wanted to do something before I start my new job and she heads back to school. It was the perfect spot. Diamond lake is a hidden gem only 90 min from where we live so, it was just the right amount of “away” without burning a day at airports and such. A quick trip to the grocery store on the way into town and we were set for the weekend. Stacey was easy to contact and there were no hiccups whatsoever! Keep in mind that this particular property is on the island and therefore requires you to get on the car ferry to get across; just about a 5 min cruise. Also, remember that they are on eastern time; we’re from Indiana so we had to factor that in. Bring some floaties or your boat if you have one and enjoy this quaint oasis that has been well cared for for over 80 years by her family. We will make every effort to return next year!

Location was great, neighbors were friendly. We didn’t spend much time indoors. We were always on the lake or the deck. The contact always responded promptly. The dock could use some updating which I think they already have plans of doing that. The shore is super rocky, but if you swim out by the end of the dock it’s great! Will be renting again in the future.