Welcome to Heavenly Hollow! Your Good Dog Friendly Retreat!

This was, hands down, the best VRBO at which we've stayed! The location is perfect, removed enough from the city to feel relaxing, but close enough to make an easy drive into Payson for dinning and shopping. The home was well stocked with everything we needed (and things we didn't even know we needed, ha) for a wonderfully memorable family getaway, and there was plenty of room and space for our 4 adults and 2 kids. It was very kid friendly, and my sons had a blast playing pool, exploring the board games in the bar area, and playing in the cool kids bed cubby. The coffee bar was especially wonderful! Enjoying a fresh cup on the cozy front porch every morning was heaven. Also, we'll definitely bring a telescope next time, because the star gazing was phenomenal, even from just the backyard! Sheila was such an attentive host, quickly responding to any questions and making us feel right at home. Before we even arrived, she provided us with so much helpful info, from home procedures to local activity ideas. Overall, she made our experience so wonderful, and everything was so streamlined and easy. We absolutely plan to make a second trip to Heavenly Hollow, and we look forward to making more memories!

The cabin itself is great—clean, comfortable, and well stocked. It’s in a beautiful area with plenty of space inside and out for relaxing, cooking, and gathering. The kitchen is functional, the backyard and grill are nice, and there’s room for a group to spread out.Check-in was a little rough: the screen door was locked, blocking the keypad, and another door took many tries to open (likely a low battery). Thankfully, Sheila responded quickly and got us sorted.The main issue isn’t the cabin—it’s a neighbor or two who clearly dislike having a rental nearby. They monitor guests closely and report even minor things. We were a responsible group of 10 adults in our 30s and 40s hosting a relatively quiet bachelor weekend. Despite following all house rules and quiet hours, Sheila contacted me multiple times based on complaints about normal activities, like unloading a car (we had 1 car too many for 5 minutes) or talking by the fire at 6 p.m on a Saturday.Sheila was responsive but overly involved at times, and we were even accused of a thing or two by the neighbors that never happened. From Sheila's standpoint, I can see how hearing from the neighbors can be concerning. Knowing the truth from my standpoint, some concerns could be ignored for Sheila's sake. I know that she fields similar compaints about other groups, not just ours. I have sympathy for that.The cabin itself is lovely, but the watchful neighbors and constant check-ins made the stay less relaxing our larger group

We had such a wonderful stay at this cozy mountain cabin! The views were absolutely breathtaking, and the peaceful setting made it the perfect getaway. The cabin was well-stocked, and had everything we needed for a comfortable stay. Sheila, the host was kind, responsive, and made check-in super easy. Highly recommend this spot for anyone looking to relax and recharge in the mountains!

Awesome home tucked away in the hills just outside of downtown Payson. House was clean and had everything we needed. Just the two of us and our dog went on multiple hikes in the surrounding area. Would love to come back in the winter if we could. Host was very helpful and informative. Thank you Sheila and family for letting us stay at your awesome place!

ProsThe home offers beautiful views and strong potential thanks to its location, layout, and large yard. The front deck is a highlight, perfect for enjoying sunsets. Inside, there are two separate living areas—one upstairs and one downstairs—providing flexibility for groups or families. The host was friendly, responsive, and kept the home clean.ConsAccess: Getting into the property was difficult, which added stress when unloading groceries for the week.Dog “Friendly”: Although advertised as dog-friendly, guests are warned that barking could lead to eviction after two complaints—without refund. This felt unfair since the neighborhood has multiple barking dogs and goats along the fence that agitated our pups. The fencing isn’t secure for small breeds, and dogs with protective instincts will struggle. We managed, but limited our time outdoors to avoid upsetting neighbors.Furniture & Maintenance: Aside from the beds, much of the furniture was broken or in poor condition. The coffee maker stopped working on day three, several lightbulbs needed replacing, and there wasn’t enough silverware for more than eight people, despite the home being advertised for twelve.RecapThe property has great potential but would benefit from several improvements:More private and secure fencing for dogsBetter indoor lighting, upstairs and downReplacement/repair of worn furniture and appliancesA fully stocked kitchen to support the advertised occupancy

Host was very responsive and attentive to our needs. It was a Perfect weekend

As a last minute vacation, I was just happy with what I could get! But this cabin was awesome and we were so happy we picked it. The views are amazing and it’s so quiet! The cabin was clean and comfortable— we both napped on the living room couches multiple times! My little dog loved the backyard and she was very impressed with the neighbor’s goats! We will definitely be back!

Perfect little getaway close enough to amenities and nestled enough for outdoor activities and views. We had a great time making home cooked meals and grilling, and hanging around the firepit while watching the goats play, mountain bg, and pups by our side. House was spacious and clean with fully fenced in yard, and our host was so welcoming, organized, and wonderfully responsive.Will visit again!

This is a must stay if you are looking to escape the heat like we were or just taking a weekend mountain getaway. The house is comfortable and clean and is located in a beautiful area that is secluded yet close to Payson and all of the outdoor activities. You couldn’t find a better home base for a mountain vacation!The thing, however, that puts this place over the top is the host Sheila! She is open and communicates daily asking what she can do to make our stay better. I’ve never met a more gracious and attentive host. She thinks of everything and provides all the little amenities to make your stay memorable. She is one of a kind, and honestly, the best host we’ve ever met!The house is family friendly and our kids loved it. They were all sad when we had to leave, but we reassured them that we would come back for sure!

We loved Heavenly Hollow and highly recommend it to everyone. We are headed back in June!