Charming 1BR • Pinecraft Vibes, Beach Nearby

Bright and inviting 1BR/1BA cottage in peaceful Pinecraft, Sarasota’s Amish village. Now under new ownership with exciting upgrades and improved amenities on the way. Sleeps 4 with queen bed + futon. Features a compact kitchen with fridge, microwave, kitchenware, coffee maker, and essentials. Walk to Amish restaurants, produce markets, ice cream shops, and more. Just minutes to world-class beaches and downtown Sarasota.

Welcome to Your Stay Near Sarasota`s Amish Heart

Step into Casa Orange – a cozy and cheerful 1BR/1BA cottage located in the heart of Sarasota’s Amish and Mennonite community of Pinecraft. Now under new ownership, this home is entering an exciting refresh phase with planned upgrades, improved amenities, and elevated guest comforts — all designed to create a more memorable experience for travelers.

With its walkable location, peaceful surroundings, and central proximity to Gulf beaches and downtown Sarasota, Casa Orange is ideal for couples, solo travelers, or small families seeking a relaxing escape with local flavor.

✨ The Space

Casa Orange balances comfort and simplicity in a compact, efficient layout:

1 Bedroom: Queen bed with fresh, hotel-style linens

Living Area: Sofa or futon for additional guest(s)

Kitchen: Includes a refrigerator, microwave, stove/oven and counter space for light meal prep

Fully Stocked: Cookware, dinnerware, coffee maker, hair dryer, and iron

Starter Supplies: Paper towels, dish soap, sponge, trash bags, and toilet paper provided for your first few days

Guests also have access to shared on-site laundry, two private entrances, and driveway parking for one vehicle, with street parking available for additional cars.

Multi-Unit Property

Casa Orange is one of four private 1–2 bedroom cottages at this address (alongside Casa Grapefruit, Casa Lemon, and Casa Lime), each with its own entrance. Outdoor areas and laundry are shared, making it ideal for families or friend groups looking to rent multiple units while enjoying their own space.

Personalized Hosting Experience

You`ll be supported by a local co-host (that`s me, Jennifer!) who’s here to answer questions, provide real-time recommendations, and make sure your stay goes smoothly — whether it’s helping you find the best beach access, farmer’s market, or local cafe.

Location Highlights

Located in the beloved neighborhood of Pinecraft, you`re walking distance to:

Yoder’s Restaurant & Amish Village shops

Produce markets, bakeries, and hand-churned ice cream

Pinecraft Park & shaded walking trails

And just minutes from:

Siesta Key Beach – ~15 min

Lido Key & St. Armands Circle – ~15 min

Downtown Sarasota – ~10 min

The Ringling Museum – ~15 min

Marie Selby Botanical Gardens – ~12 min

Casa Orange offers a warm, thoughtful, and well-placed retreat in Pinecraft — the perfect balance of village charm and Sarasota access. We look forward to hosting you!

Casa Orange is a ground-level stand alone cottage with its own private entrance. Guests have access to the property and their unit. They may park one vehicle in the shared driveway; please be sure not to block entrances, as cars may need to be moved to allow access for others. Additional vehicles may be parked on the street, where there is ample free parking.

This home is proudly co-hosted by HomeIngo, founded by Jennifer, a Sarasota local with 18+ years in the area and 6 years of hosting experience. Guests enjoy personalized support, and insider tips. Jennifer and her team are nearby and happy to help ensure your stay is seamless, comfortable, and unforgettable.

Neighborhood Vibe

Casa Orange is nestled in the heart of Pinecraft, Sarasota’s historic Amish and Mennonite community. Guests love strolling to local restaurants, produce markets, pizza shops, and ice cream parlors. The neighborhood is peaceful and family-friendly — the perfect place to unwind. While we want all guests to enjoy their stay, this is not a party house. Please keep noise low and respect the community’s quiet nature.
Sarasota enforces towing for cars that block driveways or mailboxes. We kindly ask that all guests park with courtesy so everyone — including neighbors — can come and go easily. Guests also have access to shared on-site laundry facilities.

Please do not block walkways or other units with bicycles.

Smoking is not allowed in any of the units. Smell or other evidence will incur a $500 fee.