75 S Penataquit Avenue, Bay Shore, New York image 1
Active

75 S Penataquit Avenue

Bay Shore, NY 11706
Mark as Favorite
$1,699,999 $7,167/Mo
Get Pre-Approved Check your credit
Bed 6

Bed

Bath 4

Bath

SqFt3,617

Sqft

Acres0.94

Acre(Lot)

Lovingly restored and thoughtfully enhanced by its current owners, this remarkable 1880 residence reflects years of careful stewardship And substantial investment. Every update was made to elevate everyday living while honoring the home's character and architectural integrity. Updates: 2021 : New Siding & Windows, New PVC & Aluminum Fencing. Leaf Filter on All Gutters 2021/2022 : Basement waterproofed ( Lifetime guarantee ) 2021/2022 : Pool heater & Filter 2022 : New Split Units 2023: Generator, 15 zone Sprinklers, Alarm system with 11 Cameras hooked up to Central Station, Doors 2024: New Kitchen & Appliances, Motorized Shades in Living Room 2025: New driveway, New walkway and Stoops 2026: 2.5 New Bathrooms, with Soaker tub on 2nd floor and wonderful shower on third floor 2026: Newly sealed bricks around pool and back walkway.

Read More Expand

Detail Ic Property Details

Property Type : Residential

Price : $1,699,999

AD Id : 89406540

MLS Id : 1030549

Beds : 6

Lot Size : 0.94 Acre

Living Area Size : 3,617

Year Built : 1880

Garage : 2

County : Suffolk

  • Map Map

Map

Map What's Nearby

Map Nearby Areas

Feature Features

  • Bedroom Information

    Total beds: 6

    Bathroom Information

    Total Baths: 4 Full Baths: 3 Half Baths: 1

    Room Information

    Rooms Total: 10 Basement: Unfinished

  • Flooring Information

    Combination, Hardwood

  • Interior Features

    Double Vanity, Eat-in Kitchen, Kitchen Island, Recessed Lighting, Storage Appliances: Dishwasher, Dryer, Oven, Refrigerator, Stainless Steel Appliance(s), Washer

  • Heating & Cooling

    Has Heating: Yes Heating: Natural Gas Has Cooling: Yes Cooling: Ductless

  • Building Information

    Year Built: 1880 Building Area Total: 4840 Construction Materials: Frame Pool Features: In Ground, Private Private Pool: Yes

  • Exterior Features

    Exterior Features: Garden, Lighting, Playground, Rain Gutters

  • Lot Information

    Lot Size Acres: 0.94 Lot Size Square Feet: 40946

  • Listing Price Information

    Listing Price: $1699999

  • Tax Information

    Parcel Number: 0500-394-00-02-00-021-000 Annual Tax: $22403.16

  • Parking Information

    Detached, Driveway

    Garage Information

    Has Garage: Yes Garage Space: 2

  • School Information

    Elementary School: Brook Avenue Elementary School
    Junior High School: Bay Shore Middle School
    Senior High School: Bay Shore Senior High School

  • Utility Information

    Natural Gas Available, Cable Available, Electricity Available, Natural Gas Connected

  • Location Information

    WaterSource: Public
Sell a home like this and save $101,501 Find out How

How much is this property worth?

Curious about this home's true market value? Use our free Home Evaluation Tool to instantly get a personalized Comparative Market Analysis (CMA) report. Make smarter, data-driven decisions before you buy.

Images
Loading, please wait...

Nearby Home Value

Address Estimate Bed Bath Sq. Ft Lot Size
12 Mallar Avenue, Bay Shore, NY, 11706 $649,000 4 2 1,300 1,300 SqFt
108 Awixa Avenue, Bay Shore, NY, 11706 $1,300,000 6 5 2,854 2,854 SqFt
100 Awixa Avenue, Bay Shore, NY, 11706 $3,350,000 5 5 6,342 6,342 SqFt
1333 Boston Avenue, Bay Shore, NY, 11706 $719,000 3 3 1,596 1,596 SqFt
45 S Penataquit Avenue, Bay Shore, NY, 11706 $2,200,000 10 7 8,783 8,783 SqFt
35 S Penataquit Avenue, Bay Shore, NY, 11706 $1,875,000 9 5 5,646 5,646 SqFt
6 Montgomery Lane, Bay Shore, NY, 11706 $1,099,999 3 3 2,200 2,200 SqFt
19 Chapman Place, Bay Shore, NY, 11706 $600,000 3 1 1,056 1,056 SqFt
48 Ellen Street, Bay Shore, NY, 11706 $699,999 4 2 1,176 1,176 SqFt
2 Burnett Avenue, Bay Shore, NY, 11706 $738,000 3 3 1,746 1,746 SqFt

Similar Homes To 75 S Penataquit Avenue

Nearby For Sale

Slider Thumb
Active
Mark as Favorite
$599,000
Home For Sale

1097 Carll Drive,
Bay Shore, NY, 11706

Bed 3

Bed

Bath 1

Bath

SqFt1,132

Sqft

Acres0.17

Acre(Lot)
Slider Thumb
Active
Mark as Favorite
$1,300,000
Home For Sale

108 Awixa Avenue,
Bay Shore, NY, 11706

Bed 6

Bed

Bath 5

Bath

SqFt2,854

Sqft

Acres0.57

Acre(Lot)
Slider Thumb
Active
Mark as Favorite
$738,000
Home For Sale

2 Burnett Avenue,
Bay Shore, NY, 11706

Bed 3

Bed

Bath 3

Bath

SqFt1,746

Sqft

Acres0.14

Acre(Lot)
Slider Thumb
Active
Mark as Favorite
$665,000
Mobile Homes For Sale

1081 Bay Shore Avenue,
Bay Shore, NY, 11706

Bed 5

Bed

Bath 2

Bath

SqFt1,950

Sqft

Acres0.30

Acre(Lot)
Slider Thumb
Active
Mark as Favorite
$3,350,000
Home For Sale

100 Awixa Avenue,
Bay Shore, NY, 11706

Bed 5

Bed

Bath 5

Bath

SqFt6,342

Sqft

Acres1.35

Acres(Lot)

The data relating to real estate for sale on this website comes in part from the Internet Data exchange of OneKey MLS. IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Copyright © 2026 OneKey MLS. All Rights Reserved

ByOwner last updated this listing 08/16/2026 @ 12:17

MLS: 1030549 LISTED BY: Maralyn CBR, Douglas Elliman Real Estate 516-681-2600 SOURCE: OneKey MLS

More Cities with for Sale by Owner Homes

Homes around $1,699,999

Slider Thumb
Active
Mark as Favorite
$859,000
Home For Sale

58 Oakridge Drive,
Bay Shore, NY, 11706

Bed 6

Bed

Bath 3

Bath

SqFt2,434

Sqft

Acres0.26

Acre(Lot)
Slider Thumb
Active
Mark as Favorite
$899,000
Home For Sale

1641 E 3rd Avenue,
Bay Shore, NY, 11706

Bed 5

Bed

Bath 4

Bath

SqFt2,577

Sqft

Acres0.45

Acre(Lot)
Slider Thumb
Active
Mark as Favorite
$899,900
Home For Sale

70 Massachusetts Avenue,
Bay Shore, NY, 11706

Bed 6

Bed

Bath 5

Bath

SqFt2,551

Sqft

Acres1.07

Acres(Lot)
Slider Thumb
Active
Mark as Favorite
$925,000
Condo For Sale

93 Boathouse Lane,
Bay Shore, NY, 11706

Bed 2

Bed

Bath 3

Bath

SqFt2,286

Sqft

Acres0.08

Acre(Lot)
Slider Thumb
Active
Mark as Favorite
$949,990
Home For Sale

19 Joan Road,
Bay Shore, NY, 11706

Bed 4

Bed

Bath 5

Bath

SqFt2,840

Sqft

Acres0.25

Acre(Lot)
Slider Thumb
Active
Mark as Favorite
$999,000
Land For Sale

100A Awixa Avenue,
Bay Shore, NY, 11706

Acres1.35

Acres(Lot)
Slider Thumb
Active
Mark as Favorite
$999,999
Home For Sale

57 Girard Avenue,
Bay Shore, NY, 11706

Bed 4

Bed

Bath 2

Bath

SqFt2,759

Sqft

Acres0.21

Acre(Lot)
Slider Thumb
Active
Mark as Favorite
$1,099,999
Home For Sale

6 Montgomery Lane,
Bay Shore, NY, 11706

Bed 3

Bed

Bath 3

Bath

SqFt2,200

Sqft

Acres0.46

Acre(Lot)
Slider Thumb
Active
Mark as Favorite
$1,200,000
Home For Sale

121 Bayway Avenue,
Bay Shore, NY, 11706

Bed 4

Bed

Bath 3

Bath

SqFt2,904

Sqft

Acres0.29

Acre(Lot)
Slider Thumb
Active
Mark as Favorite
$1,300,000
Home For Sale

108 Awixa Avenue,
Bay Shore, NY, 11706

Bed 6

Bed

Bath 5

Bath

SqFt2,854

Sqft

Acres0.57

Acre(Lot)
Slider Thumb
Active
Mark as Favorite
$1,500,000
Condo For Sale

202 Captains Way,
Bay Shore, NY, 11706

Bed 2

Bed

Bath 2

Bath

SqFt1,796

Sqft

Acres0.10

Acre(Lot)
Slider Thumb
Active
Mark as Favorite
$1,600,000
Land For Sale

LOT 5 Overlea Court,
Bay Shore, NY, 11706

Acres0.75

Acre(Lot)
Slider Thumb
Active
Mark as Favorite
$1,788,000
Home For Sale

16 S Montgomery Avenue,
Bay Shore, NY, 11706

Bed 5

Bed

Bath 6

Bath

SqFt4,500

Sqft

Acres0.44

Acre(Lot)
Slider Thumb
Active
Mark as Favorite
$1,800,000
Land For Sale

LOT 6 Overlea Court,
Bay Shore, NY, 11706

Acres1.24

Acres(Lot)
Slider Thumb
Active
Mark as Favorite
$1,875,000
Home For Sale

35 S Penataquit Avenue,
Bay Shore, NY, 11706

Bed 9

Bed

Bath 5

Bath

SqFt5,646

Sqft

Acres1.40

Acres(Lot)
Slider Thumb
Active
Mark as Favorite
$2,000,000
Multifamily For Sale

64 Mowbray Avenue,
Bay Shore, NY, 11706

Acres0.58

Acre(Lot)
Slider Thumb
Active
Mark as Favorite
$2,100,000
Land For Sale

LOT 4 AND LOT 11 Overle..,
Bay Shore, NY, 11706

Acres1.19

Acres(Lot)
Slider Thumb
Active
Mark as Favorite
$2,200,000
Home For Sale

45 S Penataquit Avenue,
Bay Shore, NY, 11706

Bed 10

Bed

Bath 7

Bath

SqFt8,783

Sqft

Acres1.64

Acres(Lot)

Selling? Save $101,501 when you sell a home like this

Tour with a ByOwner Agent